search

zxdavb / ramses_rf

An interface for the RAMSES RF protocol, as used by Honeywell-compatible HVAC & CH/DHW systems.
MIT License
58 stars 15 forks source link

Orcon ventilation: 31D9 payload not recognized, wrong fan modes #45

Closed maleadt closed 1 year ago

maleadt commented 2 years ago

I'm looking into using this (awesome!) software with my Orcon HRC-350 (sold to me under the brand Ventiline) through an Arduino running evofw3, and am encountering a couple of issues.

The first is a payload that isn't recognized. When I set the ventilation fan speed to respectively away, 1, 2, 3, or auto, encoded as fan modes 0 to 4, my unit responds with a 31D9 message where the payload is simply either 00000000, 00000100, 00000200, 00000300 or 00000400. That doesn't match the regex in ramses.py, which seems to expect much more data:

23:13:48.670 || HVC:150155 |  32:134044 |  I | switch_speed     |      || {'rate': 0.0, '_step_idx': 0, '_step_max': 4, 'fan_mode': 'standby'}
23:13:48.689  I --- 32:134044 --:------ 32:134044 31D9 004 00000000 < Corrupt payload: Payload doesn't match '^(00|01|21)[0-9A-F]{4}((00|FE)(00|20){12}(00|08))?$': 00000000

23:04:28.570 || HVC:150155 | HVC:134044 |  I | switch_speed     |      || {'rate': 0.25, '_step_idx': 1, '_step_max': 4, 'fan_mode': 'auto'}
23:04:28.598  I --- 32:134044 --:------ 32:134044 31D9 004 00000100 < Corrupt payload: Payload doesn't match '^(00|01|21)[0-9A-F]{4}((00|FE)(00|20){12}(00|08))?$': 00000100

23:04:34.219 || HVC:150155 | HVC:134044 |  I | switch_speed     |      || {'rate': 0.5, '_step_idx': 2, '_step_max': 4, 'fan_mode': 'low'}
23:04:34.251  I --- 32:134044 --:------ 32:134044 31D9 004 00000200 < Corrupt payload: Payload doesn't match '^(00|01|21)[0-9A-F]{4}((00|FE)(00|20){12}(00|08))?$': 00000200

23:04:38.197 || HVC:150155 | HVC:134044 |  I | switch_speed     |      || {'rate': 0.75, '_step_idx': 3, '_step_max': 4, 'fan_mode': 'medium'}
23:04:38.223  I --- 32:134044 --:------ 32:134044 31D9 004 00000300 < Corrupt payload: Payload doesn't match '^(00|01|21)[0-9A-F]{4}((00|FE)(00|20){12}(00|08))?$': 00000300

23:13:51.928 || HVC:150155 |  32:134044 |  I | switch_speed     |      || {'rate': 1.0, '_step_idx': 4, '_step_max': 4, 'fan_mode': 'high'}
23:13:51.956  I --- 32:134044 --:------ 32:134044 31D9 004 00000400 < Corrupt payload: Payload doesn't match '^(00|01|21)[0-9A-F]{4}((00|FE)(00|20){12}(00|08))?$': 00000400

This also shows that the fan modes are not mapped correctly: 0 is away, 1-3 match fan speed 1 to 3, and 4 should be auto (fan speed determined by air humidity).

The much more complicated 31DA packets are fully recognized though 🙂 The rendering in the CLI is cut off though (maybe it could drop fields that are known to be bogus for this model?):

23:13:55.251 || HVC:134044 |            |  I | vent_31da        |      || {'exhaust_fan_speed': 0.15, 'remaining_time': 0.0, 'co2_level': None, 'indoor_humidity': 0.51, 'air_quality': None, 'air_quality_b

Finally, I also encountered the following packet with a prompt to file an issue:

