xsf / xeps

Hosts the markup for all XMPP Protocol Extensions.
https://xmpp.org/extensions/
Other
125 stars 121 forks source link

XEP-0004: clarify rules for multi-item forms #1194

Closed SamWhited closed 1 year ago

SamWhited commented 2 years ago

After a discussion on the mailing list a few days ago no conclusion was reached other than "multi-item forms are confusing". I believe this was likely the original intent of the section, and it's likely the simplest solution for now so I've gone ahead and made changes to disallow elements other than "reported" and "items" in multi-item forms. Users who want to mix and match should write a new XEP defining a new field type such as "table" that can contain other fields.

singpolyma commented 1 year ago

While I would prefer if we specified the opposite of this, I do understand that many have thought this is what the XEP already said so having something made clear is certainly better than leaving it unspecified.

singpolyma commented 1 year ago

Oh wait... the version that got merged implies that even title isn't allowed with reported/items? How does that make sense?