Questions on code (ATL)

[anjugopinath]

Could you answer the below questions please?

1. What do the following keywords in lib/ult/ult.py indicate?

i) Neg_select ii) pos_h_boxes iii) neg_h_boxes iv) pattern_type v) pattern_channel

2. In which file do you mention the input path for the training dataset? In this case, 'HOI-CL/Data/hico_20160224_det/images/train2015/' ? I executed python tools/Train_ATL_HOCO.py

Thank You.

[zhihou7]

Sorry for the confusing variable name.

Following iCAN, we augment the no_interaction samples. E.g., if the image includes a person, an apple and a desk, the Dataset has annotated <person, eat, apple>, but not annotated <person, no_interaction, desk>. Then, we augment the data via adding the pair <person, no_interaction, desk>, i.e., negative samples.

i) Neg_select: This is following the code of iCAN (https://arxiv.org/abs/1808.10437). Neg_select is related to Pos_augment. Pos_augment is the number of pos HOI samples (annotated samples), while Neg_augment is the number of negative HOI samples (augmented no-interaction samples, i.e. the no_interaction samples that do not exist in the annotation). augment means we augment the box via random crop. ii) pos_h_boxes: This is corresponding to pos_augment. iii) neg_h_boxes: This is the human boxes of negative interaction samples (augmented no_interaction samples) iv) pattern_type: This is useless. pattern_type is fix to 0. This is redundant code. v) pattern_channel: This is useless. In the released code, pattern_channel is fix to 2.

We use the path in utl.py, Test_HICO.py (test), tools.py (co-occurrence matrix). You can search "cfg.DATA_DIR" in these files.

Sorry for the confusing code. Feel free to ask questions if you have any questions.

[anjugopinath]

Hi,

Thank You for the quick response! I had some more questions. Thank You in advance.

1) I put a breakpoint inside this function. But, it wasn't hit. What is it used for? def Generate_action_HICO(actionlist): action = np.zeros(600) for GT_idx in actionlist: action[GTidx] = 1 action = action.reshape(1, 600) return action

If I need to train ATL on a new dataset, are the 2 .pkl files listed below the only 2 additional input files that are required apart from the images itself? Also, could you explain what the annotations are?

2) Trainval_Neg_HICO.pkl

3) Trainval_GT_HICO.pkl

Thank You.

[zhihou7]

The two files are annotations.

Trainval_Neg_HICO.pkl is the annotation for negative samples (augment unlabeled no_interaction) Trainval_GT_HICO.pkl is the annotation for positive samples (annotated instances).

in Trainval_Neg_HICO.pkl, the key is the image id, the value is <image_id, HOI_category, human_box, object_box, ...> . We do not use the other number.

Trainval_GT_HICO.pkl is a list. each item represent an annotation: <image_id, HOI_category, human_box, object_box, ...> We do not use the other number.

[anjugopinath]

Hi,

In this image: The person is interacting with the glass bottle and the pipe. There are other bottles, a grater, a scrubber, knife etc. Should I add 'no_interaction' annotations for every item for which there is no interaction? In that case, should I say no_interaction for bottle? Since, there is another bottle that is interacting.

[zhihou7]

Yes, for the other bottle (no interaction and no annotation), we currently include this no_interaction in Trainval_Neg_HICO.pkl when we have the object boxes (bottle), that's negative samples.

[anjugopinath]

Hi,

Thank You for the reply. Can I train the model if I do not have Trainval_Neg annotations for the new dataset I am using?

[zhihou7]

You can train the model. But you might suffer from imbalance/label missing problem. For affordance recognition, I find the effect of removing negative samples is limited.

[anjugopinath]

Hi, Thank You for the reply. Can you answer the below questions please? 1.

2. 

Can you explain the contents of the above two .pkl files? Specifically, the mapping, for ex- 0:0, 1:0 etc. Also, how are they related to the below 5 files?

3. hico_list_obj.txt

4. hico_list_vb.txt

5. hico_list_hoi.txt

6. 24_verbs.txt

7. 21_verbs.txt

8. What is prior_mask.pkl used for?

9. Is hoi_coco_list_num.txt required when training for ATL?

Thank You.

[zhihou7]

hoi_to_obj.pkl and hoi_to_verb.pkl store the co-occurence matrix in HICO-DET, i.e. which object and verb are corresponding to a HOI. the name of the id in hoi_to_obj.pkl and hoi_to_verb.pkl are provides in hico_list_obj.txt, hico_list_vb.txt, hico_list_hoi.txt respectively. Noticeabley, the id in pkl files starts from 0 while the id in txt files starts from 1.

24_verbs.txt and 21_verbs.txt illustrate the name of verbs in V-COCO (HOI-COCO).

prior_mask.pkl is similar to hoi_to_obj.pkl, but is for V-COCO. prior_mask.pkl is providd in previous works.

hoi_coco_list_num.txt is not required for training ATL. hoi_coco_list_num.txt just demonstrates the long-tailed distribution.

[anjugopinath]

Thank You for your reply. Do I need to create 24_verbs.txt,21_verbs.txt and prior_mask.pkl for training ATL?

[anjugopinath]

1.What is the difference between self.num_classes = 600 and self.compose_num_classes = 600? in ResNet101_HICO.py inside class ResNet101()

2. Are the weights in self.HO_weight (size 1 by 600) randomly initialized?

I saw this comment: "We copy from TIN. calculated by log(1/(n_c/sum(n_c)) c is the category and n_c is the number of positive samples." What is TIN?

[zhihou7]

"num_classes" are annotated class number, while "self.compose_num_classes" is how many types of HOIs you want to compose (that can be larger than self.num_classes or smaller than self.num_classes).

TIN is Transferable Interactiveness knowledge for Human-Object Interaction Detection. The weights aim at balancing the data. it is a traditional re-balance strategy for imbalance data.