search

zabbix-community / helm-zabbix

Helm chart for Zabbix
https://artifacthub.io/packages/helm/zabbix-community/zabbix
Apache License 2.0
83 stars 48 forks source link

[zabbix-community/zabbix] Mysql missing #18

Open seanfariacustomink opened 1 year ago

seanfariacustomink commented 1 year ago

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. No mysql documentation, has it been dropped or just missing

Describe the solution you'd like Update docs to have mysql support for example: https://artifacthub.io/packages/helm/fermosit/zabbix-server-mysql/0.0.5

aeciopires commented 1 year ago

Hi @seanfariacustomink!

Despite knowing that Zabbix officially supports MySQL and other types of databases, this helm chart has only focused on PostgreSQL since the first commits. Supporting many databases in a helm chart requires a lot of technical effort and time.

If you have the proper knowledge and time to tweak this helm chart and make it flexible to support multiple database types, starting with MySQL, we'd be happy to review and test your changes.

Merry Christmas and have an excellent 2023 for you, your family and friends.

seanfariacustomink commented 1 year ago

Hi @aeciopires,

Seems like a lot of this work is already done, i.e. mysql-zabbix-helm-chart

seanfariacustomink commented 1 year ago

Hi @aeciopires, Rather than support MySQL or etc databases can the instructions be provided for someone to point to an existing MySQL DB?

aeciopires commented 1 year ago

Hi @seanfariacustomink!

Good idea. It's a better way. Do you agree @sa-ChristianAnton?

inggaboluna commented 1 year ago

Support for external dbs would be highly appreciate it.

xeberth commented 1 year ago

Our company is migrating most of its workloads to kubernetes, including zabbix.

In terms of offering a robust HA monitoring service, external database support is business critical. It allows us to connect self-managed AWS RDS databases that offer HA

ralfhauser commented 7 months ago

Support for external dbs would be highly appreciate it.

Also for us, currently most useful would be a helm-chart variant where the persistence (mariaDB or mysql) is outside k8s - any hints for this one ?

marijusGood commented 7 months ago

External DBs would help our team a lot. I've seen PRs that in part address this issue already https://github.com/zabbix-community/helm-zabbix/pull/25 We have tried to replace zabbix/zabbix-server-pgsql with a mysql one and our own DB but the server could not start. Is there some volume misconfiguration that we need to fix?

aeciopires commented 7 months ago

Hello @marijusGood @ralfhauser @xeberth @inggaboluna @seanfariacustomink!

I understand the importance of supporting MySQL/MariaDB and other databases supported by Zabbix.

But unfortunately I don't have the knowledge and time to implement this feature.

I made a lot of changes to the helm chart to unlock unique PostgreSQL configurations, but that's about it.

Another problem for us is running multiple tests on each database type with each new version of the chart. We do not have automated tests.

But if anyone has time to contribute, I'd appreciate it.

Have a nive week.