Asset listed in AM/not in PKL/referenced in CPL - Githubissues

wolfgangw / backports

Deep inspection of digital cinema packages

27 stars 12 forks source link

Asset listed in AM/not in PKL/referenced in CPL #67

Open wolfgangw opened 7 years ago

wolfgangw commented 7 years ago

Imagine this DCP with 1 PackingList and 1 CompositionPlaylist:

AssetMap listing n distinct content assets
PKL listing n-1 distinct content assets from AssetMap
CPL referencing n distinct content assets as listed in AssetMap

According to specification this would be an incomplete composition because the PKL is missing one content asset referenced by the CPL.

dcp_inspect

(incorrectly) reports the CPL as OV
does not provide info/hint/error regarding the n-1 listing in PKL

Thanks to Marko Pekić for providing the test case.

wolfgangw commented 7 years ago

Confirmed on Doremi ShowVault: The composition correctly ends up incomplete.

dcp_inspect is looking in the wrong place (AM dictionary) to find the referenced asset, finds it, too, and thus remains silent.

Big one.