withfig / fig

Public issue tracker for Fig.
https://fig.io
MIT License
2.04k stars 54 forks source link

Sunset #2934

Open levino opened 3 months ago

levino commented 3 months ago

I am sad to hear that fig is sunsetting. However I am wondering, since this is supposed to be an open source project and is under the MIT license, why it does not just continue as a community project? Is nobody willing to take over as a maintainer? Is the provisioning of expensive server resources necessary to enable fig?

SupianIDz commented 3 months ago

By removing the Plugin, Dotfiles, and Server features, I see this as a step backwards. Users are only being offered AI, which doesn't benefit those who heavily rely on dotfiles, servers, and plugins.

levino commented 3 months ago

I also really do not like the idea of all my prompts being sent to amazon. But that is another story. I do not want to criticise the new product. I hope that I can use fig also in the future. What kind of server infrastructure is needed? Can this requirement be removed without breaking fig?

anthonyhexium commented 3 months ago

That's such a shame to shutdown a project like this. CodeWhisperer has nothing similar to Fig. Fuck.

SupianIDz commented 3 months ago

I have no problem with my prompt being sent to Amazon, but my biggest question is, Why doesn't Amazon continue Fig instead of creating a new product and just taking autocomplete from Fig and leaving everything else. Even though in Fig previously it was planned that there would be AI.

levino commented 3 months ago

Even though I understand a certain degree of frustration, I think it is not worth while challenging the decision of the fig team.

Lets focus on the future of fig. It is under MIT license (at least as far as I know, is this true for all the code base?) and as such can never really be shut down. One just needs to find people who continue the maintenance and potentially the hosting for the back end (is there any which is really necessary for the CLI to work?).

michealroberts commented 3 months ago

Is anyone interested in forking this product and keeping it alive by other means? I have been boycotting Amazon and Amazon Web Services for their working and employment practises across other divisions, and total disregard of unionised workforces.

BB-BenBridges commented 3 months ago

I love the servers feature of Fig. Anyone aware of alternatives?

volgersnet commented 3 months ago

Sad this is stopping, I don't feel like sending my data to amazon.

mickaelxd commented 3 months ago

I use the customize terminal feature a lot. Before 2021 I had a lot of trouble configuring the terminal "by hand", and with fig it was all like magic. I faithfully hope that someone manages to keep Fig online, perhaps by creating an OpenFig. I would certainly be one of the testers.

pfurini commented 3 months ago

Unfortunately I don't think all the fig codebase is under MIT license. I can only find the autocomplete repo, that incidentally is the only feature being supported by Amazon. Everything else I think it's closed source, and it will remain so unless the creators decide to release the entire codebase under an OSS license.

wheresfrank commented 3 months ago

CodeWhisperer for command line has the same core features as Fig

It depends on who you ask. The core features for me are scripts and dotfiles. Looks like I have until September to find an alternative. Sad news.

duckpuppy commented 3 months ago

It's a real bummer for those of us working in environments where GenAI tools are not allowed on developer machines given the issues with licensing of output.

cpalafox commented 3 months ago

Installed Codewhisperer to try it out and it's not as responsive and not what i want. Such a disappointment. This is not the tool i wanted. What a waste :(. Glad the creators were able to get the bag tho, i guess

irsptech commented 3 months ago

How can we use Plugins in Code Whisper? My Fig setup is full of plugins and I don't believe that they will just drop support. This is so disrespectful with the community.

davidldennison commented 3 months ago

Same core features? That statement is actually outlandish. Lol

brendanfalk commented 3 months ago

Hi everyone. Just addressing the comments about Fig scripts/dotfiles/plugins/servers

Unfortunately this year's CodeWhisperer for command line roadmap doesn't have plans to support equivalents for Fig scripts, dotfiles, plugins, or servers. We're hoping to revisit them at some point, but for now, we decided to prioritize new features like support for Linux, AI chat, and inline AI suggestions. Amazon's bar for security, support, and operational readiness is incredibly high. Given our small team size, it was hard for us to support these features. Autocomplete and AI were by far our most popular features and so we have decided to prioritize these + integrations.

Some basic recommendations for tools you can switch to

michealroberts commented 3 months ago

@brendanfalk Disappointed, but glad you made $$$. You could literally make a similar tool, right?

o6uoq commented 3 months ago

@brendanfalk Disappointed, but glad you made $$$. You could literally make a similar tool, right?

Yes, I think we (the community) should. You could use GitOps as a backing store vs parsing data through a remote server, and features and solutions that we want and not the MegaCorp.

EloB commented 3 months ago

It's insane what money can do. Did AWS bought the product just to put it down? I don't want anything todo with AWS. They are terrible at software and then we should not talk about their docs.

o6uoq commented 3 months ago

Why Not Fork The Fig?

DarioLopes commented 2 months ago

Erf... we can't have nice things anymore, who asked for AI in a prompt... just installed CodeWhisperer without knowing that it won't support scripts (and likely never will), so gone are my scripts. Will the program simply stop working and become unusable after september 1?

In any case Amazon can keep himself his CodeWhisperer.

pbr0ck3r commented 2 months ago

As someone who contributed to Fig, parts of Fig are open source (https://github.com/withfig/plugins, https://github.com/withfig/autocomplete) but the backend servers (used for auth and storing other fig related user data) and desktop application/apis itself were closed source. Fig chose not to sell user data or charge out of the gate, and thus took the funding path to pay the developers/backend costs. Naturally when a company takes funding (Y Combinator’s S20 class) that path then is naturally being acquired or adding a paid tier (such as teams/enterprise features) as its exit.

Source to original Hacker News Announcement.