wokhan / WFN

Windows Firewall Notifier extends the default Windows embedded firewall by allowing to handle and notify about outgoing connections, offers real time connections monitoring, connections map, bandwidth usage monitoring and more...
GNU General Public License v3.0
603 stars 96 forks source link

Alert dialog shows NetBIOS internet traffic when using a browser #97

Closed kekukui closed 4 years ago

kekukui commented 4 years ago

image

This is Firefox connecting to GitHub - it happens with other sites too https://bgpview.io/ip/185.199.109.154

Windows - insecure by default? https://www.speedguide.net/port.php?port=137

Strange how Windows file sharing works over the internet when you did not even want it - but does not work properly over the freaking LAN 😆

image (...and that is with the firewall disabled!)


Here I keep pressing "Allow" but the alert is never dismissed, I just had to quit the program...

image

And now the browser has stopped responding so I had to open a new tab & re-create this GitHub issue...

image

I also hear Mozart's piano sonata # 16 ... 🎹 🎶

hoasis2 commented 4 years ago

Windows - insecure by default?

This is not a WFN specific problem.

Here I keep pressing "Allow" but the alert is never dismissed, I just had to quit the program...

You should have clicked at least 2 more times. See "Attempts: 2"

And now the browser has stopped responding so I had to open a new tab & re-create this GitHub issue...

Don't use nightlies on productive systems. You ought to use first v2.0-beta3, which is almost stable.

hoasis2 commented 4 years ago

This is Firefox connecting to GitHub - it happens with other sites too https://bgpview.io/ip/185.199.109.154

BTW look at the screenshot: "Application path:" is "System", not Firefox.

Probably your Synology Assistant client is trying to access your public IP address,

harrwiss commented 4 years ago

Hi @kekukui, it's difficult to judge from the information what happened and why port 137 tries to connect to the internet (seems it got redirected). The GitHub IP refers it seems to a CDN (Content Delivery Network), that is hosted by GitHub. The port 137 redirection is probably the reason why dsassisten.exe didn't work and the windows firewall blocked it.

For clarification some points (which you may know already 😄 ):

harrwiss commented 4 years ago

@hoasis2 - thanks for your comments.

wokhan commented 4 years ago

Hi @harrwiss,

If the Allow button is pressed multiple times with the same rule setttings it may create multiple rules in the firewall (still something not working perfectly there i.e. we should remove the notifications which do not apply anymore after a Allow/Block action).

You cannot be more right. I'm pretty sure I implemented this back in the days but obviously I didn't or it's broken somehow... I'll create an issue regarding this for WFN2.1 as it's pretty important for our users.

harrwiss commented 4 years ago

Think we can close this issue now as there is no futher info.

harrwiss commented 4 years ago

btw: This is my most annoying "test" app generating lots of requests - left it running for the day. Figure somebody trying to click through that number of attempts 🤔

image