23:13:59.371 RP --- 32:134044 18:201242 --:------ 10E0 038 000001C87D140D67FEFFFFFFFFFF170C07E3564D442D3135524D533634000000000000000000 < Support the development of ramses_rf by reporting this packet, with the make/model of device: 32:134044 (device type 32 not known to have signature: 0001C87D140D67FEFF)

Let me know if you need additional information.

maleadt commented 2 years ago

Here's a more complete trace, trying all the buttons on my remote:

client.py: Starting ramses_rf...
11:08:16.605 It is strongly recommended to provide a known_list, and use it as a whitelist (device_id filter), configure: enforce_known_list = True
11:08:16.608 Not using any device filter: using a known_list (as a whitelist) is strongly recommended)
11:08:16.641 || HGI:201242 | NUL:262142 |  I | puzzle_packet    |      || {'datetime': '2022-05-10T11:08:16.608', 'engine': 'v0.20.0', 'parser': 'v0.20.0'}

# power-on device
11:08:21.617 || HVC:134044 |            |  I | message_042f     |      || {'counter_1': '0x0104', 'counter_3': '0x0004', 'counter_5': '0x0105', 'unknown_7': '0x5E30'}
11:08:21.663 || HGI:201242 | HVC:134044 | RQ | device_info      |      || {}
11:08:21.759  I --- 32:134044 63:262142 --:------ 10E0 038 000001C87D140D67FEFFFFFFFFFF170C07E3564D442D3135524D533634000000000000000000 < Support the development of ramses_rf by reporting this packet, with the make/model of device: 32:134044 (device type 32 not known to have signature: 0001C87D140D67FEFF)
11:08:21.758 || HVC:134044 | NUL:262142 |  I | device_info      |      || {'date_2': '0000-00-00', 'date_1': '2019-12-23', 'product_id': '7D', 'oem_code': '67', 'description': 'VMD-15RMS64'}
11:08:21.861 || HGI:201242 | HVC:134044 | RQ | device_info      |      || {}
11:08:23.723 || HGI:201242 | HVC:134044 | RQ | device_info      |      || {}
11:08:25.705 PktProtocolQos.send_data(sent=10E0|RQ|32:134044): boff=3, want=10E0|RP|32:134044, tout=2022-05-10T11:08:25.701: QoS: IS_EXPIRED (giving up) (2/2)
11:08:42.494  I --- 32:134044 --:------ 32:134044 31D9 004 000001FE < Corrupt payload: Payload doesn't match '^(00|01|21)[0-9A-F]{4}((00|FE)(00|20){12}(00|08))?$': 000001FE
11:08:51.537 || HVC:134044 |            |  I | vent_31da        |      || {'exhaust_fan_speed': 0.15, 'remaining_time': 0.0, 'co2_level': None, 'indoor_humidity': 0.52, 'air_quality': None, 'air_quality_b

# press 'away'
11:09:14.037 || HVC:150155 | HVC:134044 |  I | switch_speed     |      || {'rate': 0.0, '_step_idx': 0, '_step_max': 4, 'fan_mode': 'standby'}
11:09:14.062  I --- 32:134044 --:------ 32:134044 31D9 004 000000FE < Corrupt payload: Payload doesn't match '^(00|01|21)[0-9A-F]{4}((00|FE)(00|20){12}(00|08))?$': 000000FE
11:09:14.100 || HGI:201242 | HVC:150155 | RQ | device_info      |      || {}
11:09:14.595 || HVC:134044 |            |  I | vent_31da        |      || {'exhaust_fan_speed': 0.1, 'remaining_time': 0.0, 'co2_level': None, 'indoor_humidity': 0.52, 'air_quality': None, 'air_quality_ba
11:09:16.105 || HGI:201242 | HVC:150155 | RQ | device_info      |      || {}
11:09:18.111 || HGI:201242 | HVC:150155 | RQ | device_info      |      || {}
11:09:20.090 PktProtocolQos.send_data(sent=10E0|RQ|29:150155): boff=3, want=10E0|RP|29:150155, tout=2022-05-10T11:09:20.089: QoS: IS_EXPIRED (giving up) (2/2)

