search

xamarin / xamarin-macios

.NET for iOS, Mac Catalyst, macOS, and tvOS provide open-source bindings of the Apple SDKs for use with .NET managed languages such as C#
Other
2.45k stars 511 forks source link

NSOpenPanel and NSSavePanel no longer work on macOS 10.15 #6474

Open JamesB7 opened 5 years ago

JamesB7 commented 5 years ago

Steps to Reproduce

Call the NSOpenPanel or NSSavePanel constructor. This only happens on macOS 10.15.

Expected Behavior

It will create the NSOpenPanel/NSSavePanel object.

Actual Behavior

On macOS 10.15, it will fail with 'init returned null'.

Environment

macOS 10.15 Xamarin.Mac Calling mono from the command line. This also happens in my program which is built into a code-signed .app. It worked perfectly on all earlier versions of macOS.

wjk commented 5 years ago

The problem here is that when using this class from ObjC, you always call +[NSSavePanel savePanel]/+[NSOpenPanel openPanel] instead of alloc/init. Calling alloc/init was AFAICT never a supported way to create an open/save panel. The reason this worked prior to Catalina is because, on Mojave and earlier, the open/save panels were hosted in-process (except when sandboxed). If you are running in a sandboxed process, or in any process on Catalina, the open and save panels execute out-of-process for security reasons. The only way to create an out-of-process open/save panel is to use those static methods mentioned above.

To fix this problem, use the static OpenPanel and SavePanel properties instead of calling the class’ constructor. (In fact, if you look up the constructor for NSOpenPanel or NSSavePanel in appkit.cs, you will see an AdviceAttribute telling you this.) I could try my hand at preparing a PR that would deprecate those two constructors, if the team agrees (and is willing to provide a bit of help; the xamarin-macios repo and I are not friends). Hope this helps!

spouliot commented 5 years ago

@wjk you're right. On 10.15 the panels always behave like they are sandboxed, i.e. its now always out-of-process.

Feel free to PR and come ask on #macios-community (gitter) if you hit any snag :)

JamesB7 commented 5 years ago

NSOpenPanel.OpenPanel also returns null to me. Is there something special I might need to call to give it a value?

rosaliagomez commented 4 years ago

Steps to Reproduce

Call the NSOpenPanel or NSSavePanel constructor. This only happens on macOS 10.15.

Expected Behavior

It will create the NSOpenPanel/NSSavePanel object.

Actual Behavior

On macOS 10.15, it will fail with 'init returned null'.

Environment

macOS 10.15 Xamarin.Mac Calling mono from the command line. This also happens in my program which is built into a code-signed .app. It worked perfectly on all earlier versions of macOS.

https://github.com/xamarin/xamarin-macios/issues/6474#issue-463324943