search

wmo-im / iwxxm

XML schema and Schematron for aviation weather data exchange
https://old.wmo.int/wiswiki/tiki-index.php%3Fpage=TT-AvXML
48 stars 22 forks source link

all IWXXM reports to be in COLLECT containers #22

Closed marqh closed 6 years ago

marqh commented 7 years ago

Annotate the documentation of IWXXM to record that ICAO requires all IWXXM reports to be packaged in a COLLECT container.

WG-MIE decided that COLLECT should be used for all IWXXM reports, even for single reports.

braeckel commented 6 years ago

Collect should be mandatory for AMHS communications, but those trying to use a WFS probably want a different solution so they can have iwxxm:METAR as the top-level featureType. The use of both should be considered so IWXXM and Collect can carry the relevant information across both communication methods

braeckel commented 6 years ago

This change may also suggest that all of the examples (TAC and XML) should be updated to include WMO bulletins and corresponding Collect elements

marqh commented 6 years ago

This requirement shall be documented on the wiswiki and details of the two different schemas, one with COLLECT and one without provided.

For all AMHS communications, including single IWXXM reports, shall be packaged in a COLLECT container

This update should be considerd for the next version of WMO 306

marqh commented 6 years ago

section 6.2.2 within ICAO doc: 8896 (Manual of Aeronautical Practice) could be requested to be updated to include this requirement

braeckel commented 6 years ago

WMO wiki should be updated to include text similar to: "It is ICAO policy that COLLECT shall be used on ATN networks in similar manner to how WMO Bulletins are used with TAC. When single IWXXM messages are distributed on the ATN they shall be wrapped in a COLLECT element as with TAC messages"

blchoy commented 6 years ago

I will add some COLLECT examples based on some of the existing sample messages.

However, does anybody know where YUDO is (I need A1A2)? :)

blchoy commented 6 years ago

Committed validated IWXXM bulletin examples (METAR, TAF and SIGMET) to the master branch (I intended to push to a new branch but failed :( ).

blchoy commented 6 years ago

As discussed with Aaron, I have undone the committed IWXXM bulletin examples. Instead, I have created a branch, committed a new set of files and initiated a pull request to Aaron, Mark and Steve to try out the review arrangement.