zamojski / TowerCollector

The OpenCellID and MLS contributor's app.
Mozilla Public License 2.0
217 stars 27 forks source link

Everybody switch MLS uploads to BeaconDB #228

Open jidanni opened 2 months ago

jidanni commented 2 months ago

Everybody should turn off MLS uploads in Preferences.

Else the app will waste much time and data plan, only to give a failure message at the end.

EchedelleLR commented 1 month ago

I am unsure if you have kept updated (I know your message is a week older than that announcement) https://github.com/zamojski/TowerCollector/issues/223 but BeaconDB exists as an alternative and TowerCollector already allows using custom MLS service.

Instead of encouraging no contributing, I would encourage changing the MLS service to BeaconDB using the app settings designed for that purpose.

jidanni commented 1 month ago

OK, I found the instructions, https://beacondb.net/ .

Actually in Tower Collector Preferences there are two MLS related preferences, and it is not clear if we should switch the first one off.

Also in the final upload dialog, it is also not clear exactly which checkboxes should be checked.

And I did the most liberal combination of the above, and indeed it seems the upload went OK, but then there were still confusing error messages.

And any final success message says that we uploaded to MLS, but it didn't say exactly which MLS. The original one or the one that we custom set.

breversa commented 2 weeks ago

Will Tower Collector be updated to contribute to BeaconDB instead of MLS without user input (for those using the default setting, of course)? :)

I see no added value to:

  1. Keep MLS as it's retired
  2. NOT switch to a working alternative
lucasmz-dev commented 2 weeks ago

beacondb.net will most likely appreciate more awareness and contributors, giving it a little spotlight would be nice to make users aware, MLS is useless now, beacondb.net is meant to be much more resistant than MLS was, as there's supposed to be public dumps that are redacted for privacy that aren't just for cell networks but also Wi-Fi and Bluetooth.

Having a way to send data previously only sent to OpenCelliD would also be interesting

zamojski commented 1 week ago

I can change the default address to point to BeaconDB however I need to consult a few things with the owner.