search

zakkinsey / PDFA-TEST

A test repository for PDFA members to learn and test gitHub actions and behaviors.
0 stars 0 forks source link

PDFUA-50: One caption for multiple content items #19

Open zakkinsey opened 5 years ago

zakkinsey commented 5 years ago

Jira issue originally created by user @:

Description: 

This example is intended to show two properly tagged graphics, contained in Figure tags, with an associated caption, properly tagged in a Caption tag.   In addition, because the single caption applies to both graphics, the Figure tags are grouped in a Div tag so as to indicate to assistive technology users that the caption relates to the contents of the Div. While not a requirement by the PDF specification, this would be considered a "best practice."  

zakkinsey commented 5 years ago

Comment created by @:

Attached PDF changed: is now an atomic example

zakkinsey commented 3 years ago

Comment created by @unknown-jira-user-3:

rejected as a div use case example.

Reason: There is not a single solution to handle this.

zakkinsey commented 3 years ago

Comment created by @PaulRayius:

Shouldn't the Div also contain the caption that accompanies the two figures? 

zakkinsey commented 3 years ago

Comment created by @PaulRayius:

Based on our conversation at the last meeting, I updated my Description.  I'm not sure, however, how to change the Status to indicate that it's ready for review.  

Also, I have another (related) issue with this example, as we discussed in our last meeting when I posed that question "Shouldn't the Caption also be in the Div."  I understand the explanation as to why it's not (so that it's not interpreted as being a caption for only one of the Figures).  That only works, however, in this very atomic example.  What if, for example, there was another Figure in the Tags tree, below the Caption?  How, then, would the relationship be established that the Caption goes with the two Figures above it and not the Figure below?  It seems to me a solution for that would be to then use another grouping tag to contain the Div and the Caption.  But we aren't conveying this information in this example.  

Maybe this is why the Status is set to "Not Accepted?"  

zakkinsey commented 2 years ago

Comment created by @PaulRayius:

I've reworded the tests and the description based on the change in use case (and title) to being focused on captions and not Div tag grouping.  That said, I think the file name, and the title, of the example PDF should be changed from "Div with 2 figures" to something like "Caption for multiple content items" (more in line with the name of this item.  

I still have the concern, though, as mentioned in my previous comment:   "What if, for example, there was another Figure in the Tags tree, below the Caption?  How, then, would the relationship be established that the Caption goes with the two Figures above it and not the Figure below?"  Do we need to address this in this example (or a different one)?