zakkinsey / PDFA-TEST

A test repository for PDFA members to learn and test gitHub actions and behaviors.
0 stars 0 forks source link

PDFUA-239: Similar real content inappropriately tagged #79

Closed zakkinsey closed 1 month ago

zakkinsey commented 1 year ago

Jira issue originally created by user @MarkusErle:

This example demonstrates the failure condition that applies when similar real content is not marked in a semantically appropriate manner. In this example, two paragraphs are wrongly tagged as one single P tag.

zakkinsey commented 1 year ago

Comment created by @MarkusErle:

Adjust title of example file.

zakkinsey commented 1 year ago

Comment created by @MarkusErle:

Title of example file refined.

zakkinsey commented 1 year ago

Comment created by @PaulRayius:

Looking at metadata, I added 09-003 (regarding role mapping) because the test procedures mention "role."  However, I did not add anything from Matterhorn about reading/ content order (like 09-001) because that's not specifically mentioned in the test procedures (even though this is a "logical content order" fundamental).  Also, for that reason, I'm not adding 1.3.2, from WCAG, to the metadata here. 

That's my interpretation on this.  Moving it along to review.  

(This is the same comment as in #153 and 238.)

zakkinsey commented 1 year ago

Comment created by @unknown-jira-user-2:

I suggest rewording the test instead of adding 09-003. See my comment on PDFUA-153 for details.

zakkinsey commented 4 months ago

Comment created by @PaulRayius:

I find the title confusing - "Similar real content..."  The issue here is that two paragraphs of content are tagged in a single P tag.  I wonder if the title should be something like "Two paragraphs of text incorrectly tagged in one P tag."