ycba-cia / blacklight-collections2

5 stars 2 forks source link

people represented facet #47

Closed yulgit1 closed 5 years ago

yulgit1 commented 6 years ago

add

People Represented: add a new facet for them. It maps to when lido:type="subjectActor"

yulgit1 commented 6 years ago

there is 'topic_subjectActor_facet' that maps to:

lido:objectRelationWrap/lido:subjectWrap/lido:subjectSet/lido:subject[@lido:type='description']/lido:subjectActor/lido:displayActor

@edgartdata does that suffice? (see comment below) (or rather than the comment below), actually implemented in: https://github.com/ycba-cia/blacklight-collections2/commit/7dc81fb81b517b7669a8640f7044644e33cfa65c can revert if necessary

yulgit1 commented 6 years ago

from a test implementation of topic_subjectActor_facet: Shakespeare, William (1564–1616), playwright and poet 1,008 Jesus Christ (7-2 BC/BCE to 30-36 AD/CE) 105 Garrick, David (1717–1779), actor and playwright 50 Hockney, David (born 1937), English painter, printmaker, and photographer 46 Cupid 43 Venus 42 Jones, Inigo (1573–1652), architect and theatre designer 30 Sir John Falstaff 25 Job 23 Russell, Lord John, 1st Earl Russell of Kingston Russell (1792-1878), politician/statesman 22 Fox, George (1624–1691), a founder of the Religious Society of Friends (Quakers) 21 saint 21 Adonis 20 Reynolds, Sir Joshua (1723–1792), portrait and history painter and art theorist 20 Apollo 19 West, Benjamin (1738–1820), American history painter active in Britain 18 William Hogarth 18 Jack Sheppard 17 Paul, the Apostle, St. (c. AD 5–c. AD 67) 17 The Virgin Mary 17 Keeler, Christine (1942-), British model 16 Wellesley, Arthur, first duke of Wellington (1769–1852), army officer and prime minister 16 Abington, Frances (1737–1815), actress 15 Hamilton, Emma, Lady Hamilton (bap. 1765, d. 1815), social celebrity and artist's model 15 demons 15 Cook, Peter (1937–1995), humorist and entertainer 14 Cordelia (character in King Lear) 14 Macbeth (character in The Tragedy of Macbeth) 14 Moore, Dudley Stuart John (1935–2002), actor, musician, and composer 14 Othello (character in Othello, the Moor of Venice) 14 Satan 14 Eve 13 Juliet (character in Romeo and Juliet) 13 The Three Witches (characters in Macbeth) 13 Diana 12 King Lear (character in King Lear) 12 Lady Macbeth (character in Macbeth) 12 Miranda (character in The Tempest) 12 Victoria (1819–1901), queen of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, and empress of India 12 Whistler, James Abbott McNeill (1834–1903), painter and printmaker 12 Bacchus 11 Dyck, Sir Anthony Van (1599–1641), painter and etcher 11 Frost, David (1939-2013), journalist, comedian, writer, media personality, and daytime TV game show host 11 George III (1738–1820), king of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, and king of Hanover 11 Hercules 11 Mary Magdalene, Saint (early 1st c. AD – mid-late 1st c. AD) 11 Peter, the Apostle, St. (ca. 1 BC - ca. 68 AD) 11 Prospero (character in The Tempest) 11 Bentinck, Lord George (1802-1848), politician/statesman, athlete/sportsman 10 Christ 10 Cosway, Richard (bap. 1742, d. 1821), artist and collector 10 Finney, Albert (born 1936), actor 10 Fox, Charles James (1749–1806), politician 10 Kauffman, Angelica (1741–1807), history and portrait painter 10 Mary 10 Ophelia (character in Hamlet) 10 Peter, Henry, 1st Baron Brougham and Vaux (1778–1868), politician/statesman 10 Zoffany, Johan Joseph (1733–1810), portrait painter 10 saints 10 Banquo (character in Macbeth) 9 Desdemona (character in Othello) 9 Hamlet, Prince of Denmark 9 Henry VIII (1491–1547), king of England and Ireland 9 Mary [Mary Stewart] (1542–1587), queen of Scots 9 Miller, Jonathan Wolfe (born 1934), stage director and author 9 Nollekens, Joseph (1737–1823), sculptor 9 O'Connell, Daniel (1775–1847), Irish nationalist leader 9 Orton, John Kingsley “Joe” (1933–1967), playwright 9 Telemachus 9 characters 9 Adam 8 Ariel (character in The Tempest) 8 Bartolozzi, Francesco (1728–1815), engraver 8 Bennett, Alan (born 1934), playwright, screenwriter, actor, and author 8 Lady Hamilton 8 Malvolio (character in Twelfth Night) 8 Northcote, James (1746–1831), artist and author 8 Pope, Alexander (1688–1744), poet 8 Sandby, Paul (bap. 1731, d. 1809), painter and engraver 8 Sandby, Thomas (bap. 1723, d. 1798), architect and draughtsman 8 Albert (1819–1861), prince consort, consort of Queen Victoria 7 Burke, Edmund (1729/30–1797), politician and author 7 Cipriani, Giovanni Battista (1727–1785), decorative painter and draughtsman 7 Disraeli, Benjamin, 1st Earl of Beaconsfield (1804-1881), politician/statesman, author/poet 7 Elizabeth I (1533-1603), queen of England and Ireland 7 Epstein, Brian Samuel (1934–1967), popular music entrepreneur and retailer 7 George IV (1762–1830), king of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, and king of Hanover 7 Hayman, Francis (1707/8–1776), painter, engraver, and book illustrator 7 James VI and I (1566–1625), king of Scotland, England, and Ireland 7 John the Evangelist, Saint (c. 1–c. 100 AD) 7 Jupiter 7 Kneller, Sir Godfrey, baronet (1646–1723), history and portrait painter 7 Locke, John (1632–1704), philosopher 7 Madonna 7 Mellon, Paul (1907–1999), philanthropist and art collector 7 Minerva 7 Morley, Lewis (1925-2013), photographer 7 Olivier, Laurence Kerr, Baron Olivier (1907–1989), actor and director 7 Siddons (née Kemble), Sarah (1755–1831), actress 7 Stubbs, George (1724–1806), painter, engraver, and anatomist 7

edgartdata commented 5 years ago

Looks good to me. @flapka and Kraig: Would your collections have metadata to contribute to this facet?

