search

younginnovations / aidstream-old

[Deprecated] AidStream is a platform for small and medium size NGOs to publish their aid data in IATI standard.
http://aidstream.org
3 stars 13 forks source link

Multiple Validation Errors For Heifer #142

Closed wendyrogers closed 8 years ago

wendyrogers commented 8 years ago

The activity file for Heifer http://www.aidstream.org/files/xml/heifer-activities.xml is currently failing on the IATI validator with a number of errors:

Element 'result': Missing child element(s). Expected is one of ( description, indicator ). Element 'description': This element is not expected. Expected is ( title ). Element 'period-end': This element is not expected. Expected is ( period-start ). Element 'result': Missing child element(s). Expected is ( indicator ). Element 'baseline': This element is not expected. Expected is ( title ). Element 'period': This element is not expected. Expected is ( title ).

Please can you investigate and amend Aidstream as required

rolfkleef commented 8 years ago

I'll check in with Heifer, have been helping the person there to move forward with their publication a few weeks ago.

wendyrogers commented 8 years ago

Thanks Rolf that will be really helpful although you might not want to change anything until @anjesh and his team have had a look as I think most of the errors being reported are related to validation? However, have a look and see what you think?

rolfkleef commented 8 years ago

I saw that the activity identifier for most activities wasn't complete in the data, and had a look via AidStream.

One thing is a somewhat confusing message in their activities dashboard about the number of published activities (the actual data and the number in the Registry is 12 activities): 2015-12-22_01

The IATI Identifier fields in several activities do have an organisation-specific, but somehow it seems that has not been copied to the full IATI identifier: 2015-12-22_02

There is some data missing in their AidStream records (such as result indicators) so that should have been flagged in a validation step.

anjesh commented 8 years ago

Same as https://github.com/younginnovations/aidstream/issues/135#issuecomment-167989277

Since we don't have schema validation, these legacy activites problematic elements don't get captured. Will be taken care after this https://github.com/younginnovations/aidstream/issues/148