# press '1'
11:09:24.227 || HVC:150155 | HVC:134044 |  I | switch_speed     |      || {'rate': 0.25, '_step_idx': 1, '_step_max': 4, 'fan_mode': 'auto'}
11:09:24.258  I --- 32:134044 --:------ 32:134044 31D9 004 000001FE < Corrupt payload: Payload doesn't match '^(00|01|21)[0-9A-F]{4}((00|FE)(00|20){12}(00|08))?$': 000001FE
11:09:24.610 || HVC:134044 |            |  I | vent_31da        |      || {'exhaust_fan_speed': 0.15, 'remaining_time': 0.0, 'co2_level': None, 'indoor_humidity': 0.52, 'air_quality': None, 'air_quality_b

# press '2'
11:09:32.185 || HVC:150155 | HVC:134044 |  I | switch_speed     |      || {'rate': 0.5, '_step_idx': 2, '_step_max': 4, 'fan_mode': 'low'}
11:09:32.214  I --- 32:134044 --:------ 32:134044 31D9 004 000002FE < Corrupt payload: Payload doesn't match '^(00|01|21)[0-9A-F]{4}((00|FE)(00|20){12}(00|08))?$': 000002FE

# press '3'
11:09:39.010 || HVC:150155 | HVC:134044 |  I | switch_speed     |      || {'rate': 0.75, '_step_idx': 3, '_step_max': 4, 'fan_mode': 'medium'}
11:09:39.038  I --- 32:134044 --:------ 32:134044 31D9 004 000003FE < Corrupt payload: Payload doesn't match '^(00|01|21)[0-9A-F]{4}((00|FE)(00|20){12}(00|08))?$': 000003FE
11:09:44.656 || HVC:134044 |            |  I | vent_31da        |      || {'exhaust_fan_speed': 0.55, 'remaining_time': 0.0, 'co2_level': None, 'indoor_humidity': 0.52, 'air_quality': None, 'air_quality_b

# press '4'
11:09:49.253 || HVC:150155 | HVC:134044 |  I | switch_speed     |      || {'rate': 1.0, '_step_idx': 4, '_step_max': 4, 'fan_mode': 'high'}
11:09:49.274  I --- 32:134044 --:------ 32:134044 31D9 004 000004FE < Corrupt payload: Payload doesn't match '^(00|01|21)[0-9A-F]{4}((00|FE)(00|20){12}(00|08))?$': 000004FE
11:09:54.667 || HVC:134044 |            |  I | vent_31da        |      || {'exhaust_fan_speed': 0.15, 'remaining_time': 0.0, 'co2_level': None, 'indoor_humidity': 0.52, 'air_quality': None, 'air_quality_b

# press 'timer'
11:09:58.896 || HVC:150155 | HVC:134044 |  I | switch_duration  |      || {'flags': [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0], 'minutes': 15, '_new_speed_mode': 'per_vent_speed', '_fallback_speed_mode': None, 'rate': 0.75
11:09:58.919  I --- 32:134044 --:------ 32:134044 31D9 004 000003FE < Corrupt payload: Payload doesn't match '^(00|01|21)[0-9A-F]{4}((00|FE)(00|20){12}(00|08))?$': 000003FE
11:09:59.687 || HVC:134044 |            |  I | vent_31da        |      || {'exhaust_fan_speed': 0.55, 'remaining_time': 15.0, 'co2_level': None, 'indoor_humidity': 0.52, 'air_quality': None, 'air_quality_

The replies are now different (000001FE instead of 00000100, etc).

packet.log

zxdavb commented 2 years ago

The issue is that none of this protocol is documented.

I have updated the code, so that it can parse your packet log without error/warning. I will be dropping a refactored build soon.

