search

wmo-im / GRIB2

GRIB2
MIT License
22 stars 9 forks source link

add new entries in Code Table 4.2, product discipline 0, category 1 (moisture) #59

Closed SibylleK closed 3 years ago

SibylleK commented 3 years ago

Branch

https://github.com/wmo-im/GRIB2/tree/issue-59

Summary and purpose

Addition of a new entry in Table 4.2, discipline 0 (Meteorological products), category 1 (Moisture)

Action proposed

The team is requested to approve the content of this proposal for inclusion with the next update of the WMO Manual on Codes.

Discussions

A new entry for precipitation of cloud ice analog to snow precipitation rate is requested to be able to distinguish between snow and cloud ice particle deposition.

Detailed proposal

ADD in Table 4.2, discipline 0, category 1:

Title_en SubTitle_en CodeFlag Value MeaningParameterDescription_en Note_en UnitComments_en Status
Parameter number by product discipline and parameter category "Product discipline 0 - Meteorological products, parameter category 1: moisture" 146 Cloud ice precipitation rate kg m-2 s-1
sebvi commented 3 years ago

Following my comment during the meeting, I would like to have additional information on what is "cloud ice" precipitation rate and how it differs from or complements the existing similar entries in Code Table 4.2, discipline 0, category 1. For instance: 67 Freezing rain precipitation rate 68 Ice pellets precipitation rate 73 Hail precipitation rate 75 Graupel (snow pellets) precipitation rate 95 Freezing or frozen precipitation rate

SebastianB2 commented 3 years ago

We consulted our experts on this issue, and here's their answer:

The precipitation categories you mentioned all refer to large-size particles commonly considered as precipitation. "Cloud ice" is the small particle mode of a bi-modal ice particle distribution, which is often observed in the atmosphere. The large mode is usually called "snow". The small ice particle mode consist primarly of primary ice crystals (monomers), but may include some small aggregates. Particle shape is dominated by irregular crystals, plates, columns or dendrites, but in some models this category may also include small frozen drops and ice pellets. Cloud ice has a slow, but but still non-negligible sedimentation speed. Not all microphysics schemes take into account cloud ice sedimentation, but the new table entry is supposed to allow distinguishing between the precipitation rates originating from cloud ice and snow if desired. In general "ice pellets" are not the same as cloud ice (see, e.g., the definition on: https://glossary.ametsoc.org/wiki/Ice_pellets ).

The entry: 0 Cloud ice (kg m-2) does already exist in discipline 0 and category 6, but there is no corresponding "precipitation rate" yet.

In order to avoid misinterpretations, would it be of help, if we add a note to the new entry?

146 Cloud ice precipitation rate****

**** Assuming a cloud containing a bi-modal ice particle distribution, “cloud ice” refers to the small particle mode, whereas the large mode is usually called “snow”. (“Ice pellets”, in contrast, may refer to the precipitation of sleet, formed from freezing raindrops or refreezing (partially) melted snow flakes, or the precipitation of small hail.)

SibylleK commented 3 years ago

The branch issue-59 has been updated with the new entry Cloud ice precipitation rate.