willschulz / bad-influence

Video discussion experiments to counter pathological influence in political discussions
0 stars 0 forks source link

Consider rewording the "strike an adult male" question. #26

Open JamesPHoughton opened 1 year ago

JamesPHoughton commented 1 year ago

In my discussion, one of the participants interpreted the question about whether it was ever appropriate for a police officer to strike an adult male as being explicitly in lieu of shooting, or using other physical violence. This raises the prospect that some participants are interpreting this question as an appropriate escalation of force, and others are considering it a potential deescalation compared to a baseline of more lethal force.

Do we want to adjust the question?

xehu commented 1 year ago

Was this one of the ANES questions / do we actually have wiggle room to adjust the question?

If we do, we can just add a clarification --- "strike (e.g., using a weapon or one's body) an adult male"