The client.py is for ad-hoc, you can:

cat packet.log | python client.py parse > msg.out

I will reach out to you shortly, when I have capacity

maleadt commented 2 years ago

Thanks, confirmed that current master parses the vent_status messages now (although it decodes the fan mode as exhaust_fan_speed):

09:13:39.893 || HVC:134044 |            |  I | vent_status      |      || {'flags': [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0], 'exhaust_fan_speed': 0.005, 'passive': False, 'damper_only': False, 'filter_dirty': False, 'frost_cycle': False, 'has_fault': False, '_unknown_3': 'FE'}
zxdavb commented 2 years ago

BTW, the fan modes may be wrong for your orcon-compatible HRU (or the 15RF), but they were OK for the system I had access to before (a Nuaire PIV)...

I think the way forward is to get it working with your system, then use the traits feature to provide fro any difference.

zxdavb commented 2 years ago

@maleadt The time has come to get remotes working... Please tell me the make/model of your remote

The latest version of the client.py has a new switch, -lf, which you may like.

zxdavb commented 2 years ago

@llevering could you tell me the exact make/model of your remote and your vent unit?

Or is it a fancy CO2 sensor?

maleadt commented 2 years ago

Please tell me the make/model of your remote

An Orcon 15RF (the device also mentions VMN-15LF01, 21800000, 2002, H6S9). The plain model, without CO2 sensor.

llevering commented 2 years ago

@zxdavb I thought I did reply earlier, but it seems I forget the sent my comment.

I have an Orcon 15RF simple remote like @maleadt the vent unit is a Orcon MVS 15RHB, with a humidity sensor. I upgraded to 20.9 today.

zxdavb commented 2 years ago

@llevering Can you confirm your remote does not have a CO2 sensor - it looks like it has one to me: 

2021-11-28T09:46:51.619824 083  I --- 37:258565 37:261128 --:------ 22F1 003 000404
2021-11-28T09:48:40.337879 082  I --- 37:258565 --:------ 37:258565 1298 003 0002F7
2021-11-28T09:49:33.668304 085  I --- 37:258565 37:261128 --:------ 31E0 004 00000100
2021-11-28T09:49:41.282669 082  I --- 37:258565 --:------ 37:258565 1298 003 00030B
2021-11-28T09:49:48.897074 081  I --- 37:258565 37:261128 --:------ 2E10 003 000100

It also has a movement/presence sensor?

Or maybe that device isn't yours?

llevering commented 2 years ago

I can confirm it does not have a co2 sensor. There are versions that have one but it ours doesn't.

From: David Bonnes @.> Sent: Tuesday, July 5, 2022 6:41:34 PM To: zxdavb/ramses_rf @.> Cc: llevering @.>; Mention @.> Subject: Re: [zxdavb/ramses_rf] Orcon ventilation: 31D9 payload not recognized, wrong fan modes (Issue #45)

@lleveringhttps://github.com/llevering Can you confirm your remote does not have a CO2 sensor - it looks like it has one to me:

2021-11-28T09:46:51.619824 083 I --- 37:258565 37:261128 --:------ 22F1 003 000404 2021-11-28T09:48:40.337879 082 I --- 37:258565 --:------ 37:258565 1298 003 0002F7 2021-11-28T09:49:33.668304 085 I --- 37:258565 37:261128 --:------ 31E0 004 00000100 2021-11-28T09:49:41.282669 082 I --- 37:258565 --:------ 37:258565 1298 003 00030B 2021-11-28T09:49:48.897074 081 I --- 37:258565 37:261128 --:------ 2E10 003 000100

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/zxdavb/ramses_rf/issues/45#issuecomment-1175265792, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAVUDMVGGMC6HHHKUGCYDBDVSRQT5ANCNFSM5VPRAXJA. You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

zxdavb commented 2 years ago

May I have a copy of your known_list?

zxdavb commented 1 year ago

No response - closing.