Open ddrozdik opened 3 years ago
@sarah-halby we have a bunch of dependencies we need to resolve before working on this one Virtual Y Solr search Open Y upgrade to decent Solr ( 8 ) Open Y Solr search Open Y Blogs search Activity Finder v3 Activity Finder v4
Also, we have some related issues which could be merged into one epic with current one
However is two servers are needed, then at least rename Activity Finder Solr server.
@sarah-halby this is our path short term. Let's discuss this on our scrum
@ddrozdik please see @podarok comment above. Timing on this fix will be after the February release so we can address this and the upgrade path.
Can we get an estimate of back porting change plus supporting the upgrade path, as well as a priority level on this task @ddrozdik ?
Hi @shelleygoetz. Sure, We will prepare the estimate.
First of all, we need to revise modules listed in this comment - https://github.com/ymcatwincities/openy/issues/2393#issuecomment-766856501
In case the SOLR Server config is similar for all of them, we can create a new module in Open Y core Open Y Solr
, that will contain only the SOLR Server config. The next step - add a dependency to this new Open Y Solr
module in listed modules, add an update with removing old server configs, and update the dependency in index config + fix index names.
So we need some time to make this revision, make the final decision, then prepare a fix for several different repositories and test it well. I think it can take 10h
.
Simple solution with only renaming indexes - 1h
.
cc @ddrozdik @podarok @sarah-halby
Medium priority per the 5Jars teams - still an issue.
Test Environment: Environment: | https://sandboxes-d9.openy.org/ Drupal version | 9.0.10 Open Y version | 9.x-2.8.0 Open Y installation type | Custom Open Y theme | Carnation
Description: In the sandbox environment, I noticed there are two Solr servers with almost the same name. The first one added via the Activity Finder v4 module https://github.com/ymcatwincities/openy_activity_finder/blob/4.x/config/optional/search_api.server.solr.yml and the second one added by Open Y Search API module https://github.com/ymcatwincities/openy/blob/9.x-2.x/modules/custom/openy_search/openy_search_api/config/install/search_api.server.solr_search.yml
Both are configured almost identically. The only difference these modules use different indexes.
I suggest to modify these modules and develop a solution that will contain only one server. However, if two servers are needed, then at least rename Activity Finder Solr server.