search

x-wrt / x-wrt

This repository is a fork of https://git.openwrt.org/openwrt/openwrt.git
https://x-wrt.com/
Other
719 stars 186 forks source link

Fake mesh Controller bridge mode doesn't work #426

Open bachvnnvn opened 2 days ago

bachvnnvn commented 2 days ago

Hi,

I am using Mikrotik OS as the main router. I have 4 AP and they are running x-wrt with fake mesh. On 1 AP, I set it as Controller and set statics IP for the Lan port. On 3 AP, I set it as Wired AP agent. The Lan Ports are using DHCP client. But on 3 AP, it cannot detect the Controller.

Could you please guide me how to fix it?

Thanks! Screenshot_2024-11-12-00-28-00-806_com android chrome

ptpt52 commented 2 days ago

get the test info:

Controller: what the lan ip is?

on AP: ubus call umdns browse

bachvnnvn commented 2 days ago

@ptpt52

Hi,

The Controller's IP is: 192.168.100.252

Below is the result of ubus that I did on 1 of the agent AP (192.168.100.250)

root@MESH-AGENT_5033F0AC80E4:~# ubus call umdns browse { "_dawn._tcp": { "MESH-AGENT_5033F0578B1C": { "iface": "br-lan", "host": "MESH-AGENT_5033F0578B1C.local", "port": 1026, "ipv4": "192.168.100.251", "ipv6": "fe80::5233:f0ff:fe57:8b1c" }, "T4": { "iface": "br-lan", "host": "T4.local", "port": 1026, "ipv4": "192.168.100.252", "ipv6": "fe80::5233:f0ff:fe3c:1c90" } }, "_fakemesh_PCRouter._tcp": { "T4": { "iface": "br-lan", "host": "T4.local", "port": 65535, "txt": "id=PCRouter", "ipv4": "192.168.100.252", "ipv6": "fe80::5233:f0ff:fe3c:1c90" } }, "_googlecast._tcp": { "Google-Nest-Hub-xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx": { "iface": "br-lan", "txt": "id=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "cd=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "rm=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "ve=05", "txt": "md=Google Nest Hub", "txt": "ic=/setup/icon.png", "txt": "fn=Bedroom display", "txt": "ca=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "st=0", "txt": "bs=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "nf=1", "txt": "rs=", "host": "fuchsia-xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "port": xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, "ipv4": "192.168.100.102", "ipv6": "fd07:97ef:93f2:5780:3c33:bc87:4f26:6105", "ipv6": "fd07:97ef:93f2:5780:5279:a460:3bbd:7881", "ipv6": "fe80::9704:46b:d745:7b55" }, "Google-Nest-Hub-xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx": { "iface": "br-lan", "txt": "id=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "cd=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "rm=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "ve=05", "txt": "md=Google Nest Hub", "txt": "ic=/setup/icon.png", "txt": "fn=Living Room display", "txt": "ca=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "st=0", "txt": "bs=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "nf=1", "txt": "rs=", "host": "fuchsia-xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "port": xxxxxxx, "ipv4": "192.168.100.22", "ipv6": "fe80::58f1:65ab:9bd8:b996", "ipv6": "fd07:97ef:93f2:5780:d67c:f6d5:aec7:5109", "ipv6": "fd07:97ef:93f2:5780:f232:a753:3304:8e90" }, "sti6140d360-1051ec27ad34d506cb8ed7caecc1c8a2": { "iface": "br-lan", "txt": "id=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "cd=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "rm=", "txt": "ve=05", "txt": "md=xxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "ic=/setup/icon.png", "txt": "fn=xxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "ca=xxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "st=0", "txt": "bs=xxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "nf=1", "txt": "ct=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "rs=", "host": "xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "port": xxxxxxxxxxxxx, "ipv4": "192.168.100.24", "ipv6": "fd07:97ef:93f2:5780:cbf9:ab05:6ebc:d26b" }, "Google-Home-Mini-xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx": { "iface": "br-lan", "txt": "id=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx5", "txt": "cd=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "rm=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "ve=05", "txt": "md=Google Home Mini", "txt": "ic=/setup/icon.png", "txt": "fn=Bedroom speaker", "txt": "ca=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "st=0", "txt": "bs=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "nf=1", "txt": "rs=", "host": "xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "port": xxxxxxxxxxxxx, "ipv4": "192.168.100.20", "ipv6": "fd07:97ef:93f2:5780:86:6830:aa35:a631" } }, "_googlezone._tcp": { "xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx": { "iface": "br-lan", "txt": "id=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "UDS", "txt": "CGS", "host": "xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "port": xxxxxx, "ipv4": "192.168.100.102", "ipv6": "fd07:97ef:93f2:5780:3c33:bc87:4f26:6105", "ipv6": "fd07:97ef:93f2:5780:5279:a460:3bbd:7881", "ipv6": "fe80::9704:46b:d745:7b55" }, "xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx": { "iface": "br-lan", "txt": "id=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "UDS", "txt": "CGS", "host": "xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "port": xxxxxxxxxx, "ipv4": "192.168.100.22", "ipv6": "fe80::58f1:65ab:9bd8:b996", "ipv6": "fd07:97ef:93f2:5780:d67c:f6d5:aec7:5109", "ipv6": "fd07:97ef:93f2:5780:f232:a753:3304:8e90" }, "xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx": { "iface": "br-lan", "txt": "id=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxB", "txt": "UDS", "txt": "CGS", "host": "xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "port": xxxxx, "ipv4": "192.168.100.20", "ipv6": "fd07:97ef:93f2:5780:86:6830:aa35:a631" } }, "_ssh._tcp": { "MESH-AGENT_5033F0578B1C": { "iface": "br-lan", "host": "MESH-AGENT_5033F0578B1C.local", "port": 22, "txt": "daemon=dropbear", "ipv4": "192.168.100.251", "ipv6": "fe80::5233:f0ff:fe57:8b1c" }, "T4": { "iface": "br-lan", "host": "T4.local", "port": 22, "txt": "daemon=dropbear", "ipv4": "192.168.100.252", "ipv6": "fe80::5233:f0ff:fe3c:1c90" } }, "_teamviewer._tcp": { "xxxxxxxxxxxxxx": { "iface": "br-lan", "txt": "DyngateID=xxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "Token=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx", "txt": "UUID=xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx" } } }

