winds-mobi / winds-mobi-providers

Real-time weather observations: weather data providers
https://winds.mobi
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
8 stars 12 forks source link

gxaircom.net seems to be broken #73

Closed MichalBryxi closed 1 year ago

MichalBryxi commented 1 year ago

photo_2023-08-02 16 57 48 photo_2023-08-02 16 57 51

ysavary commented 1 year ago

Thanks, I also noticed it.

@gereic Do you know the status of the gxaircom stations? It looks that some stations are very near to other providers but updated less often?

I'm working on a new API feature that will return only the best stations when several stations are at the same place.

gereic commented 1 year ago

@ysavary I'm sorry. I was testing to bring some stations to windy with an OGN-Interface. All Windline-stations where imported and I saw that windline already sends it stations to winds.mobi.

Can you please delete all GxAircomstations beginning with begins with 05 ?

Thank you.

ysavary commented 1 year ago

Hi @gereic,

I deleted the gxaircom stations starting with 05.

But it looks like that gxaircom republishes data from providers meteoswiss and holfuy too. In the republished data, the gxaircom timestamp does not match the data timestamp published by the provider as shown in the screenshots below. Moreover, it's weird, because it appears that the wind values are slightly modified.

Meteoswiss interlaken at 9h53: Screenshot 2023-08-08 at 09 53 15

Holfuy interlaken: Screenshot 2023-08-08 at 09 29 51

MichalBryxi commented 1 year ago

From the area of my interest I still have one duplicate:

Screenshot 2023-08-08 at 14 50 04

The name "Höhematte holfuy" seems a bit meh as it seems like the provider just appended their name behind the name of the location for some reason.

gereic commented 1 year ago

@ysavary you are right. Can you delete the gxaircom-stations which starts with FC ? Thanks. Is it ok, to forward skytraxx and burnair-stations from OGN ?

ysavary commented 1 year ago

@gereic

Is it ok, to forward skytraxx and burnair-stations from OGN

Yes, it would be awesome to have new stations in winds.mobi!

Burnair is already consuming winds.mobi api. I assume they repost the winds.mobi data on the FANET+ network, but not having a skytraxx myself, I'm not sure what they do with the winds.mobi data.

What are skytraxx and burnair stations?

ysavary commented 1 year ago

@MichalBryxi

"Dead: Höhematte - windline.ch" and "Alive: Höhematte holfuy - holfuy.com" are not really duplicate stations in the sense that they are 2 different stations and not exactly in the same place.

The name "Höhematte holfuy" was set by the admin of this holfuy station. Winds.mobi uses the name of the station of the provider when it exists. This station was registered in holfuy.com by https://vkpi.ch. chilloutparagliding.com recently contacted me about this station. You should contact them if you would like to discuss the name they put.

MichalBryxi commented 1 year ago

@ysavary cool, thanks for explanation.

The dead "Höhematte - windline.ch" really seems dead. I'm not sure what the cause might be and if I should annoy windline to fix it? Or if that is physically damaged device ... in which case not sure who can fix it?

Sorry if that's not your business, I will also try to contact chillout as they do a lot around here. Trying to make the map around here readable again :)

MichalBryxi commented 1 year ago

Ok, maybe one more to this topic to cover all the cases of gxaircom I can see. Just scrolled up and noticed that "Hohwald" still exists from gxaircom.net (and is dead). The arrows are not exactly overlapping, but I don't think those will be two physically different stations. Can check it in person later if you want.

Screenshot 2023-08-10 at 07 21 39

MichalBryxi commented 1 year ago

Ok so few updates:

Höhematte

Turns out there is a person behind the currently defunct station at Höhematte and from what he wrote that one should eventually be working again:

if he means the gxaircom.net stations, i have no influence there. there is only howald at the moment. double. höhenmatte will have two working ones, one of them is in repair.

So I guess this "extra" Höhematte station is actually ok.

Hohwald

Got visual confirmation from a friend that went to Hohwald today that there is only one weather station there.

From the previous conversation on this ticket it seems like you deleted some old instances from the gxaricom.net source. I don't understand what their page is saying, but I can't find Hohwald there anymore.

So to me it seems like "Hohwald from gxaircom.net" can be deleted?

gereic commented 1 year ago

On the page, you have a list of all stations, which gxaircom gets. Hohwald was deleted, but maybe it is still in the database of winds.mobi

gereic commented 1 year ago

As far as I know, if there are no station-data for more then 60days, it will be automatically deleted from winds.mobi

MichalBryxi commented 1 year ago

Oh cool. So the that's settled for all my cases. Should we close this ticket and I will finally stop bothering you? :)