yuliskov / SmartTubeLegacy

Watch YouTube videos on your TV and set-top-box with comfort
Mozilla Public License 2.0
4.43k stars 599 forks source link

"YouTube is killing its web-based TV interface"will this affect the app? #338

Open darren3 opened 5 years ago

darren3 commented 5 years ago

I read this article today "YouTube is killing its web-based TV interface" on Android police.

https://www.androidpolice.com/2019/09/13/sorry-htpc-owners-youtube-is-killing-its-web-based-tv-interface/

Is this going to affect this app?

SocietasEvanescentes commented 5 years ago

I would also like to know

fgl27 commented 5 years ago

they are working on this seems all related.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UaVk1IyvUgs&feature=youtu.be&list=PLPz0U7t-NBWmNf6KyqH8EltRVjSEDbK83

from that video it does also seems to be web based, maybe isn't maybe it's, if is all java maybe is a app that can be mod as the vaced youtube is this... https://www.xda-developers.com/youtube-vanced-apk/

evertonstz commented 5 years ago

they are working on this seems all related.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UaVk1IyvUgs&feature=youtu.be&list=PLPz0U7t-NBWmNf6KyqH8EltRVjSEDbK83

from that video it does also seems to be web based, maybe isn't maybe it's, if is all java maybe is a app that can be mod as the vaced youtube is this... https://www.xda-developers.com/youtube-vanced-apk/

I really doubt it's not a wrapper, you can't just decompile a google app, modify it and post it on Github, with binaries and all, that's why Vanced has their own website.

fgl27 commented 5 years ago

I really doubt it's not a wrapper, you can't just decompile a google app, modify it and post it on Github, with binaries and all, that's why Vanced has their own website.

btw no one is telling anyone to do anything @evertonstz , mostly anything related of what you wrote.

I was just making conversation.

on vanced web site they have this

Vanced is a well known modded version of YouTube

I wrote

if is all java maybe is a app that can be mod as the vaced youtube is this... https://www.xda-developers.com/youtube-vanced-apk/

no one is toking about wrappers, decompiling/recompiling or sharing wherever was somehow modded anywhere.

I have no idea on how Vanced works is made I was just making conversation.

evertonstz commented 5 years ago

I really doubt it's not a wrapper, you can't just decompile a google app, modify it and post it on Github, with binaries and all, that's why Vanced has their own website.

btw no one is telling anyone to do anything @evertonstz , mostly anything related of what you wrote.

I was just making conversation.

on vanced web they have this

Vanced is a well known modded version of YouTube

I wrote

if is all java maybe is a app that can be mod as the vaced youtube is this... https://www.xda-developers.com/youtube-vanced-apk/

no one is toking about wrappers, decompiling/recompiling or sharing wherever was somehow modded anywhere.

What are you talking about, mate? What I'm saying is that this app in specific, SmartYoutubeTV is probably wrapped around the web-based interface(that's youtube.com/tv ) simply because it's against the rules to host illegal code and binaries on GitHub, that's all. And if I'm right, it'll stop working once google kills the web interface, that's what the issue is talking about.

The video you posted is the official leanback youtube app for Android TV, that's also a wrapper but the website it's wrapped on is not youtube.com/tv so all official leanback apps won't be affected, only non official ones like this one.

fgl27 commented 5 years ago

@evertonstz yours post implies that I wanna that someone do this

decompile a google app, modify it and post it on Github

When the conversation never ever reach that state but from nowhere you started it.

All I wanna to make is a conversation that does't in any way implies that level or sharing a google thing.

evertonstz commented 5 years ago

@evertonstz yours post implies that I wanna that someone do this

decompile a google app, modify it and post it on Github

When the conversation never ever reach that state but from nowhere you started it.

All I wanna to make is a conversation that does't in any way implies that level or sharing a google thing.

Does it? I guess you're not a native English speaker, so let me try to explain: "decompile a google app, modify it and post it on Github" that's my argument to say SmartYoutubeTV is a webwrapper: It's not using google's code, and the only way to do that, as far as I know, is to wrap it around youtube.com/tv . I'm not talking about you mate. This discussion is related to SmartYoutubeTV, what you do or don't do with your repositories is not my business.

fgl27 commented 5 years ago

@evertonstz you quote me with this

you can't

if you are quoting someone and writing "you", you are talking about me, I never told I would do that or told anyone to do that.

that is why I started the discussion read again I started with

btw no one is telling anyone to do anything @evertonstz , mostly anything related of what you wrote.

I'm solely bothered on the implication that you make regarding me.

and btw I born speaking the same language as you and never ever had any education on the english language why because I can't afford it so thank you for the free education, but I do know how to educate myself and know when to use "you" or "one" you could had just write

one can't just decompile a google app...

without quoting me, and the problem would never started.

do you get it now? the problem that you creating implying that I would do or request something to someone?