search

zotero / zotero-bits

CSL-related community feedback for Zotero
56 stars 8 forks source link

Remap Podcast to broadcast #83

Closed bwiernik closed 5 years ago

bwiernik commented 6 years ago

At least in its contemporary usage, podcasts are much more similar to radio broadcasts than they are to musical recordings, especially in terms of citation requirements (specific dates, serialization, etc.). In Zotero, it would be good to remap podcast to broadcast rather than to song as it is now.

dstillman commented 5 years ago

Closed in https://github.com/zotero/zotero/commit/bf4deeff8fb94fff253a1a47d2cff94f9f4fba9c

dstillman commented 5 years ago

After making this change, a podcast item exported to CSL JSON includes collection-title for the Series Title, but the item is reimported as TV Broadcast and that field is lost. I assume there's nothing to do about that now, but should Series Title be added to TV Broadcast? I didn't see that in a quick glance at the open issues.

bwiernik commented 5 years ago

No, Series Title for Podcast should be remapped to container-title. It is analogous to the Program Title field for TV Broadcast.

dstillman commented 5 years ago

Hmm, is that right? That's a bit problematic if so. Series Title and Program Title aren't equivalent fields in Zotero. Series Title is just Series Title, and it exports to collection-title from any item type. Program Title is a base-mapped field for Publication Title, which gets exported as container-title.

bwiernik commented 5 years ago

The choice of fields generally for Podcast don’t make much sense. There is no field for “Program Title” of the podcast as a whole, rather than the episode (analogous to TV Broadcast).

Series Title doesn’t make much conceptual conceptual sense for TV Broadcast or Podcast. It would be the name for a collection of related episodes within the broader Program Title (e.g., perhaps the name of a five-episode arc or special report). I’m not sure that these are common enough to warrant a field. If they are included “Series Title” is a very confusing label for that—I imagine most users would not know what the difference between “Program Title” and “Series Title” would be.

dstillman commented 5 years ago

OK, so it would be better to just migrate seriesTitle to programTitle in podcast?

bwiernik commented 5 years ago

Yes.