antonnell
commented
4 years ago 1) Each iearn product is on its own website, there’s no central repo or index where I can see all iearn products in one simple interface (I really do like the simple design). I think https://yearn.finance 4 should be this central index for yearn, ygov, staking, yswap, ytrade, yliquidate, ypool, and hyperlinks to integrations like curve 1inch, forum, docs, twitter, medium, FAQ, YFI explainer, etc. 2) The voting page on https://ygov.finance/vote 3 does not make it clear that you need 1000 bpt in the governance pool staked, it does not tell you what each proposal is for, there should be a link to the proposal from this forum and at least the title of the vote, and the UI does not prevent people from voting even when they don’t meet the requirements, wasting their gas 3) Each staking pool should have the steps laid out in on how to join and the hyperlinks to each pool on curve and balancer, or at least link to an article that explains what you need to do to farm YFI and provide liquidity 4) https://iearn.finance and https://docs.iearn.finance are dead links, I’ve seen people think the project is dead because they had these bookmarked before the rebrand to yearn, these should redirect to their correct links (https://yearn.finance 4 and https://docs.yearn.finance 1) like how https://uniwap.exchange goes to https://app.uniswap.org 1. Thus we should stay consistent with the name from here on out for continued brand recognition (We should converage on Yearn, yEarn, or yearn?) 5) When I refresh the page on iearn sites, it makes me sign into my web3 wallet again 6) UI on https://ygov.finance 2 doesn’t update when I make a transaction like deposting, withdrawing, claiming, means I need to refresh and connect my wallet again 7) https://docs.yearn.finance 1 should have a link to the twitter and medium blog 8) There should be a security page/section that explains that the protocol is community governed and the admin key is a 6-of-9 multisig and moving to DAO in the future 9) Its not clear how the system works, or all the components. Nothing is actually documented
Alrighty: 1) Anybody in the community with some competent design capabilities can create a marketing related website. And we can look at getting it domained. If needs be, I can build whatever they design. But this isn't a massive priority. 2) There isn't a requirement like that. You need 1000 BTP to stake in the Fee Rewards pool. 3) I'll add in the links 4) We don't control those domains anymore - legal reasons. So can't redirect. 5) I don't want to store any session information. With the balances refreshing it shouldn't be as much of a hastle. 6) Added a refresh every 15 seconds. If I missed somewhere, let me know and Ill fix. 7) Asked Andre to update. 8) This can be added to the "Marketing website (1)" 9) There are some medium articles explaining how the systems work.
With regards to 1, 8, 9. Our goal was never to make this massively normy friendly. If you don't want to go through the effort of reading how the system works (medium, twitter, reading smart contracts) then sadly you are going to miss out. Everything in the yearn ecosystem is designed to make our lives easier.
milkyklim
DBBIONIC
brockelmore
I've asked people for feedback and received pretty long list: https://gov.yearn.finance/t/time-to-get-our-shit-together/173/9.
Should I put each bullet point as separate issue in this repo or will you take over from forum?
cc @antonnell