search

ytdl-org / youtube-dl

Command-line program to download videos from YouTube.com and other video sites
http://ytdl-org.github.io/youtube-dl/
The Unlicense
132k stars 10.01k forks source link

Ted Videos --max-quality #5397

Closed asansli closed 9 years ago

asansli commented 9 years ago

Whe trying to get all video formats via --max-qualty -F --list-formats get only three

format code  extension  resolution note
low          mp4        320x180    
medium       mp4        512x288    
high         mp4        854x480    (best)

But when I check JSON data at website, I can see better video is there. Like:

{"talks":[{"id":2207,"duration":683,"languages":[{"languageName":"English","languageCode":"en","isRtl":false},{"languageName":"Hebrew","languageCode":"he","isRtl":true},{"languageName":"Italian","languageCode":"it","isRtl":false}],"nativeLanguage":"en","isSubtitleRequired":false,"introDuration":11.82,"adDuration":"3.33","adUrl":"https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/ads?ciu_szs=300x250%2C512x288%2C120x60%2C320x50%2C6x7%2C6x8\u0026correlator=%5Bcorrelator%5D\u0026cust_params=event%3DTEDxNewYork%26id%3D2207%26tag%3DTEDx%2Cactivism%2Ccities%2Ccrime%2Cprison%2Csocial%2Bchange%2Cviolence%2Cyouth%26talk%3Dismael_nazario_what_i_learned_as_a_kid_in_jail%26year%3D2014\u0026env=vp\u0026gdfp_req=1\u0026impl=s\u0026iu=%2F5641%2Fted2%2Ftalk\u0026output=xml_vast2\u0026sz=640x360\u0026unviewed_position_start=1\u0026url=%5Breferrer%5D","streamer":"rtmp://cp358131.edgefcs.net/ted","resources":{"h264":[{"bitrate":320,"file":"http://download.ted.com/talks/IsmaelNazario_2014X-320k.mp4?apikey=489b859150fc58263f17110eeb44ed5fba4a3b22"}],"rtmp":[{"bitrate":1500,"file":"mp4:talk/stream/2014X/Blank/IsmaelNazario_2014X-1500k.mp4","name":"1500k","width":1280,"height":720},{"bitrate":950,"file":"mp4:talk/stream/2014X/Blank/IsmaelNazario_2014X-950k.mp4","name":"950k","width":854,"height":480},{"bitrate":600,"file":"mp4:talk/stream/2014X/Blank/IsmaelNazario_2014X-600k.mp4","name":"600k","width":640,"height":360},{"bitrate":450,"file":"mp4:talk/stream/2014X/Blank/IsmaelNazario_2014X-450k.mp4","name":"450k","width":512,"height":288},{"bitrate":320,"file":"mp4:talk/stream/2014X/Blank/IsmaelNazario_2014X-320k.mp4","name":"320k","width":512,"height":288},{"bitrate":180,"file":"mp4:talk/stream/2014X/Blank/IsmaelNazario_2014X-180k.mp4","name":"180k","width":512,"height":288},{"bitrate":64,"file":"mp4:talk/stream/2014X/Blank/IsmaelNazario_2014X-64k.mp4","name":"64k","width":398,"height":224}],"hls":{"adUrl":"https://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/ads?ciu_szs=300x250%2C512x288%2C120x60%2C320x50%2C6x7%2C6x8\u0026correlator=%5Bcorrelator%5D\u0026cust_params=event%3DTEDxNewYork%26id%3D2207%26tag%3DTEDx%2Cactivism%2Ccities%2Ccrime%2Cprison