zivid / zivid-ros

Official ROS driver for Zivid 3D cameras
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
62 stars 46 forks source link

NaN values in depth data #92

Closed scotgopal closed 1 month ago

scotgopal commented 1 year ago

I've realised that the 32FC1 encoded depth data has some NaN values. May I know what is the significance of this data? And what is the situation that may cause Zivid to record this data?

Hole filling was enabled prior to recording this data, so that is not helping to avoid NaN values in depth data. Is there any other config that I can set to avoid it from appearing in my depth data?

Thank you.

scotgopal commented 11 months ago

Hi there. Can anyone of you help with this issue please?

@ajlandau @nedrebo @eskaur

eskaur commented 11 months ago

Hi @scotgopal !

A Zivid point-cloud is a "Structured Point Cloud" with a set of (X,Y,Z) values for each pixel in the camera. There are several reasons why a pixel may have (X,Y,Z) = (nan,nan,nan). The most common ones are:

While you could in theory get rid of the first cause by turning off all filters (not a good idea generally), the second cause will always be present: It is impossible for us to successfully reconstruct (X,Y,Z) for all pixels in the camera for any given scene due to the "projector shadow" effect.

Thus, there will always be some NaN Z-values in a Zivid point cloud, and the user has to accommodate for that in whatever algorithm consumes the point cloud.

Tip: If your algorithm is fine with an Unstructured Point Cloud (basically just a linear list of points) you can get a NaN-free point cloud by looping over all our points and only copying over the ones that are non-NaN.

apartridge commented 1 month ago

Closing issue as this is not a bug.