wudongming97 / TopoMLP

[ICLR2024] TopoMLP: A Simple yet Strong Pipeline for Driving Topology Reasoning
Apache License 2.0
131 stars 11 forks source link

How to implement this experiment of ground-truth topology? #8

Closed SuperPengXue closed 6 months ago

SuperPengXue commented 6 months ago

20231212-143649

Thanks to you awesome work!

SuperPengXue commented 6 months ago

now I understand, Have you ever tried using ground-truth of lane and traffic element alone to predict topology of ll and lt?

wudongming97 commented 6 months ago

Sorry. We have not tried using ground-truth of lane and traffic element alone to predict topology of ll and lt.

sugar-fly commented 2 months ago

now I understand, Have you ever tried using ground-truth of lane and traffic element alone to predict topology of ll and lt?

Hi, I want to continue this discussion.

Have you conducted this experiment? In the current framework, my experimental findings indicate that ground truth (traffic element and centerline) as input does not significantly enhance topology reasoning. @SuperPengXue I'm not sure whether it's due to flaws in my experimental setup. I think the primary focus of the framework is detection, with topology reasoning being treated as an auxiliary task, which makes it difficult to learn robust topology. Is that right? @wudongming97

Best,

wudongming97 commented 2 months ago

In this paper, I'd like to express that the topology reasoning is based on the detection performance. It is logical. So I don't think topology reasoning is an auxiliary task.

Using only ground truth (traffic element and centerline) as input to perform topology reasoning seems unreasonable because it lacks a global understanding of lane position or traffic position within an image. Nonetheless, it needs lots of experiments to confirm it.