worlickwerx / pi-parport

retro parallel port for raspberry pi
GNU General Public License v2.0
67 stars 12 forks source link

hardware_v4: add bypass capacitors, reroute traces #34

Closed quorten closed 4 years ago

quorten commented 4 years ago

These changes should close issues #28 and #29.

Here are some graphical indicators of the changes contained in this pull request.

pullreq_drawing1

pullreq_drawing2

quorten commented 4 years ago

A few additional comments are worthwhile for discussion. On one hand, I find it somewhat curiously interesting that the EEPROM chip worked just fine without a decoupling capacitor, but hey, being physically close to the Raspberry Pi board as a HAT is plausibly good fortune for avoiding the problems that would require the decoupling capacitors.

Technically I'm intending on using pi-parport with a Raspberry Pi Zero, as a first step I thought I'd try the board out as-is, but since my setup would likely involve connecting the two boards with a short cable, the missing bypass capacitors seemed too glaring of a problem.

garlick commented 4 years ago

Thank you @quorten - really nice job presenting the changes pictorially, and I appreciate that you fixed this design before moving on to the zero.

Would you mind tacking on a commit to rename hardware_v3 to just plain hardware and fixing the links in README.md? Probably the oshpark link in the README.md should then say "version 3 is shared..." until I get a chance to put up a v4.

When you've got a good design for the zero, perhaps that can go in hardware_zero or similar?

(All that's up for discussion if you have other ideas?)

quorten commented 4 years ago

Yeah, sure thing, I'll rename the directories and polish that up when ready. Actually, I ended up creating a Raspberry Pi Zero board design faster than I expected, I could probably finish it up pretty soon and create a pull request for that. And in doing so, I noticed there was another problem with traces running under resistor R3 on the v3 board, that should be an easy fix by moving R3 down and running in the space between instead.

pizero

garlick commented 4 years ago

Beautiful! Love it!

quorten commented 4 years ago

I decided to restructure the directories so that all versions are placed in a single directory, hardware instead of hardware_old. hardware_latest is setup to be a symlink to the latest hardware version.

One thing that I saw I got tripped up on in hardware_v3 was that the schematic specified 0805 package resistors at the EEPROM, but the PCB used 0603 footprints. I'm guessing that was a last minute decision to change those on the board to make positioning them easier when they are packed right next to each other, but I figure that bigger is probably better for hand soldering, and technically you could have squeezed 0805 packages onto the v3 board just fine.

cmp_foots

The other trace is now rerouted so that it doesn't go under resistor R3, I decided to move the vias closer to the EEPROM so now the I2C wires mostly travel across the back side of the board. I also fixed some minor CAD issues, so now the KiCad 3D view properly shows the rounded corners of the board outline! (Board outline just barely not closed at one spot.)

pullreq_drawing3

pr2_back

quorten commented 4 years ago

Looks like GitHub doesn't like following the symlink for the board image in README.md, that will have to be fixed.

garlick commented 4 years ago

Great improvements!

One thing that I saw I got tripped up on in hardware_v3 was that the schematic specified 0805 package resistors at the EEPROM, but the PCB used 0603 footprints

Doh! The 0603's came from the Kicad pi hat template, and I must not have forced the pcb to update after changing the footprint assignment in the schematic. Good catch!

garlick commented 4 years ago

Board outline just barely not closed at one spot.

Double-doh!

I'm happy to hit the merge button if you're all done making changes @quorten. I'm super pleased with these improvements, thank you!

quorten commented 4 years ago

@garlick One last change, related to the footprint swap-out, the reference R3 is probably better put to the right than the bottom, that's just the default location it ended up after force-updating the footprint changes.

quorten commented 4 years ago

Alright, looks good now.

pi-parport

quorten commented 4 years ago

@garlick Ready for you to merge.