Command + Q doesn't work

zen-browser / desktop

🌀 Experience tranquillity while browsing the web without people tracking you!

https://zen-browser.app

Mozilla Public License 2.0

15.61k stars 373 forks source link

Command + Q doesn't work #1680

Closed the-shoemaker closed 2 weeks ago

the-shoemaker commented 3 weeks ago

Captchas

[X] I have read the instructions.
[X] I have searched existing issues and avoided creating duplicates.
[X] I am not filing an enhancement request.

What happened?

Since the newest update cmd + q, cmd + , and many more don't work anymore on macOS.

Reproducible?

[X] I have checked that this issue cannot be reproduced on Mozilla Firefox.

Version

1.0.1-a.4

What platform are you seeing the problem on?

macOS - aarch64

Relevant log output

No response

linear[bot] commented 3 weeks ago

ZEN-1711 Command + Q doesn't work

Nitrousoxide commented 3 weeks ago

cmd + f (which should be find/search the page) also instead goes fullscreen on mac.

the-shoemaker commented 3 weeks ago

cmd + f (which should be find/search the page) also instead goes fullscreen on mac.

I fixed that, by deleting the f11 shortcut for full-screen, which doesn't really make sense, it's all behaving very oddly. Also, you can get cmd + w and t back by double-clicking in the box to select the small "w" and replacing it with a large "W" by pressing shift. Somehow that works on a few of the basic browser shortcuts, but not everything.

vitusli commented 3 weeks ago

Same, basically all my shortcuts for mac are

a) gone, I had to set them up again b) basically no one works anymore, also not the ones I set up again (except for the most basic like cmt+t and cmd+w, cmd+opt+arrows do work)

There are many new options for shortcuts since the last update but really important like space and switch tab switching are gone. Probably just a temporary bug. I love your work and really appreciate every feature you add. Thank you so much.

chriskirknielsen commented 3 weeks ago

Just chiming in that Cmd+Q does something for me (Cmd+Q Catcher extension enabled notifies me of the attempt), however when disabling the extension, indeed, nothing happens. Additionally, as reported above, Cmd+F goes fullscreen instead of search, and Cmd+, does not open settings. I use shortcuts a lot, but so far, those are the ones that stand out.

the-shoemaker commented 3 weeks ago

Same, basically all my shortcuts for mac are

a) gone, I had to set them up again b) basically no one works anymore, also not the ones I set up again (except for the most basic like cmt+t and cmd+w, cmd+opt+arrows do work)

There are many new options for shortcuts since the last update but really important like space and switch tab switching are gone. Probably just a temporary bug. I love your work and really appreciate every feature you add. Thank you so much.

I also noticed that some shortcut boxes seem to be duplicated, so there are for example 2 full-screen options.

neonfuz commented 2 weeks ago

I'm pretty sure the cause of all of these bugs is Zen treating Cmd as Ctrl. They did it in an update. This is not how macos apps are supposed to work, they are supposed to be able to handle ctrl and cmd separately. On firefox you can do cmd+m to minimize, and ctrl+m to mute, without collisions. I really hope zen browser fixes this and returns macos keyboard functionality to how every other app works on macos.

neonfuz commented 2 weeks ago

I also noticed websites are capturing cmd when that does not happen on firefox on macos. For example, go to tiktok and try to close the tab with cmd+w. On the latest zen version this does not work, but on firefox for macos it does.

mauro-balades commented 2 weeks ago

Please follow the discussion here https://github.com/zen-browser/desktop/issues/1629, it might get fixed for the next release. Thanks!