Add topics for ocean earth system domain

[david-i-berry]

Update 08/10/24

Following comments received via email the proposal has been updated, a new branch can be found at:

https://github.com/wmo-im/wis2-topic-hierarchy/tree/oceanv2

Proposed initial topics for the ocean earth system domain based on GOOS networks and existing GTS headers (see #147):

Name	Description	Source
moored-buoys-and-moorings	Data from moored buoys and moorings
drifting-buoys	Data from drifting buoys
sea-ice	Sea ice observations
drifting-ocean-profilers	Data from ocean profilers, e.g. Argo
ship-surface	Along track surface observations from ships
ship-sub-surface	Profile data measured from ships, e.g. XBT, CTD, etc.
wave-buoys	Data from wave buoys
tsunami-buoys	Data from tsunami buoys, e.g. DART buoys
autonomous-surface-vehicles	Data from autonomous surface vehicles
autonomous-underwater-vehicles	Data from autonomous underwater vehicles
animal-borne-sensors	Data from animal borne sensors
fixed-marine-platforms	Data from fixed surface platforms
fixed-coastal-platforms	Data from fixed coastal stations, e.g. sea level monitoring station, HF radars etc

[david-i-berry]

Response received from GOOS Observations Coordination Group (10th September 2024, email)

WIS2.0 topic hierarchy-Ocean based observations

Observation Coordination Group (OCG) response

OCG executive members have discussed the suggested topic hierarchy (Annex 1) for the ocean-based platform data. Comments from the OCG Exb members;

1. The suggested hierarchy (Annex1) is based on the platform view of the system. With a wide variety of platform types, adding EOV/ECV based hierarchy makes it more meaningful, although as long as this is available as a readily searchable option, it may not need hard coding into the hierarchy.
   • e.g. ocean/surface-based-observations/EOV or ECV/fixed-marine-platforms
2. We suggest keeping the observing systems in the hierarchy that is broad enough to include a variety of similar observing systems. In line with this, we suggest the following changes
   • change gliders to autonomous underwater vehicles. (i.e. gliders, Autosub from UK, other underwater vehicles) ocean/surface-based-observations/autonomous underwater vehicles
   • Change ocean-profilers (Argo) to include other platforms providing ocean profilers ocean/surface-based-observations/drifting ocean profilers
   • moored buoys category includes sub-surface measurements ocean/surface-based-observations/moored-buoys-and-moorings
   • Sea-level is an EOV. Replace it with fixed coastal station that can include sea level stations (GLOSS) and HF Radar ocean/surface-based-observations/fixed-marine-platforms
3. We are not clear whether this hierarchy will be used to search on each of these terms or work as tree branches , see comment 1 above. If it is the former, we are comfortable with the proposed hierarchy with the edits mentioned above and with or without the inclusion of EOV/ECV, preferably before the observing system similar to the example provided in bullet i).

Question: We would like to clarify how the data users will use this topic hierarchy. Please see our assumption in iii) above. 

Annex 1

Oceanographic data

ocean/surface-based-observations/fixed-marine-platforms ocean/surface-based-observations/moored-buoys ocean/surface-based-observations/drifting-buoys ocean/surface-based-observations/wave-buoys ocean/surface-based-observations/autonomous-sea-surface-vehicles ocean/surface-based-observations/gliders ocean/surface-based-observations/sea-level ocean/surface-based-observations/animal-borne-sensors ocean/surface-based-observations/ship-based-observations ocean/surface-based-observations/ocean-profilers

Meteorological / weather data

weather/surface-based-observations/ship-based-observations weather/surface-based-observations/ship-based-radiosondes weather/surface-based-observations/moored-buoys weather/surface-based-observations/drifting-buoys weather/surface-based-observations/fixed-marine-platforms weather/surface-based-observations/autonomous-sea-surface-vehicles

[amilan17]

@david-i-berry @amilan17 or @tomkralidis update a new branch (https://github.com/wmo-im/wis2-topic-hierarchy/tree/151-add-topics-for-ocean-earth-system-domain) with requested changes for team to review.

[tomkralidis]

@david-i-berry / @amilan17 any update here? Can we have a branch update for review?

[david-i-berry]

@kevin-obrien

To answer the questions above, starting with (3):

3. The topic hierarchy is used to subscribe to (and publish) alerts when new data files are available. The tree structure is used to subscribe to different domains and sub-domains through the use of wild cards, with the notifications containing additional (limited) metadata to enable further filtering. The topics are not intended to be used to discover / search the catalogues. (@tomkralidis please correct me if I am wrong).

Now (1) and (2):

1. Data on the WIS2 is packed into reports / BUFR messages containing multiple EOVs. As such, a EOV based approach would not work. However, the WIS2 metadata, used to discover datasets and topics to subscribe, will contain this information - both through controlled vocabularies and free text keywords.

2. Proposed changes made, see proposal at the top of this issues (and associated branch):

   https://github.com/wmo-im/wis2-topic-hierarchy/tree/oceanv2

[tomkralidis]

TT-WISMD 2024-10-22:

• @kevin-obrien to provide final confirmation in the next 1-2 days

[tomkralidis]

Update: we have a go ahead from @kevin-obrien.