Technical review + design review before publication: " "Public opinion should be suspended until further report": A Data-Assisted Analysis of International Newspaper Coverage of the Explosion of the USS <i>Maine</i> (1898)"

[inactinique]

PID = aADj3Ljjqti2

https://github.com/jdh-observer/aADj3Ljjqti2

[eliselavy]

https://github.com/jdh-observer/aADj3Ljjqti2/pull/3#issuecomment-2124505480

[eliselavy]

Should be the moment to promote archive url, problem can not find it

https://web.archive.org/web/20240000000000*/https://hndm.iib.unam.mx/consulta/publicacion/visualizar/558a33207d1ed64f16908db9/

Some Mexican Herald avaialble https://web.archive.org/web/20240324142553/https://hndm.iib.unam.mx/consulta/publicacion/visualizar/558075be7d1e63c9fea1a34d

but not for the year requested: 17 February 1898

[eliselavy]

Go to send to copy-editing Need to fix problme conversion ipynb => tex= > word

doesn't support plotly output

    \begin{Verbatim}[commandchars=\\\{\}]
<pandas.io.formats.style.Styler at 0x7fa148f8f350>
    \end{Verbatim}

[eliselavy]

Send to copy-editing

[eliselavy]

@biumiamy no copy -editing to add (from andy: This article has no changes, it can go to the next stage.) review design can be done take care of anchor if there are

• Desanonomization need to be done - no ORCID - no Institution provided
• Copyright?
• Cover image

[eliselavy]

Should be the moment to promote archive url, problem can not find it

https://web.archive.org/web/20240000000000*/https://hndm.iib.unam.mx/consulta/publicacion/visualizar/558a33207d1ed64f16908db9/

Some Mexican Herald avaialble https://web.archive.org/web/20240324142553/https://hndm.iib.unam.mx/consulta/publicacion/visualizar/558075be7d1e63c9fea1a34d

but not for the year requested: 17 February 1898

available: figure 8 available

[eliselavy]

@biumiamy no copy -editing to add (from andy: This article has no changes, it can go to the next stage.) review design can be done take care of anchor if there are

• Desanonomization need to be done - no ORCID - no Institution provided
• Copyright?

Email has been sent to request copyright / cover / validation contributors

[biumiamy]

"(as can be seen in table 2-8)" Does the author mean from table 2 to 8?

because then he tags this as an anchor.. but this table doesnt exist.

So.. I will just tag/anchor table 2?

[biumiamy]

• added the anchor tag in the tables and figures to connect to the anchor in the text: https://github.com/jdh-observer/aADj3Ljjqti2/compare/update-anchors?expand=1

once its merged, let me know, I can test it

[eliselavy]

@biumiamy merge

[inactinique]

AUthors send an email stating that the latest version was there: https://github.com/mpriewe/repo_article_maine

[eliselavy]

AUthors send an email stating that the latest version was there: https://github.com/mpriewe/repo_article_maine

ok copyright added

@inactinique tweet + signed copyright to collect @biumiamy socialmedia cover

[biumiamy]

added social media cover: https://github.com/jdh-observer/aADj3Ljjqti2/blob/main/socialmediacover.png

[biumiamy]

I just saw this: need to delete "keyword" on the first tag

[inactinique]

added the cover image.

[eliselavy]

added the cover image. lost javascript

fixed now

better to do a pull request and asking review , when we are on this stage , as everything has been controlled problem javascript , notebook needs to be trusted and consolidation with the md

report didn't help has no detection....

[eliselavy]

need to adjust cover

[eliselavy]

ok skim-article used here

[eliselavy]

1) After seeing how our cover image looks in the article, we have decided to change it, if possible. I have copied the new image, which is much more fitting than the current one, below as well. Since my assistant doesn’t have access to your repository, would it be possible for you to change the cover image? Or should we do that in „our“ version and you’ll synchronize them again?

2) I have also noticed that the affiliation of my co-author Adán Lerma-Mayer has not been updated to "Universidad Anáhuac“ yet. We had made that change on June 11 in our version. Could you please check that this will be displayed correctly in the final version or advise us in which file to make that change?

---

• affiliation updated
• cover image changed
• citation generated in dev

to be put in production , needs to have a description for Varia @inactinique , see here https://github.com/C2DH/journal-of-digital-history-pm/issues/36#issuecomment-2205605820

here the version:

[eliselavy]

@inactinique in prod - tag new added - just need to put publish status if you want to send for validation to the author

[inactinique]

It does not have the 'publish' status, but is seeable there: https://journalofdigitalhistory.org/en/article/aADj3Ljjqti2 Even if not connected. Can I send that to authors? Best, Frédéric

[eliselavy]

It does not have the 'publish' status, but is seeable there: https://journalofdigitalhistory.org/en/article/aADj3Ljjqti2 Even if not connected. Can I send that to authors? Best, Frédéric

because you have the direct url otherwise not visible but maybe you need also to reinforce the authentication at the level of the article also

you can send them the url like that or set status publish in the admin or i do it if you validate

[inactinique]

Yes of course, but I can then send the direct URL to authors and we don't need to publish it yet (we can wait that the three first articles of the varia to publish them at the same time, or the to first).

[inactinique]

And the tweets, once it's published:

"Delving into the archives: Our digital humanities project analyzes the initial global newspaper reactions to the USS Maine explosion in 1898. Discover how media shaped the prelude to the Spanish-American War. #DigitalHumanities #HistoricalMedia" "Join us in exploring how digital tools enhance our understanding of historical media biases. Our latest study on the USS Maine explosion uses quantitative analysis to trace certain discursive constructions of the event across countries. #DigitalHumanities #MediaStudies" "How did newspapers from seven different countries report the USS Maine explosion in 1898? Our digital humanities research employs statistical and close reading methods to uncover biases in historical journalism. #DigitalHumanities #TransnationalJournalism" "Our digital humanities research provides a new perspective on the USS Maine explosion through a data-assisted analysis of international newspaper coverage. See how different narratives influenced the lead-up to the Spanish-American War. #DigitalHumanities #History" "Unpacking the role of media in shaping public opinion during historical events: Our study on the USS Maine explosion uses digital archives to analyze coverage in seven countries. Insights into media influence and bias. #DigitalHumanities #MediaHistory"

[eliselavy]

And the tweets, once it's published:

"Delving into the archives: Our digital humanities project analyzes the initial global newspaper reactions to the USS Maine explosion in 1898. Discover how media shaped the prelude to the Spanish-American War. #DigitalHumanities #HistoricalMedia" "Join us in exploring how digital tools enhance our understanding of historical media biases. Our latest study on the USS Maine explosion uses quantitative analysis to trace certain discursive constructions of the event across countries. #DigitalHumanities #MediaStudies" "How did newspapers from seven different countries report the USS Maine explosion in 1898? Our digital humanities research employs statistical and close reading methods to uncover biases in historical journalism. #DigitalHumanities #TransnationalJournalism" "Our digital humanities research provides a new perspective on the USS Maine explosion through a data-assisted analysis of international newspaper coverage. See how different narratives influenced the lead-up to the Spanish-American War. #DigitalHumanities #History" "Unpacking the role of media in shaping public opinion during historical events: Our study on the USS Maine explosion uses digital archives to analyze coverage in seven countries. Insights into media influence and bias. #DigitalHumanities #MediaHistory"

perfect - there were already attached https://github.com/jdh-observer/aADj3Ljjqti2/blob/main/tweets.md

[eliselavy]

Integration last changes

[eliselavy]

READY TO PUBLISH