zed-industries / zed

Code at the speed of thought – Zed is a high-performance, multiplayer code editor from the creators of Atom and Tree-sitter.
https://zed.dev
Other
48.95k stars 2.95k forks source link

Include the Lapce editor on the Zed website #7725

Open nervenes opened 8 months ago

nervenes commented 8 months ago

Check for existing issues

Describe the feature

Lapce is another popular GUI code editor written in Rust that's growing in popularity. It would be fair to include this editor in the insertion latency, startup time and memory footprint tests. Here's why:

With that said, comparing the two can lead to two benefits:

Sublime is more so a legacy editor these days, CLion is aimed for power users with huge feature integrations, and VSC is a fair competition to go against but the majority of the users who cares enough to look for alternatives already knows VSC is a bloated browser. And so, I think competing more with Lapce 1-1 would be better.

If applicable, add mockups / screenshots to help present your vision of the feature

No response

AndydeCleyre commented 4 months ago

Sublime is more so a legacy editor these days

I am eagerly awaiting the development of any open source editor to offer me the features, performance, and resource usage of Sublime Text 4, which currently achieves either 2nd or 1st place in each of the metrics charted on Zed's homepage.

Aside from not understanding this take, I don't know what it adds to the issue description in any case. Unless you're requesting that ST4 be removed from the comparison? If so, I would push back against that, as I am looking to switch to Zed if and only if it ever out-competes ST4 specifically.

nervenes commented 4 months ago

I'm not requesting for any editor to be removed, I'm requesting to add another editor. Competition is a good thing, and Lapce is another open source GUI code editor written in Rust like Zed, that's also characterized by its performance like Zed, released around the same time as Zed, so it would be more than fair to include them in these benchmarks.

teotikalki commented 3 months ago

This is actually the only comparison I was looking for on that page... comparing yourself to incumbents is fine, but it's extremely relevant to compare yourself to your direct competition.

People leaving Atom/Suublime/VSCode/etc already know that they want something new or we wouldn't be at your site in the first place. I can't think that it's uncommon that someone is trying to decide which of Lapce/Zed to switch TO from any of those.