%2Csocial%2Bchange%2Cviolence%2Cyouth%26talk%3Dismael_nazario_what_i_learned_as_a_kid_in_jail%26year%3D2014\u0026env=vp\u0026gdfp_req=1\u0026impl=s\u0026iu=%2F5641%2Fmobile%2Fios%2Fweb\u0026output=xml_vast2\u0026sz=640x360\u0026unviewed_position_start=1\u0026url=%5Breferrer%5D","stream":"http://hls.ted.com/talks/2207.m3u8","metadata":"http://hls.ted.com/talks/2207.json"}},"canonical":"http://www.ted.com/talks/ismael_nazario_what_i_learned_as_a_kid_in_jail","external":null,"name":"Ismael Nazario: What I learned as a kid in jail","title":"What I learned as a kid in jail","speaker":"Ismael Nazario","thumb":"http://img.tedcdn.com/r/images.ted.com/images/ted/c72c69bed3747f108a611b6a1795483a06ef61a3_2880x1620.jpg?quality=89\u0026w=600","slug":"ismael_nazario_what_i_learned_as_a_kid_in_jail","event":"TEDxNewYork","filmed":1414800000,"published":1426087377,"nativeDownloads":{"low":"http://download.ted.com/talks/IsmaelNazario_2014X-light.mp4?apikey=489b859150fc58263f17110eeb44ed5fba4a3b22","medium":"http://download.ted.com/talks/IsmaelNazario_2014X.mp4?apikey=489b859150fc58263f17110eeb44ed5fba4a3b22","high":"http://download.ted.com/talks/IsmaelNazario_2014X-480p.mp4?apikey=489b859150fc58263f17110eeb44ed5fba4a3b22"},"subtitledDownloads":{"en":{"name":"English","low":"http://download.ted.com/talks/IsmaelNazario_2014X-low-en.mp4","high":"http://download.ted.com/talks/IsmaelNazario_2014X-480p-en.mp4"},"he":{"name":"Hebrew","low":"http://download.ted.com/talks/IsmaelNazario_2014X-low-he.mp4","high":"http://download.ted.com/talks/IsmaelNazario_2014X-480p-he.mp4"},"it":{"name":"Italian","low":"http://download.ted.com/talks/IsmaelNazario_2014X-low-it.mp4","high":"http://download.ted.com/talks/IsmaelNazario_2014X-480p-it.mp4"}},"audioDownload":"http://download.ted.com/talks/IsmaelNazario_2014X.mp3?apikey=489b859150fc58263f17110eeb44ed5fba4a3b22","shareUrl":"http://www.ted.com/talks/ismael_nazario_what_i_learned_as_a_kid_in_jail"}],"language":"en","ratings":[{"id":3,"name":"Courageous","count":205},{"id":8,"name":"Informative","count":180},{"id":22,"name":"Fascinating","count":60},{"id":1,"name":"Beautiful","count":43},{"id":10,"name":"Inspiring","count":225},{"id":21,"name":"Unconvincing","count":25},{"id":23,"name":"Jaw-dropping","count":19},{"id":25,"name":"OK","count":39},{"id":24,"name":"Persuasive","count":87},{"id":7,"name":"Funny","count":9},{"id":2,"name":"Confusing","count":8},{"id":26,"name":"Obnoxious","count":3},{"id":9,"name":"Ingenious","count":7},{"id":11,"name":"Longwinded","count":4}],"relatedTalks":[{"image":"http://img.tedcdn.com/r/images.ted.com/images/ted/3f6dda85c262a19435f481dfe30c3ebe469d874a_800x600.jpg?quality=75\u0026w=500","speaker":"Damon Horowitz","title":"Philosophy in