Carter-Center-Health-Data-Support-Unit / CC-RB-LF-SCH-DASHBOARD

0 stars 0 forks source link

Dam Workers & Refugees #14

Open zacka-cartercenter opened 1 year ago

zacka-cartercenter commented 1 year ago

We need to decide on a final classification for dam worker and refugees

1. Dam Workers:

Admin 3 level reporting

From May 2019 onwards data has been collected at the admin 3 level

adm1_name adm2_name adm3_name
ben gumuz dam_workers (metekel) NA

Admin 2 level reporting

Prior to May 2019 only adm2 was collected and was collected as "dam_workers (metekel)"

Therefore, we need to decide on how to classify them so they are aggregated in the desired manner. We should have adm1_name, adm2_name, and adm3_name for ward level data and just adm1_name, and adm2_name for the zone/adm2 level data... As dam workers (metekel) are probably in metekel we could call admin 2 metekel, but then when the data is aggregated to admin 2 the dam workers and other metekel district data will be combined which may not be desired...

Proposed adm3 level: adm1_name adm2_name adm3_name
ben gumuz dam_workers (metekel) dam_workers (metekel)
Proposed adm2 level: adm1_name adm2_name
ben gumuz dam_workers (metekel)

2. Refugees

May 2019 onwards we have adm1_name adm2_name adm3_name
gambella refugees_gambella NA
gambella refugees (7 camps) NA

before may 2019 we just have adm2_name = "refugees (gambella)"

Therefore, if we want to keep refugees (gambella) & refugees (7 camps) distinct in the aggregations we could do the following for the ward level data:

adm1_name adm2_name adm3_name
gambella refugees (gambella) refugees (gambella)
gambella refugees (7 camps) refugees (7 camps)

and for zone/adm2 level data we can do:

adm1_name adm2_name
gambella refugees (gambella)

Not sure if pre may 2010 we were in the "7 camps" location. If so when aggregating post may 2019 to admin 2 we might want to combine both refugee classifications and keep the distinction only at ward level in that case we would want our classifications to look like

adm 3 level

adm1_name adm2_name adm3_name
gambella refugees refugees (gambella)
gambella refugees refugees (7 camps)

adm2 level

adm1_name adm2_name
gambella refugees
zacka-cartercenter commented 1 year ago

Actually after reviewing https://github.com/Carter-Center-Health-Data-Support-Unit/CC-RB-LF-SCH-DASHBOARD/issues/11#issue-1525021212 I realized that adm2 for gambela refugees is already recommended as "agnewak". Therefore I think the admins should be harmonized to the table below

adm0_pcode adm1_en adm1_pcode adm2_en adm2_pcode adm3_en adm3_pcode adm_1_2_3
et gambela et_12 agnewak et_1202 refugees et_1202_cc01 gambela_agnewak_refugees
et gambela et_12 agnewak et_1202 refugees (7 camps) et_1202_cc02 gambela_agnewak_refugees (7 camps)
et benishangul_gumz et_06 metekel et_0602 dam_workers et_0602_cc01 benishangul_gumz_metekel_dam_workers
zacka-cartercenter commented 1 year ago

pretty sure refugees and refugees (7 camps) are the same