search

zerotier / ZeroTierOne

A Smart Ethernet Switch for Earth
https://zerotier.com
Other
14.57k stars 1.71k forks source link

Excessive data usage when idling - even in lowBandwithMode and disconnected from all networks (MacOS) #2399

Open adam-ah opened 3 weeks ago

adam-ah commented 3 weeks ago

Problem

This has been reported multiple times but not been taken seriously enough and people moving to different VPN solutions:

Despite lowBandwithMode, the client is extremely chatty - sending and receiving substantial amount of data every 5s, even if not connected to any networks.

Service running, networks disconnected:

Screenshot 2024-11-01 at 2 11 16 pm

Service shut down:

Screenshot 2024-11-01 at 2 13 48 pm

local config:

zerotier-cli info -j | grep low

   "allowTcpFallbackRelay": true,
   "lowBandwidthMode": true,

Recommended solution(s)

Felix14-v2 commented 2 weeks ago

It consumes about 3 Mb/s on my Windows 11 system without any connected networks, that's just unacceptable image

glimberg commented 2 weeks ago

@adam-ah what version of ZeroTier were you running? There was an issue in 1.14.1 where the low bandwidth mode setting was being ignored. That's been resolved in 1.14.2

glimberg commented 2 weeks ago

@Felix14-v2 Can you give us more details about your environment? It makes no sense for ZT to be using that much bandwidth without being connected to a network. That screenshot looks like there's a network with an active transfer happening..

Normal ambient data usage without being connected to a network should be less than 1KB/sec.

adam-ah commented 2 weeks ago

@glimberg Unsure what version sorry, I already uninstalled, and the filename / installer does not disclose version number. I downloaded the latest package from the official website on 1 Nov: SHA1 (ZeroTier One.pkg) = dca599f81b575dc1ce510b80bc2c31515849403b SHA256 (ZeroTier One.pkg) = 018e2368cf1f571606ad173339910470d3e253854b0bdb51b81b18d3c3105edd MD5 (ZeroTier One.pkg) = de5fc3a11d6f0bd1167006c277c98a18

Regardless of a bug with low bandwidth or not, I still stand by my original bug report and suggested solutions, as

It not only wakes up the radio on small and embedded devices leading to battery drain, it uses often expensive data for no reason (I hate comparing it to other products because ZeroTier is a fantastic idea and implementation, but WG, TailScale, ZeoTrust WARP all work as expected in this regard).

On another note, the "less than 1KB/sec" still adds up to 1KB 3600 24 =~ 84MB/day. A disconnected client's acceptable use is approx. 0KB/day.

Felix14-v2 commented 2 weeks ago

It makes no sense for ZT to be using that much bandwidth without being connected to a network. That screenshot looks like there's a network with an active transfer happening

The issue is that my only network has definitely been disconnected this time, that was the first thing I checked. And after having ho success, I had to completely disable the ZeroTier service to avoid such a huge network usage. Unfortunately I can't provide steps to reproduce the issue, because this bug happens randomly, but disabling networks definitely doesn't change anything:

https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/3ee21f63-fcad-4c14-afec-c57bef568713

All I can say is that this time I couldn't connect to my printing server via ZeroTier because of some weirdness with my connection (CONNECTION_TIMED_OUT), and this happened.

I'll try to update ZeroTier (just noticed that I hadn't updated it from 1.14.0 on this PC). Let me know if you need any more specific information, I just don't know what could be useful. And thanks for the answer!

UPD: still happens in 1.14.2

Felix14-v2 commented 2 weeks ago

I noticed that actually ZeroTier stops destroying my bandwidth after some time if the network is disconnected, so this 1-5Mb/s data is just an overhead? As you can see from the demo above, the payload is about 0.1Mb/s, I don't believe this is an intended behavior.