witch-house / pronoun.is

Show people how to use pronouns!
http://pronoun.is
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
929 stars 102 forks source link

Second singular person problem #107

Open grinapo opened 4 years ago

grinapo commented 4 years ago

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. I am non native English speaker. I also haven't heard these pronouns. So I meet them and have to learn how to use them. Useful site.

Problem example sentence:

And the problem is:

or

Second singular usage is not observable in your examples, and it is probably one of the most frequent uses.

Describe the solution you'd like Well, it's a problem if you don't have a field about forced plurality; but generally requires a new example sentence and a forced plurality check.

Describe alternatives you've considered Not caring about the problem. ;-)

Additional context This page is referenced from lots of places, but if one has no prior knowledge of this language feature it's not providing all the info needed for everyday use.

clarfonthey commented 4 years ago

In English, "they go" is always the way it's said. The singular they is always treated the same as plural they for conjugating verbs.

grinapo commented 4 years ago

As I said: this form is not known here around (and possibly Europe) so if you don't tell us "it's always treated as" then we won't know. The point is whether you want to educate people about their usage or don't (asking that from people speaking English as second, and in one case even first languaguage) resulted mixed answers, so I'd say it's not obvious for everyone.

I am at the "never heard of that, and people have linked your page as an explanation about its usage" end of the pipe.

But you can close this issue if you think it's not justified. Thanks for your time.

frei0 commented 4 years ago

It would be nice to have example conjugations and contractions with auxiliary verbs like "to be" and "to have". Like "xe's".

colinphill-reify commented 2 years ago

+1 to this. I recently looked up a set of pronouns I was unfamiliar with, xey/xem, to try to figure out whether to use plural verbs as I would with they/them. The examples simply don't demonstrate that.

One simple change that may meet this need is to use the present tense in one or more of the sentences. "Xey went to the park" leaves grammatical number ambiguous, but "Xey is going to the park" does not.