will-henney / globule-seminario

Evaporating globules in photoionized nebulae
0 stars 0 forks source link

Estimate the emission measure and the ionized density from H alpha brightness of LDN 1616 #4

Open will-henney opened 1 year ago

will-henney commented 1 year ago

Using the brightness measured in #3 we can calculate the emission measure of the ionized gas at the surface of the globule:

CleanShot 2023-02-07 at 13 31 35@2x

For this, we will need the following steps:

After that, we can convert it to a density, assuming $n_0^2 r_0 \approx \mathrm{EM}$

will-henney commented 1 year ago

This is how we convert from Rayleighs to emission measure:

CleanShot 2023-02-09 at 16 47 46@2x

We use the definition of Rayleigh from Wikipedia, but converted to cgs

CleanShot 2023-02-09 at 16 48 25@2x

We also use an effective H alpha recombination rate of 1.17e-13, which is the value given in the Draine textbook for a temperature of 10,000 K

The final result is EM = 2.76 times the surface brightness in Rayleighs, where EM is in units of pc per cm^6

will-henney commented 1 year ago

The temperature dependence of the factor 2.76 is approximately linear. For instance, at a temperature of 8000 K, it would be 2.2

We should use 2.2 for the conversion factor, since a lower temperature is more realistic.

For comparison, Finkbeiner gave a number that implies 2.56 for this factor

Also, Pon et al (2014) have the following: CleanShot 2023-02-09 at 17 07 07@2x

So, all these estimates are in agreement to within about 10%

will-henney commented 1 year ago

@RobeReyes please repeat the calculation of the density to document it here. We can assume that the line of sight depth is related to the globule radius as $\ell = (2 / \sqrt{10}) r_0$.

Then use the fact that $\mathrm{EM} = n_0^2 \ell$

RobeReyes commented 1 year ago

For the density we have that $n_0=\sqrt{\frac{EM}{l}}$ and if we suppose a brightness of 30, we have that $n_0=\sqrt{\frac{2.76 I/Ry}{(2/\sqrt{10})r_0}}\approx 9.88 cm^{-3}$