flapka commented 5 years ago

@edgartdata : When library descriptions record a person as subject of the item (MARC 600), it may mean that the person is the subject of the text or that the person is visually depicted (sometimes both). In a fair number of library records, the 600 field will include the subdivision 'Portraits' (e.g. "Mellon, Paul -- Portraits"). I think it would be sensible to map such headings to the people represented facet (discarding the word "Portraits" when we do).

edgartdata commented 5 years ago

@flapka Sounds great! Does that mean that we also need to harmonize names for this facet? That might be more difficult for the art collections as there are many people who don't have authority files. However, whenever we can we do add ULAN URIs to the names of sitters (organized in the TMS thesaurus manager).

edgartdata commented 5 years ago

@KraigBinkowski Would your collections have metadata to contribute to this facet?

KraigBinkowski commented 5 years ago

Yes, ref lib would have same 600 fields as rare, additionally, if we are thinking of the photo archives there are definitely many subjects that include sitters of portraits or family groups. The problem is that the T_Subject tables don't codify the type of subject so to isolate a person represented it would take two fields: the SUBJECT and the CATEGORY = "Portrait".

flapka commented 5 years ago

@edgartdata @KraigBinkowski Thinking aloud: Do we definitely want to exclude library material that is about a person (but without a portrait of the person)? I could see going either way.

The same question is pertinent to place represented.

edgartdata commented 5 years ago

@flapka The People Represented heading is actually misleading: it is rare but it happens that the art collections also uses this metadata element for people alluded to but not represented in, such as for William Shakespeare for whim of course there are wet few portraits. However, 100% of the names of places linked to art collections that show up in the Places Repesented facet are actually visible in the works of art. That said I think both facets would be really powerful ways to connect the library and art collections.

KraigBinkowski commented 5 years ago

No, you're right, I would want to include lib materials about the person as well -- its just with the photo archive that the additional element of PORTRAIT would have to be added to not get hordes of unrelated results.

edgartdata commented 5 years ago

@yulgit1 replace the name of the People Represented facet with "Associated People"

yulgit1 commented 5 years ago

@edgartdata On the show page there is the field 'People Represented or Subject' with the same data as the 'People Represented' facet. Should both of these now be "Associated People"?

edgartdata commented 5 years ago

@flapka @KraigBinkowski Do we want this facet to represent cases when a library item is about somebody rather than a visual representation of that person? April 23 discussion item.

flapka commented 5 years ago

@yulgit1 @edgartdata @KraigBinkowski

Simple change: Map to People Represented from MARC 600 (all subfields).

(But MARC 600 should remain mapped to Subject Terms, too)

yulgit1 commented 5 years ago

revised xslt for indexing this weekend: 600 (all subfields) to Associated People

https://git.yale.edu/ermadmix/ycba_xslts/commit/d26f7125337a5dfddf01276d802adf6810cc3697

edgartdata commented 5 years ago

@flapka Okay to close for RB?

flapka commented 5 years ago

@yulgit1 @edgartdata

We could consider this resolved as is. Or: would it be better to eliminate the added subdivisions that appear after some names (e.g. "Bacon, Francis, 1909-1992 -- Exhibitions.")? Given the facet scope, I think it'd be better to omit such subdivisions.

If you agree with my suggestion, then we should change the mapping (in this facet) to grab only 600 subfields abcdq. Sorry for not recognizing this earlier.

yulgit1 commented 5 years ago

@edgartdata do you agree with Francis, (just 600 abcdq)?

edgartdata commented 5 years ago

@flapka yes, i think dropping the subdivisions (like --Exhibiitons) would be helpful here.

edgartdata commented 5 years ago

@yulgit1 the label in the New Additions facet would be: Past Year

yulgit1 commented 5 years ago

@flapka 600abcdq addressed in: https://git.yale.edu/ermadmix/ycba_xslts/commit/7a2f1ceaf2c7d7b10e4c17d2a5a4418433cdaec8

to be reindexed...

yulgit1 commented 5 years ago

@flapka how's Associated People look with this 600 abcdq only? OK to close?

flapka commented 5 years ago

Yes, very close. One small issue remains. Some headings include a terminal period, others don’t – depending on whether the mapping stripped away non-abcdq fields. See for example:

http://10.5.96.187:3000/?utf8=%E2%9C%93&f%5Bcollection_ss%5D%5B%5D=Rare+Books+and+Manuscripts&search_field=all_fields&q=reynolds

The heading for Joshua Reynolds appears twice, with and without the terminal period.

Is there a way to normalize and remove that period?

yulgit1 commented 5 years ago

normalize by excluding trailing period addressed in: https://git.yale.edu/ermadmix/camel_collections2/commit/137664db7ace9469b7c34fa1c2416832b8f289b8

to be reindexed this weekend

yulgit1 commented 5 years ago

@flapka - reindexed, Associated People facet look OK now?

flapka commented 5 years ago

Yes, looks good. Thanks!