search

yhat / ggpy

ggplot port for python
http://yhat.github.io/ggpy/
BSD 2-Clause "Simplified" License
3.69k stars 573 forks source link

Is this project dead? #654

Open hnykda opened 5 years ago

hnykda commented 5 years ago

Hey. It seems that the last commit was about 2 years ago. Is this officially dead? @glamp ?

bburan commented 5 years ago

@hnykda See https://plotnine.readthedocs.io/en/stable/ and https://github.com/has2k1/plotnine. I found these links when browsing the PRs and issues for this repo.

hnykda commented 5 years ago

Hey. Thanks, so I believe it is not then? I still think that mentioning plotnine and describing what's the relationship + explaining what's the status of ggpy would be a huge help for the users as well as the projects.

cc @has2k1

has2k1 commented 5 years ago

ggpy and plotnine are independent projects. See the about plotnine page for some more information.

hnykda commented 5 years ago

So do I understand correctly that from plotnine perspective, ggplot2 is considered finished? Really no bugs, no new features, no PRs needed to be merged (there are 24 open right now) which are not bothering anyone? I mean, you are fine with the fact that the reference implementation hasn't been improved for 2 years?

I am not saying it is an issue, but at least for me, as a software developer, this is very unlikely.

has2k1 commented 5 years ago

I think you are mixing up projects, this is ggplot2.

bburan commented 5 years ago

ggplot2 is the R-library that the Python-based ggpy and plotnine libraries emulate. As you pointed out, ggpy may be dead. I've started using plotnine and it seems to be a fairly feature-complete implementation of ggplot2 in Python.

hnykda commented 5 years ago

I am sorry :man_facepalming: , my bad, now I got it.

Nevertheless, the original question still holds - this repo seems dead and I encourage its developers, (based on the commit frequency - @glamp only), to make this clear in the readme or e.g. archive this repo.

st-pasha commented 5 years ago

This is really sad... plotnine looks very nice, but having a GPL-2 license, I don't see how it can be used in any non-GPL project.

dfsp-spirit commented 5 years ago

I just discovered this library but quickly noticed that all the links to the documentation on the ggplot project page at pypi.org are dead and came here to ask exactly this question. Sad to see that the answer seems to be yes. (I'm fine with GPLv2, so I'll have a look at plotnine.)

JoshRosen commented 5 years ago

I would be extremely grateful if this project could be adopted by / donated to someone who can help to more gracefully put it into maintenance mode by updating the documentation links, merging only dependency compatibility fixes, and publishing a minor maintenance release. Some users of ggpy have existing legacy codebases which cannot be trivially ported to plotnine, so the creation of maintenance-only releases is extremely valuable even if new feature development stops.

Here are some small but valuable maintenance fixes which I would love to see released:

As a stretch goal, I would also consider making a 0.6.9 release to fix an incompatibility with modern versions of six: #655. That's a relatively niche issue but is important to users who must continue using older versions of this library due to breaking API changes in newer versions.

sushinoya commented 5 years ago

Sucks to have to manually change from from pandas.lib import Timestamp to from pandas import Timestamp. @JoshRosen is there anything we can do except waiting for the repo's owner to reply? I wouldn't mind helping out but seems like nothing can be done for now.

sushinoya commented 5 years ago

Have a look at #656: Working copy of ggpy

randomizedthinking commented 5 years ago

A quick search shows the company Yhat was acquired by Alteryx in 2017-06-06, so this project is dead officially.

iliatimofeev commented 5 years ago

Take a look at Altair not exactly ggplot2 but the grammar of graphics implementation that is under active development and support.

whyboris commented 4 years ago

Looks like we have a working, maintained copy of ggpy https://github.com/sushinoya/ggpy 🎉 just 

pip uninstall ggplot
pip install git+https://github.com/sushinoya/ggpy

🎉

nateGeorge commented 3 years ago

A quick search shows the company Yhat was acquired by Alteryx in 2017-06-06, so this project is dead officially.

US capitalism strikes again...