worldbank / dime-standards

Repository with resources for DIME's research standards and coding standards
47 stars 40 forks source link

Updates to Guidance Note Submission Checklist, and Reviewer Feedback Checklist #54

Closed Avnish95 closed 1 month ago

Avnish95 commented 1 month ago

Guidance note is now in GitHub markdown, and aligned with the reproducibility verification guidelines, along with the submission checklist, and reviewer feedback checklist

Avnish95 commented 1 month ago

Hi Maria, requesting your review on the updates to the Peer Code Review guidance note, package submission checklist, and the feedback checklist based on comments from Mer, Luise, Roshni, Ankriti, Mahin, as well as the general idea of aligning them with the reproducibility guidelines.

Thanks so much!

mariaruth commented 1 month ago

One more point that got cut off: i think it needs to be clearer in the guidance note that all reviewers fill out the checklist for overall code feedback (from which we'll remove reproducibility) and then fill out other checklists depending on the tasks requested for review.