young24 / Perfect-Lab-System

To develop a perfect project-management system for labs
MIT License
4 stars 3 forks source link

Integrate with a reference manager? #1

Open young24 opened 6 years ago

young24 commented 6 years ago

I just searched the market of the reference managers. I don't like EndNote. There are 3 plausible options: Zotero, ReadCube, and Mendeley.

Zotero

Pros

Cons

ReadCube

Pros

Cons

Mendeley

Pros

Cons

young24 commented 6 years ago

integrate the Reference folder with reference managers

xutq commented 6 years ago

Mendeley's build-in search engine is weird.

image

young24 commented 6 years ago

It is perfect on my computer, however, I believe you can adjust it manually. @xutq

young24 commented 6 years ago

I'm just aware that we can just add a link to the web library in a markdown to achieve the goal. So that,

  1. click the link
  2. jump to the web library
  3. Done.

Then if you want to download any files from the library, just click on the download button of that paper in the web library. (This can be achieved easily by Mendeley.) @xutq

xutq commented 6 years ago

Should this library be set to a shared library?

young24 commented 6 years ago

Yes, you have to invite other team members to share this library. Moreover, Mendeley provides links for each file in the library, which allows us to manipulate files separately.
So that, actually, we can build a hyperlink-style library on GitHub with the help of Mendeley. It is approximately my ideal storage model. Put real files in the Mendeley library and put their links on GitHub. @xutq

young24 commented 6 years ago

Sadly, there's no reference manager works with Markdown. Ideally, there should be a reference list noted with Markdown. So that when you add a file to the library (stored outside GitHub), an item would be automatically added to the Markdown list. In this way, GitHub can still track every manipulation but be free of the storage burden.

xutq commented 6 years ago

What is the situation of tracking the changes of references?

young24 commented 6 years ago

When you add/remove/edit an item to/from/in the library @xutq

xutq commented 6 years ago

What is the reason/necessity to track them?

young24 commented 6 years ago

Put all in one place. In the ideal storage model, you can access to every detail of the project from GitHub.

young24 commented 6 years ago

It's better to rephrase the idea in Git terms. Get version control on catalog items. Therefore, there are actually three procedures for an ideal reference manager:

  1. Generate the catalog automatically for each item in the folder. (e.g., Author-title-year)
  2. Record the catalog in Markdown style in an organized way. / Silent record just in the library.
  3. Git version control on the markdown file in step 2.

Mendeley provides APIs which enable the possibility of generating such a catalog in Markdown file. However, is that okay to update this catalog markdown file directly on GitHub? This would cause some unnecessary pull-down, which might not good for the collaboration.