zakkinsey / pdfa-test-3

0 stars 0 forks source link

PDFUA-19: Expansion Text used to describe the lack of content #16

Closed zakkinsey closed 1 month ago

zakkinsey commented 5 years ago

Jira issue originally created by user @aubbink1:

The use of expansion text is used here to identify the lack of information. IE Box number. If that box is empty, it states "Box 20 Blank". In this case expansion text is used to explain what number "020" is as well as whether or not it contains a value.

Versus, number "018" which contains a value. In this case, expansion text is used to explain the number 18 only, it states "Box 18".

Each of these elements also contains the French text.

WCAG Success Criterion 3.1.4 (Abbreviations)

zakkinsey commented 5 years ago

Comment created by @:

{color:#000000}Evaluation with Acrobat and JAWS {color}

{color:#000000} {color}

{color:#000000}Adobe Acrobat DC (19.010.10059){color}

{color:#000000}JAWS Version 2018.1811.2 ILM{color}

{color:#000000}Windows 10{color}

{color:#000000} {color}

Problems:

- JAWS speaks the expansion text in both boxes mentioned 020 and 018, but the expansion text is followed by "/ Case 020 blank" and "/ Case 018", causing a duplication of the same info. So the expansion text is not helping. Perhaps not a good example.

 

Here is what JAWS reads:

 

MCDONALD M RONALD PO BOX 123 CORNERBROOK CORNERBROOK CB NL A2K 1H7 CAN A2K 1H7 Year Année 2014 T4A Statement of Pension, Retirement, Annuity, andOtherIncome État du revenudepension,deretraite, de renteoud'autressources Protected B when completed / Protégé B une fois rempli Payer's name Nom du payeur Box 016 / Case 016 Pension or superannuation-line 115 Prestations de retraite ou autrespensions-ligne115 14187.84 Box 022 / Case 022 Income tax deducted -line437 Impôt sur le revenu retenu ligne437 1318.20 Box 061 / Case 061 Payer's account number Numéro de compte du payeur 121491807RP0029 Box 018 / Case 018 Lump-sum payments -line 130 Paiements forfaitaires - ligne 130 12345.67 Box 020 blank / Case 020 blank Self-employed commissions Commissions d'un travail indépendant Box 012 / Case 012 Social insurance number Numéro d'assurance sociale 100 123 456 Box 013 / Case 013 Recipient's account number Numéro de compte du bénéficiaire 000000000RP0000 Box 024 blank / Case 024 blank Annuities Rentes Box 048 blank / Case 048 blank Fees for services Honoraires ou autres sommes pour services rendus Other information (see over) Autres renseignements (voir au verso) Box Case 032 Amount - Montant 880.62 Box Case 046 Amount Montan 1111.11 Box Case 118 Amount Montant 22222.22 Box Case 135 Amount Montant 448.32 Box Case 146 Amount Montant 333333.33 Box Case 148 Amount Montant 4444.44 Box

 

zakkinsey commented 5 years ago

Comment created by @aubbink1:

Hi Andres, apologies that sample should have had "Box 018 blank / Case 018 Vide" or  "Box 020 blank / Case 020 Vide". Vide being the missing component in this sample. Yes, very frustrating for the end user to have to listen to both languages for every tag.

zakkinsey commented 5 years ago

Comment created by @mrbhardy:

The review committee is rejecting this.  While this is a great document in concept, it is too complex and real world for the purposes of atomic examples. 

zakkinsey commented 5 years ago

Comment created by @aubbink1:

New example uploaded

zakkinsey commented 3 years ago

Comment created by @MarkusErle:

Rejected, because of:

it should be tagged as a table

we already have an Expansion text pass example PDFUA-148