Anuken / Mindustry-Suggestions

Repository for Mindustry suggestions and feedback
130 stars 58 forks source link

Segment is dominated by Mend Projector + Thorium Wall #624

Closed Daniel-Chin closed 3 years ago

Daniel-Chin commented 4 years ago

Describe what you would like changed, and why.

Even after being buffed (see this issue), Segment, I think, is still too weak. Here I show that Mend Projector + Thorium Wall dominates Segment.
A Segment can destroy 6 bullets per second and consumes 480 power/s. (This takes 4 tiles of space.)
Using the same amount of energy, you can afford 5.33 Mend Projectors, healing 588 HP/s to a Large Thorium Wall. Compared to this, Segment is like a joke. Let alone multiple Thorium Walls can be healed simultaneously. Let alone Segment cannot intercept melee/laser/shock attacks.
The only downside is the extra space (~21 tiles of space) required. However, you can arguably place your Mend Projector much farther away from the frontline than you can with Segments, saving real estate.

Describe the changes you want to propose. Include possible alternatives.

One possible solution: Include a high-tier unit that fires powerful artillery shots at a very slow rate. Then players can place Segments in the back to cover those without wasting fire rate on small bullets.

here-be-username commented 4 years ago

Toxopid: Am I a joke to you?

Adding something that segment can counter isn't really a good fix. There are other ways to fix segment, such as allowing it to hit multiple bullets at once, extending it's range slightly, and/or allowing it to hit units (If you can blow a bullet out of the sky, why can't you hit a unit that's much bigger and slower?).

github-actions[bot] commented 3 years ago

This suggestion is now stale, and will be automatically closed.