DCC-EX / Support-Planning

DCC++EX Repo to hold project planning documentation and processes
1 stars 1 forks source link

Ticket Submitted via Website #795

Open fire-bot opened 4 hours ago

fire-bot commented 4 hours ago

Sent by (dccextended@gmail.com). Created by fire.


Mike created a ticket

Name: Mike Detheridge

Email: mikedetheridge1@gmail.com

Timezone: 0

Software: EX-CommandStation

Version: 4.0.x

Title: Turn out commands

Description: I am trying to operate a turnout decoder provided by rails of Sheffield but designed by DCC Concepts Ltd. I am having success with my own computer operated controller operating trains with sound OK. But the turnout controller does not work although I am getting success messages back when I send instructions. DCC Concepts ask if I am using NMRA DCC compliant address commands. Could you please tell me if the commands in the turnout section of your documentation is NMRA compliant? Unlike your documentation when I search the NMRA material I am just confused! Thanks

Remaining email Quota: 99

Ash-4 commented 2 hours ago

There can be some confusion when sending turnout commands to DCC connected turnouts. The log from the serial monitor should show what commands are being sent/received. Are you sending DCC accessory commands <a ....> or are you sending DCC-EX turnout commands <T ...> .. either can be used. If you are sending DCC-EX turnout commands, then the turnout will need to be defined. We recommend defining them in myAutomation.h, where descriptions can be included. https://dcc-ex.com/ex-rail/EX-RAIL-command-reference.html#turnout-id-addr-sub-addr-description-define-a-dcc-accessory-turnout-point

Another method to define turnouts: https://dcc-ex.com/reference/software/command-reference.html#defining-setting-up-a-turnout-point

You may benefit from an interactive discussion on the DCC-EX discord server. https://dcc-ex.com/support/index.html#preferred-option-discord