ptpt52 commented 2 days ago

AP 已经拿到 ac ip了

ptpt52 commented 2 days ago

确保 meshid都填写正确，PCRouter

bachvnnvn commented 2 days ago

@ptpt52 yes, all the APs have the same mesh ID "PCRouter". But as you can see in the snapshot above, on the Agent, the list of wireless is not there while it is on the Controller.

How to debug this further?

Thank you!

bachvnnvn commented 2 days ago

Here is the setting on the Controller

image

bachvnnvn commented 2 days ago

Here is on the Agent

image

ptpt52 commented 2 days ago

logread -e fakemesh

bachvnnvn commented 2 days ago

logread -e fakemesh

The log shows that the Agent is trying to get mesh info from the main router (192.168.100.1) and it is running Mikrotik OS.

root@MESH-AGENT_5033F0578B1C:~# logread -e fakemesh Tue Nov 12 10:39:09 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(6533): started! Tue Nov 12 10:46:58 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(6533): umdns: achost not found(lost_ac=0)! Tue Nov 12 10:46:58 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(6533): fetch config from controller.fakemesh failed(1)! Tue Nov 12 10:46:58 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(6533): fetch config from achost(controller.fakemesh)/gateway(192.168.100.1) failed(1), wait 30s Tue Nov 12 10:47:49 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(6533): umdns: achost not found(lost_ac=1)! Tue Nov 12 10:47:49 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(6533): fetch config from controller.fakemesh failed(2)! Tue Nov 12 10:47:49 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(6533): fetch config from achost(controller.fakemesh)/gateway(192.168.100.1) failed(2), wait 30s Tue Nov 12 10:48:39 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(6533): umdns: achost not found(lost_ac=2)! Tue Nov 12 10:48:39 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(6533): fetch config from controller.fakemesh failed(3)! Tue Nov 12 10:48:39 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_lost_ac(9722): started! lost_ac=3 Tue Nov 12 10:48:39 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_lost_ac(9722): setup temporary lan ip=192.168.16.1 Tue Nov 12 10:48:40 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_lost_ac(9722): starting wifi SSID=\'X-WRT_1C90\' on radio1 5g! Tue Nov 12 10:48:49 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_lost_ac(9722): done! Tue Nov 12 10:48:49 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(11565): started! Tue Nov 12 10:49:11 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(11565): umdns: achost not found(lost_ac=3)! Tue Nov 12 10:49:11 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(11565): fetch config from controller.fakemesh failed(4)! Tue Nov 12 10:49:11 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_lost_ac(14359): started! lost_ac=4 Tue Nov 12 10:49:11 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(14392): started! Tue Nov 12 10:49:34 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(14392): umdns: achost not found(lost_ac=4)! Tue Nov 12 10:49:34 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(14392): fetch config from controller.fakemesh failed(5)! Tue Nov 12 10:49:34 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_lost_ac(17290): started! lost_ac=5 Tue Nov 12 10:49:34 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(17295): started! Tue Nov 12 10:49:56 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(17295): umdns: achost not found(lost_ac=5)! Tue Nov 12 10:49:56 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(17295): fetch config from controller.fakemesh failed(6)! Tue Nov 12 10:49:56 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_lost_ac(20226): started! lost_ac=6 Tue Nov 12 10:49:56 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(20231): started! Tue Nov 12 10:50:19 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(20231): umdns: achost not found(lost_ac=6)! Tue Nov 12 10:50:19 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(20231): fetch config from controller.fakemesh failed(7)! Tue Nov 12 10:50:19 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_lost_ac(23170): started! lost_ac=7 Tue Nov 12 10:50:19 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(23175): started! Tue Nov 12 10:50:41 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(23175): umdns: achost not found(lost_ac=7)! Tue Nov 12 10:50:41 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(23175): fetch config from controller.fakemesh failed(8)! Tue Nov 12 10:50:41 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_lost_ac(26089): started! lost_ac=8 Tue Nov 12 10:50:41 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(26094): started! Tue Nov 12 10:51:04 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(26094): umdns: achost not found(lost_ac=8)! Tue Nov 12 10:51:04 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(26094): fetch config from controller.fakemesh failed(9)! Tue Nov 12 10:51:04 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_lost_ac(28938): started! lost_ac=9 Tue Nov 12 10:51:04 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(28943): started! Tue Nov 12 10:51:26 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(28943): umdns: achost not found(lost_ac=9)! Tue Nov 12 10:51:26 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(28943): fetch config from controller.fakemesh failed(10)! Tue Nov 12 10:51:26 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_lost_ac(31846): started! lost_ac=10 Tue Nov 12 10:51:26 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(31851): started!

