A few things from my experience in working with the witchtools package:
I think it would be really important to have a way in which new users can easily edit their files locally of the whole witch-* framework without having always to use github, ie using witch-data and witchtools in the local folder
Given it is an independent package would be good to make it work also based on a completely new witch-mode/input and witch-data folder. However, as of now it doesn't work: If I create all the files (ie run translate_witch_data), and then switch to witch-data method on an empty folder, and just rerun the script it gives a few errors: (Yet in my opinion, this should work without errors).
-1) ssp data not found (OK I assume because of the weights).
-2) "database connection not found" not sure which one (globiom? primap for emission weights?).
I think the weights we should or embed them in the package or make them by default use piggyback so it will work with a completely new data folder for other models etc.
Anyhow we should discuss in a witch strategic meeting!
About not using witchtools without github. This is very easy with rstudio, in fact this is how I work and develop. I can teach how to do it and you will see how much this is great and easy! (then you can develop new R packages ;) )
the witch-data in local is working for me but probably needs more testing (let's add some automatic test for this)
Independent package, sure. This is in my agenda. Next step was exactly to put weights in the packages. We might create a tasklist so everybody knows where it goes and can also contribute.
A few things from my experience in working with the witchtools package:
I think the weights we should or embed them in the package or make them by default use piggyback so it will work with a completely new data folder for other models etc.
Anyhow we should discuss in a witch strategic meeting!