prison","duration":230,"slug":"damon_horowitz_philosophy_in_prison"},{"image":"http://img.tedcdn.com/r/images.ted.com/images/ted/28d6fdbc71f8ab7559b394cb64fb380a90252a6c_1600x1200.jpg?quality=75\u0026w=500","speaker":"Jeff Smith","title":"Lessons in business ... from prison","duration":300,"slug":"jeff_smith_lessons_in_business_from_prison"},{"image":"http://img.tedcdn.com/r/images.ted.com/images/ted/69e4f4f5e656aa0f9d1ea4ab6accd8a7fd05b2a7_2400x1800.jpg?quality=75\u0026w=500","speaker":"Dan Pacholke","title":"How prisons can help inmates live meaningful lives","duration":632,"slug":"dan_pacholke_how_prisons_can_help_inmates_live_meaningful_lives"},{"image":"http://img.tedcdn.com/r/images.ted.com/images/ted/2d581c7373812177a05cfb1b07464ae3e80f9c67_2880x1620.jpg?quality=75\u0026w=500","speaker":"Eduardo Sáenz de Cabezón","title":"Math is forever","duration":614,"slug":"eduardo_saenz_de_cabezon_math_is_forever"},{"image":"http://img.tedcdn.com/r/images.ted.com/images/ted/c503844ad499db8826d41e0b5bc5df56bd375d22_2880x1620.jpg?quality=75\u0026w=500","speaker":"Boniface Mwangi","title":"The day I stood up alone","duration":440,"slug":"boniface_mwangi_boniface_mwangi_the_day_i_stood_up_alone"},{"image":"http://img.tedcdn.com/r/images.ted.com/images/ted/95a4015b80150ecd8795e24793648c5877612d20_2880x1620.jpg?quality=75\u0026w=500","speaker":"Alison Killing","title":"There’s a better way to die, and architecture can help","duration":279,"slug":"alison_killing_there_s_a_better_way_to_die_and_architecture_can_help"},{"image":"http://img.tedcdn.com/r/images.ted.com/images/ted/ca8853f7f7fa4fa629610bd38f7f42795d10f9c6_2880x1620.jpg?quality=75\u0026w=500","speaker":"Theaster Gates","title":"How to revive a neighborhood: with imagination, beauty and art","duration":1012,"slug":"theaster_gates_how_to_revive_a_neighborhood_with_imagination_beauty_and_art"},{"image":"http://img.tedcdn.com/r/images.ted.com/images/ted/a2b28c69eac9216fa175749c32ced0c39d6c93ff_2880x1620.jpg?quality=75\u0026w=500","speaker":"Anand Giridharadas","title":"A tale of two Americas. And the mini-mart where they collided","duration":1163,"slug":"anand_giridharadas_a_tale_of_two_americas_and_the_mini_mart_where_they_collided"},{"image":"http://img.tedcdn.com/r/images.ted.com/images/ted/0511af4aab445591aeeebadc7e8fbb78653b800d_2880x1620.jpg?quality=75\u0026w=500","speaker":"Robyn Stein DeLuca","title":"The good news about PMS","duration":884,"slug":"robyn_stein_deluca_the_good_news_about_pms"},{"image":"http://img.tedcdn.com/r/images.ted.com/images/ted/9fef2f6fcee1c5983ede2827907f66c31db28735_2880x1620.jpg?quality=75\u0026w=500","speaker":"Vincent Cochetel","title":"I was held hostage for 317 days. Here's what I thought about…","duration":1187,"slug":"vincent_cochetel_i_was_held_hostage_for_317_days_here_s_what_i_thought_about"}],"threadId":26826}

