willaguiar / DSW-collaborative-project

0 stars 0 forks source link

Why does CM2atm forcing increases DSW formation? #27

Open willaguiar opened 10 months ago

willaguiar commented 10 months ago

We have noticed that using the CM2atm forcing on OM2 increases the DSW formation. This issue is to discuss possible reasons why.

Overview of the issue below


Comparing the shelf SWMT between the control 21mbath , and CM2atm , we can see that CM2atm has increased transformation of waters across the 28 sigma0 value, i.e., we have more waters becoming denser than 28 kg/m3 when forcing OM2 with CM2atm.

SWMTshelf_21mbath_sigma0_total SWMTshelf_CM2atm_sigma0_total

This DSW signal gets even stronger when checking the volume transport across the 1km isobath. See the ~2 SV increase volume transport of waters with sigma0=>27.84 for example. For reference, waters below 4000m in OM2 in the Southern Ocean (i.e., AABW) seem to have sigma0=>27.84.

CSMT_21mbath_sigma0_1000m CSMT_CM2atm_sigma0_1000m

willaguiar commented 10 months ago

Shelf WMT by sector


We can see that most of the shelf SWMT changes happens in the Weddell Sea, where the WMT curve moves to denser values. SWMTsector_division SWMTsimulations_comp_by_sector_sigma0_total Most of this change in Weddell WMT is driven by salinity changes: SWMTsimulations_comp_by_sector_HEATandSALT_sigma0_total Looking to shelf properties during the winter , WS=Weddell Sea


We can see in the Age at the bottom anomalies [a] that CM2atm has stronger DSW export to the abyss in the WS than in the ctrl case (21mbath) ([a] is the only plot here that is not the winter average, but the values for the last month of the simulation). The WS shelf also has higher salinities in CM2atm, both in the bottom [b] and surface [c] .

In [d] we have the freshwater fluxes from sea ice growth/melt, and the yellow line is the contour of 0.2 salinity anomaly from [c]. We can see that, when compared to the ctrl, more water exits the ocean in the inner WS in CM2atm. These negative anomalies in freshwater flux match the contour of high surface salinity anomalies suggesting that the stronger freshwater outflow is causing the WS inner shelf to increase salinity. This increase salinity/increased freshwater outflow region matches the region with increased ice growth seen in [e]. Shelf ATM and sea ice changes during winter


Here are a few options of what could be causing this change in WS.

OPTION 1: When looking at Tau_x on the control case [a] we can see there is some convergence between eastward stress in the Antarctic Peninsula (red box) and Westward stress in inner/west WS (blue box). Looking at the anomalies in tau_x in [b] we see that this convergence is decreased. This decreased convergence could make sea ice thinner in the WS ( and that can be seen in ice volume anomalies in [e]). Thinner winter sea ice due to weaker convergence would allow more ocean-atm heat exchange during winter, fostering local sea ice formation (i.e., brine rejection, freshwater outflow) and therefore increasing salinities on the shelf.

OPTION 2: Comparing winter Tau_y between the Ctrl [c] and CM2atm simulations [d] we can see there is a small region on the eastern WS where TAU_y is reversed from Southward to northward. Perhaps this new Northward transport is continuously displacing sea ice to the North on the eastern WS, increasing polynya size and DSW formation locally.

Sea_ice_tau

Let me know if you see something I'm missing here. important info: water flux from sea ice plot used the melt variable. I'm not 100% sure if that is the correct variable to use (can someone confirm?) Full images, control fields and plots with 5mdz can be found here

adele-morrison commented 10 months ago

The 'melt' diagnostic is garbage. I reckon we should stop outputting this in all ACCESS-OM2 runs because it's confusingly labelled. You need to use 'wfiform' + 'wfimelt' to get the net FW flux from sea ice.

On Thu, 21 Sept 2023 at 12:56, Wilton Aguiar @.***> wrote:

Shelf WMT by sector

We can see that most of the shelf SWMT changes happens in the Weddell Sea, where the WMT curve moves to denser values. [image: SWMTsector_division] https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/70033934/269456999-32391e45-4639-42c6-8b26-73dc46aa6f74.png [image: SWMTsimulations_comp_by_sector_sigma0_total] https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/70033934/269457017-01f6125b-63ce-4a8d-bc93-e69715c6cf08.png Most of this change in Weddell WMT is driven by salinity changes: [image: SWMTsimulations_comp_by_sector_HEATandSALT_sigma0_total] https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/70033934/269463659-432e7d1a-da79-44e8-a53a-484fa9bd4308.png Looking to shelf properties during the winter , WS=Weddell Sea

We can see in the Age at the bottom anomalies [a] that CM2atm has stronger DSW export to the abyss in the WS than in the ctrl case ( 21mbath) ([a] is the only plot here that is not the winter average, but the values for the last month of the simulation). The WS shelf also has higher salinities in CM2atm, both in the bottom [b] and surface [c] .

In [d] we have the freshwater fluxes from sea ice growth/melt, and the yellow line is the contour of 0.2 salinity anomaly from [c]. We can see that, when compared to the ctrl, more water exits the ocean in the inner WS in CM2atm. These negative anomalies in freshwater flux match the contour of high surface salinity anomalies suggesting that the stronger freshwater outflow is causing the WS inner shelf to increase salinity. This increase salinity/increased freshwater outflow region matches the region with increased ice growth seen in [e]. [image: Shelf] https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/70033934/269466643-f404d2c6-8c08-4b0c-ad53-69869b789327.png ATM and sea ice changes during winter

Here are a few options of what could be causing this change in WS.

OPTION 1: When looking at Tau_x on the control case [a] we can see there is some convergence between eastward stress in the Antarctic Peninsula (red box) and Westward stress in inner/west WS (blue box). Looking at the anomalies in tau_x in [b] we see that this convergence is decreased. This decreased convergence could make sea ice thinner in the WS ( and that can be seen in ice volume anomalies in [e]). Thinner winter sea ice due to weaker convergence would allow more ocean-atm heat exchange during winter, fostering local sea ice formation (i.e., brine rejection, freshwater outflow) and therefore increasing salinities on the shelf.

OPTION 2: Comparing winter Tau_y between the Ctrl [c] and CM2atm simulations [d] we can see there is a small region on the eastern WS where TAU_y is reversed from Southward to northward. Perhaps this new Northward transport is continuously displacing sea ice to the North on the eastern WS, increasing polynya size and DSW formation locally.

[image: Sea_ice_tau] https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/70033934/269469433-e267c877-a820-4e16-a402-ae3e65f04bc1.png

Let me know if you see something I'm missing here. important info: water flux from sea ice plot used the melt variable. I'm not 100% sure if that is the correct variable to use (can someone confirm?)

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/willaguiar/DSW-collaborative-project/issues/27#issuecomment-1728692745, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ACA44UYQ6UZ67YIC6EGF4NTX3OUGLANCNFSM6AAAAAA5AY7FWE . You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.Message ID: @.***>

willaguiar commented 10 months ago

Thanks Adele. Below is the new plot with 'wfiform' + 'wfimelt' (top is JJA mean for the last year in 21mbath, bottom left is anomaly as in CM2atm - 21mbath. Values >0 indicates freshwater entering the ocean. All is negative in the control because of sea ice formation in the winter. This var shows an even stronger amount of FW leaving the shelf in the inner WS (matching the 0.2 PSU salinity contour).

FW_from_Seaice_ontheshelf-2