will-henney / globule-seminario

Evaporating globules in photoionized nebulae
0 stars 0 forks source link

Estimate ionized density of photoevaporation flow from LDN 1616 #2

Open will-henney opened 1 year ago

will-henney commented 1 year ago

Once we know the ionizing flux that is incident on the globule, then we can estimate the ionized density by balancing the photon flux against two terms: the advection of new atoms through the ionization front, plus the recombinations in the ionized flow

CleanShot 2023-02-02 at 17 40 48@2x

The effective thickness, h, can be assumed to be roughly 0.1 times the globule radius.

For the recombination coefficient, use 2.3e-13 cm^3 / s

For the gas velocity, use 10 km/s

will-henney commented 1 year ago

The next step will then be to calculate the predicted H alpha surface brightness.

RobeReyes commented 1 year ago

We can compute the ionized density by balancing the photon flux using two terms: the advection of new atoms through the ionization front, $n_0 u0$, and the re-combinations in the ionized flow, $\int{r0}n^{2} \alpha{\beta} dr=n0^2 h \alpha{\beta}$. So we use $F_0=n_0 u_0 + n0^2 h \alpha\beta$ to compute the ionized density $n_0$, where $u_0$ is the gas velocity, we use $10 km/s$, $h$ is the effective thickness, we take $h=0.1r_0$ where $r0$ is the globule radius that we compute, and $\alpha\beta$ is the re-combination coefficient, we use $2.3\times 10^{-13} cm^3/s$, so we have

h = 0.1 * globule_radius.to('cm') #The effective thickness
alpha_beta = 2.3E-13 * u.cm**3 / (u.second) #The recombination coefficient
u_0 = 10 * u.kilometer / (u.second) #The gas velocity
cm_s = u.cm / u.second #convert the gas velocity to cgs
F_0 = flux_io_eps_ori_cms
a = h*alpha_beta
b = u_0.to(cm_s)
c = -F_0
n_0 = (-b+(b**2-(4*a*c))**(1/2))/(2*a)

To compute the ionized density we resolved our quadratic function $n0^2(h\alpha\beta)+n_0(u_0)-F_0=0$ and we take only the positive solution, so the solution $n_0=\frac{-u_0+\sqrt{u0^2+4h\alpha\beta F0}}{2h\alpha\beta}$ is

9.3998478 cm^{-3}

If we only take the advection term then the ionized density is $n_0=\frac{F_0}{u_0}$ and we have

F_0/(u_0.to(cm_s))

17.805235 cm^{-3}

similarly if we only take the re-combinations in the ionized flow then the ionized density is $n_0=\sqrt{\frac{F0}{h\alpha\beta}}$ and we have

(F_0/(h*alpha_beta))**(1/2)

13.680936 cm^{-3}
will-henney commented 1 year ago

After looking at H alpha emission, we have decide that a globule radius of 0.2 degrees would be more appropriate.

@RobeReyes please recalculate the density using this new radius, and also correcting the factor of 2 that was missing from your calculation in #1