ptpt52 commented 2 days ago

AP上执行执行获取AC的ip，是否能获取

ubus call umdns browse | jsonfilter -e "@['_fakemesh_PCRouter._tcp'][*]['ipv4']"
ptpt52 commented 2 days ago

多了个空格，更新一下命令

ptpt52 commented 2 days ago 
ubus call umdns browse | jsonfilter -e "@['_fakemesh_PCRouter._tcp'][*]['ipv4']"
bachvnnvn commented 2 days ago

@ptpt52

ptpt52 commented 2 days ago

re-run ubus call umdns browse multi-times after reboot.

bachvnnvn commented 2 days ago

re-run ubus call umdns browse multi-times after reboot.

I ran "ubus call umdns browse" more than 20 times then restarted the AP. Ran the "ubus call umdns browse" again but still no AC's IP there (192.168.100.252)

ptpt52 commented 2 days ago

为什么你之前的运行可以获得 ac IP 呢

bachvnnvn @.***> 于 2024年11月12日周二 12:32写道：

re-run ubus call umdns browse multi-times after reboot.

I ran "ubus call umdns browse" more than 20 times then restarted the AP. Ran the "ubus call umdns browse" again but still no AC's IP there (192.168.100.252)

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/x-wrt/x-wrt/issues/426#issuecomment-2469581041, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABIVTYWAHLW2BQ7SMC7BU6T2AGAFLAVCNFSM6AAAAABRSJQD4SVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDINRZGU4DCMBUGE . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

bachvnnvn commented 2 days ago

我也不知道。不过在重启AP之后，Controller的IP不再出现了，尽管我仍然可以ping通。有没有办法手动调整让AP接收Controller的IP呢？

bachvnnvn commented 2 days ago

挺有趣的。我进入AP并取消勾选Fake Mesh，AC的IP出现了。如果我勾选Fake Mesh，AC的IP就消失了。

bachvnnvn commented 2 days ago

I ran this command on each AP: echo "192.168.100.252 controller.fakemesh" >> /etc/hosts

And now the new log:

root@MESH-AGENT_5033F0AC80E4:~# echo "192.168.100.252 controller.fakemesh" >> /etc/hosts
root@MESH-AGENT_5033F0AC80E4:~# ubus call umdns browse | jsonfilter -e "@['_fakemesh_PCRouter._tcp'][*]['ipv4']"
192.168.100.252
root@MESH-AGENT_5033F0AC80E4:~# logread -e fakemesh
Tue Nov 12 13:28:58 2024 daemon.err uhttpd[2184]: [info] luci: accepted login on /admin/mesh/fakemesh for admin from 192.168.100.9
Tue Nov 12 13:33:12 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(29587): started!
Tue Nov 12 13:33:28 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(29587): fetch config from 192.168.100.252 failed(1)!
Tue Nov 12 13:33:28 2024 user.notice fakemesh: agent_sync_config(29587): fetch config from achost(192.168.100.252)/gateway(192.168.100.1) failed(1), wait 30s
ptpt52 commented 1 day ago

Maybe your meshid or password is inconsistent with the configuration on the AC.