Open kayD opened 1 year ago
1) "Not applicable" is bad label. I'll rename it to "Unusable" 2) I'll change to "No parking/private"
Please excuse my ignorance, but I don't understand "Unusable":
I thought that the main use case for the map would be the first (people in need of parking space advice). If this is the case, then mapping problems should be visible (as "cannot tell"/"error"), but should not probably not be the most pronounced display.
@zlant I am a bit confused about the code. I thing this might be a mixup from the v1 vs. v2 schema. In the current version (v2-code path) does not use the :condition
schema anymore
Former… parking:condition=* tagging was deprecated and should no longer be used.
(Source)
… however the code uses the term condition
extensively. The tooltip also still talks about :condition
based on the hard coded https://github.com/zlant/parking-lanes/blob/master/src/parking/controls/Legend.tsx#L37
However, the tags for the road at https://zlant.github.io/parking-lanes/#18/49.85089/9.95935 are a simple parking:left=no
.
I think the code for the current (v2) schema actually looks at the physical "parking position" (not the legal aspect) which is defined in https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Street_parking#Parking_position as as simple
There is no parking. This refers only to the physical presence of a parking lanes, not the legal condition.
Therefore, the label could be "No parking (unspecified)" indicating that there the legal reason why there is no parking (which would be described by tags like access
, fee
, restriction
… (Wiki)) is not specified.
This label would still make it hard to separate it from the value =no_parking
which also says "No parking" but referring to the legal aspect.
Maybe "No parking (no infrastructure)" is better to clarify the reason for the "no".
The "not applicable" label in the legend is problematic:
https://zlant.github.io/parking-lanes/#18/49.85138/9.96014![image](https://github.com/zlant/parking-lanes/assets/316554/34ac4fb7-fcba-4103-8223-8142ea5587fb)
The two issues are:
parking:left=no
-- unclear what "not applicable" in the legend should mean to the user of the map.access=private
-- it is a company parking lot, even with a fence and gate around the property.