wmde / Wikiba.se-2017

The Wikiba.se website
http://wikiba.se
Other
22 stars 7 forks source link

Homepage is about Wikibase Repo #4

Closed JeroenDeDauw closed 10 years ago

JeroenDeDauw commented 10 years ago

The homepage is about the Wikibase Repo application, especially the "features" section. It's a very nice overview for Wikibase Repo, and we definitely want it on the site. However Wikibase Repo is not the only application. At the moment we also have Wikibase Client. Soon we will also have Wikibase Query. And there are many others that we can create.

Wikibase allows the collaborative editing of structured data on top of MediaWiki

That is specific to the MediaWiki extensions, Wikibase Repo and Wikibase Client. The core concepts of the Wikibase platform are MediaWiki agnostic, and can be used together with very different delivery and data access mechanisms. So while this line is fine if Wikibase is changed to Wikibase Repo, we need something more general on the homepage. Perhaps something along the lines of

Wikibase is a platform for creating, managing and sharing structure data
JeroenDeDauw commented 10 years ago

@AbrahamWMDE

lydiapintscher commented 10 years ago

We will mention MediaWiki on that page.

AbrahamWMDE commented 10 years ago

I want to go for this

"Wikibase is a platform for creating, managing and sharing structure data, e.g. on top of MediaWiki"

or

"Wikibase is a platform for creating, managing and sharing structure data, e.g. on top of MediaWiki as it is done for the Wikidata project"

ghost commented 10 years ago

@JeroenDeDauw @lydiapintscher I just talked to @AbrahamWMDE about this and we decided to

JeroenDeDauw commented 10 years ago

The Doctrine project has some similarity to Wikibase. It's not a single thing, but a collection of "projects". The main page does not talk about the Doctrine ORM, even though that might be the "big thing most people think about when they hear about the project", much like Wikibase Repo in our case. It then has separate documentation for each project, avoiding the context problems the wikiba.se site currently has (both the old and new versions).

This makes me think that putting the installation instructions for Wikibase Repo and Wikibase Client in the new site was a mistake. We will always have these docs on the extension pages on MediaWiki org, where people expect them to be. So it seems to make more sense to just refer to those from a dedicated page about the particular extension.

AbrahamWMDE commented 10 years ago

@JeroenDeDauw sounds good and reasonable