ACCESS-NRI / access-hive.org.au

Documentation hub for the Earth System models, ACCESS, and their community
https://access-hive.org.au/
8 stars 12 forks source link

ACCESS-OM2 Model Run: Added top level "About" section #681

Closed aidanheerdegen closed 2 months ago

aidanheerdegen commented 2 months ago

Description

Added top level About section.

Fixes #680

github-actions[bot] commented 2 months ago

PR Preview :---: 🛬 Link removed because the pull request was closed. 2024-05-10 15:30 AEST

atteggiani commented 2 months ago

Thank you for this @aidanheerdegen. I think it's a great idea.

I changed the base to development instead of main. I am going to review it next week (mainly change link to markdown and re-style the button).

atteggiani commented 2 months ago

@aidanheerdegen

I saw that you created your branch from main. Before my review, can you please rebase from development?

aidanheerdegen commented 2 months ago

Before my review, can you please rebase from development?

Done.

aidanheerdegen commented 2 months ago

@paigem this is the PR to update the OM2 model run docs

paigem commented 2 months ago

This looks great @aidanheerdegen and @atteggiani! I'm going to add a couple small comments here, since I don't want to slow this process down as I remember how to contribute to an open PR (sorry - I guess I need to review some GitHub training! 😅).

aidanheerdegen commented 2 months ago

Those are all good suggestions @paigem.

On this specific question:

Kelsey also suggested adding a link to the model code. I actually couldn't find the model code - it looks like it's all neatly packaged in this repo, where cloning this repo and running a few commands will run the model on Gadi. Is the model code available somewhere, and is that something worth linking to?

The model code resides in a number of different repositories. They're linked in the README:

ACCESS-OM2 consists of the MOM 5 ocean model, CICE 5 sea ice model, and a file-based atmosphere called YATM coupled together using OASIS3-MCT v2.0.

But it could be more explicit. e.g. as a table, with a column being a link to the code repo.

Note we also don't specify a version in this page because there is no single canonical version: there are 12 configurations which could all have slightly different versions, with slightly different versions of the actual model.

Did I mention it was complex?

paigem commented 2 months ago

Thanks @aidanheerdegen!

But it could be more explicit. e.g. as a table, with a column being a link to the code repo.

Thanks - you're right that it makes sense now that we just link out to each component's code. 🤦‍♀️ What might make it slightly clearer is to, instead of having the links on the name of the models (I thought those links would go to information about the model, rather than model code), to have in parentheses after each model is listed "(link to MOM5 code)", for example, to make it clear where the links direct to. But, I think this is minor and not worth worrying about now - the information is there and quite readable as is.

aidanheerdegen commented 2 months ago

What might make it slightly clearer is to, instead of having the links on the name of the models (I thought those links would go to information about the model, rather than model code), to have in parentheses after each model is listed "(link to MOM5 code)", for example, to make it clear where the links direct to

I agree. It's what I was getting at with the table, but I explained badly. Feel free to make an issue to improve the README in that repo. It won't get fixed otherwise.

atteggiani commented 2 months ago

Thank you @paigem for the suggestions.

I committed your suggestions

The instructions below outline how to run the model using ACCESS-NRI's software deployment pipeline, specifically designed to run on the National Computating Infrastructure's (NCI's) Gadi supercomputer.

with minor modifications:

The instructions below outline how to run the ACCESS-OM2 using ACCESS-NRI's software deployment pipeline, specifically designed to run on the National Computating Infrastructure (NCI) supercomputer Gadi.

I also changed the Github button text to "ACCESS-OM2 configurations".

If no more modifications are required, I will merge this PR around 3:30pm today.

Thank you! @aidanheerdegen

paigem commented 2 months ago

This all looks great @atteggiani! All my comments have been addressed - thanks! 😊

atteggiani commented 2 months ago

Also rebased with development