Here is the video I tried to get.

youtube-dl http://www.ted.com/talks/ismael_nazario_what_i_learned_as_a_kid_in_jail --max-quality

It gets marked with (best).

My question is why youtube-dl does not gets better one?

asansli commented 9 years ago

Also checked for downloading playlists from TED, again shows best as 950k bitrated ones beside there is 1500k bitrated videos as mp4.

#!console
youtube-dl http://www.ted.com/playlists/180/the_10_most_popular_tedx_talks --max-quality -F --list-formats 
[TED] the_10_most_popular_tedx_talks: Downloading playlist webpage
[download] Downloading playlist: The 10 most popular TEDx talks
[TED] playlist The 10 most popular TEDx talks: Collected 10 video ids (downloading 10 of them)
[download] Downloading video 1 of 10
[TED] tom_thum_the_orchestra_in_my_mouth: Downloading webpage
[TED] tom_thum_the_orchestra_in_my_mouth: Extracting information
[info] Available formats for 1792:
format code  extension  resolution note
low          mp4        320x180    
medium       mp4        512x288    
high         mp4        854x480    (best)
[download] Downloading video 2 of 10
[TED] simon_sinek_how_great_leaders_inspire_action: Downloading webpage
[TED] simon_sinek_how_great_leaders_inspire_action: Extracting information
[info] Available formats for 848:
format code  extension  resolution note
low          mp4        320x180    
medium       mp4        512x288    
high         mp4        854x480    (best)
[download] Downloading video 3 of 10
[TED] brene_brown_on_vulnerability: Downloading webpage
[TED] brene_brown_on_vulnerability: Extracting information
[info] Available formats for 1042:
format code  extension  resolution note
low          mp4        320x180    
medium       mp4        512x288    
high         mp4        854x480    (best)
[download] Downloading video 4 of 10
[TED] shawn_achor_the_happy_secret_to_better_work: Downloading webpage
[TED] shawn_achor_the_happy_secret_to_better_work: Extracting information
[info] Available formats for 1344:
format code  extension  resolution note
low          mp4        320x180    
medium       mp4        512x288    
high         mp4        854x480    (best)
[download] Downloading video 5 of 10
[TED] cameron_russell_looks_aren_t_everything_believe_me_i_m_a_model: Downloading webpage
[TED] cameron_russell_looks_aren_t_everything_believe_me_i_m_a_model: Extracting information
[info] Available formats for 1647:
format code  extension  resolution note
low          mp4        320x180    
medium       mp4        512x288    
high         mp4        854x480    (best)
[download] Downloading video 6 of 10
[TED] ash_beckham_we_re_all_hiding_something_let_s_find_the_courage_to_open_up: Downloading webpage
[TED] ash_beckham_we_re_all_hiding_something_let_s_find_the_courage_to_open_up: Extracting information
[info] Available formats for 1932:
format code  extension  resolution note
low          mp4        320x180    
medium       mp4        512x288    
high         mp4        854x480    (best)
[download] Downloading video 7 of 10
[TED] louie_schwartzberg_nature_beauty_gratitude: Downloading webpage
[TED] louie_schwartzberg_nature_beauty_gratitude: Extracting information
[info] Available formats for 1283:
format code  extension  resolution note
low          mp4        320x180    
medium       mp4        512x288    
high         mp4        854x480    (best)
[download] Downloading video 8 of 10
[TED] larry_smith_why_you_will_fail_to_have_a_great_career: Downloading webpage
[TED] larry_smith_why_you_will_fail_to_have_a_great_career: Extracting information
[info] Available formats for 1384:
format code  extension  resolution note
low          mp4        320x180    
medium       mp4        512x288    
high         mp4        854x480    (best)
[download] Downloading video 9 of 10
[TED] thomas_suarez_a_12_year_old_app_developer: Downloading webpage
[TED] thomas_suarez_a_12_year_old_app_developer: Extracting information
[info] Available formats for 1272:
format code  extension  resolution note
low          mp4        320x180    
medium       mp4        512x288    
high         mp4        854x480    (best)
[download] Downloading video 10 of 10
[TED] colin_stokes_how_movies_teach_manhood: Downloading webpage
[TED] colin_stokes_how_movies_teach_manhood: Extracting information
[info] Available formats for 1650:
format code  extension  resolution note
low          mp4        320x180    
medium       mp4        512x288    
high         mp4        854x480    (best)
dstftw commented 9 years ago

All formats will be extracted in the next version. Thanks for the report.

asansli commented 9 years ago

Thanks for update.

http://www.ted.com/playlists/180/the_10_most_popular_tedx_talks --max-quality -F --list-formats

get a long list as 

youtube-dl http://www.ted.com/talks/ismael_nazario_what_i_learned_as_a_kid_in_jail --max-quality -F --list-formats 
[TED] ismael_nazario_what_i_learned_as_a_kid_in_jail: Downloading webpage
[TED] ismael_nazario_what_i_learned_as_a_kid_in_jail: Extracting information
[TED] ismael_nazario_what_i_learned_as_a_kid_in_jail: Downloading m3u8 information
[info] Available formats for 2207:
format code  extension  resolution note
hls-meta     mp4        multiple   Quality selection URL 
rtmp-64k     flv        398x224      64k 
hls-68       mp4        unknown      68k , mp4a
rtmp-180k    flv        512x288     180k 
hls-282      mp4        320x180     282k , avc1, mp4a 
rtmp-320k    flv        512x288     320k 
rtmp-450k    flv        512x288     450k 
rtmp-600k    flv        640x360     600k 
hls-790      mp4        512x288     790k , avc1, mp4a 
rtmp-950k    flv        854x480     950k 
hls-1407     mp4        512x288    1407k , avc1, mp4a 
rtmp-1500k   flv        1280x720   1500k 
hls-2017     mp4        512x288    2017k , avc1, mp4a 
hls-2680     mp4        640x360    2680k , avc1, mp4a 
hls-3774     mp4        853x480    3774k , avc1, mp4a 
hls-5961     mp4        1280x720   5961k , avc1, mp4a 
audio        mp3        unknown    
h264-320k    mp4        unknown     320k 
low          mp4        320x180    
medium       mp4        512x288    
high         mp4        854x480    (best)

Although there are 1280x720 why these are not best?