Attribute assignments lost after update

[milesstoetzner]

Description

Hey,

I am having trouble with assigned attributes which are lost during an update of the service template. I encountered this problem when assigend public addresses of compute node templates have been lost.

Greetings Miles

Steps

Here is a minimal service template that should be deployed.

# service-template.yaml
tosca_definitions_version: tosca_simple_yaml_1_3

node_types:
    node_dummy:
        derived_from: tosca.nodes.Root
        attributes: 
            some_attribute: 
                type: string
        interfaces:
            Standard:
                operations:
                    create: create.yaml

topology_template:
    node_templates:
        node_first:
            type: node_dummy

The deployment works as expected.

$ opera deploy service-template.yaml
[Worker_0]   Deploying node_first_0
[Worker_0]     Executing create on node_first_0
[Worker_0]   Deployment of node_first_0 complete

And we can see in .opera/instances/node_first_0 that the attribute some_attribute of the node template node_first has the value some_value.

{
  "tosca_name": {
    "is_set": true,
    "data": "node_first"
  },
  "tosca_id": {
    "is_set": true,
    "data": "node_first_0"
  },
  "state": {
    "is_set": true,
    "data": "started"
  },
  "some_attribute": {
    "is_set": true,
    "data": "some_value"
  }
}

However, if we update the service template with service-template.v2.yaml, then the assigned attribute ist lost even tho node_first should not be "touched" since its state is started.

# service-template.v2.yaml
tosca_definitions_version: tosca_simple_yaml_1_3

node_types:
    node_dummy:
        derived_from: tosca.nodes.Root
        attributes: 
            some_attribute: 
                type: string
        interfaces:
            Standard:
                operations:
                    create: create.yaml

topology_template:
    node_templates:
        node_first:
            type: node_dummy

        node_second:
            type: node_dummy

The update command.

$ opera update service-template.v2.yaml
[Worker_0]   Deploying node_second_0
[Worker_0]     Executing create on node_second_0
[Worker_0]   Deployment of node_second_0 complete

The new content of .opera/instances/node_first_0 which has no value assigned to some_attribute.

{
  "tosca_name": {
    "is_set": true,
    "data": "node_first"
  },
  "tosca_id": {
    "is_set": true,
    "data": "node_first_0"
  },
  "state": {
    "is_set": true,
    "data": "started"
  },
  "component_version": {
    "is_set": false,
    "data": null
  },
  "admin_credential": {
    "is_set": false,
    "data": null
  },
  "some_attribute": {
    "is_set": false,
    "data": null
  }
}

The attribute has been assigned at node_second as exepcted.

{
  "tosca_name": {
    "is_set": true,
    "data": "node_second"
  },
  "tosca_id": {
    "is_set": true,
    "data": "node_second_0"
  },
  "state": {
    "is_set": true,
    "data": "started"
  },
  "some_attribute": {
    "is_set": true,
    "data": "some_value"
  }
}

Interestingly, when we add the node template node_second directly to the currently deployed service template service-template.yaml and resume the deployment, then the attribute assignment is obtained.

# service-template.yaml (directly updated)
tosca_definitions_version: tosca_simple_yaml_1_3

node_types:
    node_dummy:
        derived_from: tosca.nodes.Root
        attributes: 
            some_attribute: 
                type: string
        interfaces:
            Standard:
                operations:
                    create: create.yaml

topology_template:
    node_templates:
        node_first:
            type: node_dummy

        node_second:
            type: node_dummy

$ opera deploy --resume --force
[Worker_0]   Deploying node_second_0
[Worker_0]     Executing create on node_second_0
[Worker_0]   Deployment of node_second_0 complete

Expected Behaviour

I expect that assigned attributes of node templates, which are already deployed and are not touched during the update, are still assigned after the service template has been successfully updated.

[milesstoetzner]

Here is also the Ansible playbook.

# create.yaml
- hosts: all
  gather_facts: false
  tasks:
      - name: Set attributes
        set_stats:
            data:
              some_attribute: some_value