search

zed-industries / zed

Code at the speed of thought – Zed is a high-performance, multiplayer code editor from the creators of Atom and Tree-sitter.
https://zed.dev
Other
47.18k stars 2.72k forks source link

iOS support for iPad #11889

Open jaanli opened 4 months ago

jaanli commented 4 months ago

Check for existing issues

Describe the feature

It would be super helpful to have iOS support, as collaborative editing is often made a lot easier with the screen and form factor of the iPad Pro.

Would this be possible? Happy to beta test / contribute if I can.

If applicable, add mockups / screenshots to help present your vision of the feature

Happy to submit a Figma user flow if needed :)

fwcd commented 2 months ago

Would love to see iOS support be a thing. The low-level graphics stack (Metal etc.) is very similar to macOS, so don't think a port would be that far out of reach[^1] as already mentioned in https://github.com/zed-industries/zed/issues/12039#issuecomment-2119789647.

[^1]: Also more feasible than e.g. Visual Studio Code, which is built on web tech (while the server version runs in Safari, there's no Electron for iOS and native UIs are generally nicer anyway).

jaanli commented 2 months ago

We at @onefact need this as well for our work with doctors.

Is there a WebAssembly port yet? We’d be happy to help contribute this.

fwcd commented 2 months ago

Is there a WebAssembly port yet?

https://github.com/zed-industries/zed/issues/12332#issuecomment-2134638801

anEXPer commented 1 month ago

I'm interested in this because I want to use Zed via a remote connection to either my home Mac Studio or a linux cloud workstation - both from an iPad pro, and, even more so, from a Vision Pro, which as I understand it is closer to an iOS device as well.

seniorgoogles commented 1 month ago

I'm interested in this because I want to use Zed via a remote connection to either my home Mac Studio or a linux cloud workstation - both from an iPad pro, and, even more so, from a Vision Pro, which as I understand it is closer to an iOS device as well.

me2

MastroPino commented 4 weeks ago

This would be a super killer feature with remote development and ciao ciao vscode

turbolent commented 2 weeks ago

I had a quick look into this:

This gets fairly far. However, it fails on wasmtime, which does not have support for iOS yet (In general, the inability to JIT code on non-macOS Apple platforms is going to be problematic):

wasmtime build errors ``` error: unknown directive | note: instantiated into assembly here --> :2:1 | 2 | .hidden wasmtime_fiber_start_21_0_1 | ^ error: unknown directive | note: instantiated into assembly here --> :4:1 | 4 | .type wasmtime_fiber_start_21_0_1,@function | ^ error: unknown directive | note: instantiated into assembly here --> :37:5 | 37 | .size wasmtime_fiber_start_21_0_1,.-wasmtime_fiber_start_21_0_1 | ^ error: unknown directive | note: instantiated into assembly here --> :39:1 | 39 | .hidden wasmtime_fiber_init_21_0_1 | ^ error: unknown directive | note: instantiated into assembly here --> :41:1 | 41 | .type wasmtime_fiber_init_21_0_1,@function | ^ error: unknown directive | note: instantiated into assembly here --> :61:9 | 61 | .size wasmtime_fiber_init_21_0_1,.-wasmtime_fiber_init_21_0_1 | ^ error: unknown directive | note: instantiated into assembly here --> :63:1 | 63 | .hidden wasmtime_fiber_switch_21_0_1 | ^ error: unknown directive | note: instantiated into assembly here --> :65:1 | 65 | .type wasmtime_fiber_switch_21_0_1,@function | ^ error: unknown directive | note: instantiated into assembly here --> :110:9 | 110 | .size wasmtime_fiber_switch_21_0_1,.-wasmtime_fiber_switch_21_0_1 | ^ error: ADR/ADRP relocations must be GOT relative | note: instantiated into assembly here --> :47:13 | 47 | adrp x17, _wasmtime_fiber_start_21_0_1 | ^ error: unknown AArch64 fixup kind! | note: instantiated into assembly here --> :47:13 | 47 | adrp x17, _wasmtime_fiber_start_21_0_1 | ^ error: unknown AArch64 fixup kind! | note: instantiated into assembly here --> :48:13 | 48 | add x17, x17, :lo12:_wasmtime_fiber_start_21_0_1 | ^ error: could not compile `wasmtime-fiber` (lib) due to 12 previous errors ```

I see at least two options:

mikayla-maki commented 2 weeks ago

Very excited for this!

turbolent commented 2 weeks ago

To start with, and also make it easier to port Zed to other platforms (e.g. WebAssembly), it might make sense to make it easier to port the "core" of Zed, i.e. putting the WebAssembly-based extension functionality behind a feature flag.

From looking at the commits, it seems like @maxdeviant and @maxbrunsfeld worked a lot on the extensions functionality: What do you think?

I'd be happy to start working on this

paclarap commented 1 week ago

If i may add - even if it is already out of active support - targeting iPad Pro 1. gen and orient on iPad 5th/6th gen as the common baseline might be the lowest as it gets while maintaing upwards compatibility and build a common denominator. Besides that these models are widespread and still in use.

In any case, happy to help testing!

P.s.: if iPhone will be intended to become a target the according models would be iPhone X/XS (for out-of-support iOS like 1. gen iPad) and iPhone XR (for supported iOS - like 6th gen iPad).

turbolent commented 1 week ago

Looks like the issue in wasmtime is bytecodealliance/wasmtime#8735