Cannot create FQDN Node using SDK

[kblankenship11]

When I use the following code to create a node on the F5:

from f5.bigip import ManagementRoot mgmt = ManagementRoot(big_ip, big_ip_user, big_ip_pass) ltm = mgmt.tm.ltm ltm.nodes.node.create(partition="Common", name="192.168.10.10", description="Created by Python")

I get the following error: f5.sdk_exception.MissingRequiredCreationParameter: Missing required params: ['address']

However in the iControl API reference (https://devcentral.f5.com/Wiki/iControlREST.APIRef_tm_ltm_node.ashx) it states that the 'address' parameter is optional; "IP address of the node. This is an optional field; if empty, the name needs to be of the form ip address".

When I try to create an FQDN node with the Python SDK, i.e.:

ltm.nodes.node.create(partition="Common", name="fqdnnode.test", description="Created by Python", fqdn={'addressFamily': 'ipv4', 'downInterval': '5', 'interval': '3600', 'tmName': arg.lower()}))

It looks for the 'address' parameter--when I don't provide it, I get this error: f5.sdk_exception.MissingRequiredCreationParameter: Missing required params: ['address']

This is a problem because even if I force my code to provide an FQDN as the 'address' the SDK won't let me because it checks that it's an IP address or not:

icontrol.exceptions.iControlUnexpectedHTTPError: 400 Unexpected Error: Bad Request for uri: https://10.23.129.132:443/mgmt/tm/ltm/node/ Text: '{"code":400,"message":"Invalid IP address: \"testnode.test\"","errorStack":[],"apiError":26214401}'

So basically I can't create an FQDN node with the Python SDK, or create an IPv4 node without providing both the name and address parameters.

[jasonrahm]

So we need to support the exclusive attributes of address or fqdn on create. It doesn't appear I can update a node via REST, is that your experience?

[kblankenship11]

I haven't actually tried that myself with REST directly, so I'm not sure. I submitted a case to F5 support with this issue--and they led me here. This was their consensus:

"Engineering Services notes that the Python SDK is expecting address to be set to "any6" when configuring a fqdn node."

[jasonrahm]

If I set it at all when using fqdn I get an error. I'll work on this this weekend

[jasonrahm]

it's definitely possible currently as shown below, but a little wonky since the SDK requires the address but the REST API does not:

>>> n1 = b.tm.ltm.nodes.node.create(name='192.168.10.10', partition='Common', address='192.168.10.10')
>>> n2 = b.tm.ltm.nodes.node.create(name='fqdn1', partition='Common', fqdn={'tmName':'fqdn1.test.local'})
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "<input>", line 1, in <module>
  File "/Users/rahm/Documents/PycharmProjects/f5-common-python/f5/bigip/resource.py", line 1053, in create
    return self._create(**kwargs)
  File "/Users/rahm/Documents/PycharmProjects/f5-common-python/f5/bigip/resource.py", line 1001, in _create
    self._check_create_parameters(**kwargs)
  File "/Users/rahm/Documents/PycharmProjects/f5-common-python/f5/bigip/resource.py", line 966, in _check_create_parameters
    raise MissingRequiredCreationParameter(error_message)
f5.sdk_exception.MissingRequiredCreationParameter: Missing required params: ['address']
>>> n2 = b.tm.ltm.nodes.node.create(name='fqdn1', partition='Common', fqdn={'tmName':'fqdn1.test.local'}, address='any6')
>>> b.tm.ltm.nodes.node.exists(name='192.168.10.10')
True
>>> b.tm.ltm.nodes.node.exists(name='fqdn1')
True

It looks like all we have to do is require either address or fqdn to make the experience better. But for now, there is a workaround.

[jasonrahm]

To clarify from the larger message above, the way you can create the fqdn node with the sdk is to provide the address as any6 in addition to specifying the fqdn:

n2 = b.tm.ltm.nodes.node.create(name='fqdn1',
         partition='Common',
         fqdn={'tmName':'fqdn1.test.local'},
         address='any6')

[jasonrahm]

I've updated node resource to only allow address or fqdn, and resulting successes with one or the other and then the error when both are supplied will look like this:

>>> n2 = b.tm.ltm.nodes.node.create(name='fqdn3', partition='Common', fqdn={'tmName':'fqdn3.test.local'})
>>> n1 = b.tm.ltm.nodes.node.create(name='192.168.10.100', address='192.168.10.100')
>>> n1 = b.tm.ltm.nodes.node.create(name='192.168.10.100', address='any6', fqdn={'tmName':'fqdn23.test.local'})
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "<input>", line 1, in <module>
  File "/Users/rahm/Documents/PycharmProjects/f5-common-python/f5/bigip/tm/ltm/node.py", line 71, in create
    raise RequiredOneOf(required_one_of)
f5.sdk_exception.RequiredOneOf: Creation requires one of the following lists of args ( name,address ) or ( name,fqdn )

Acceptable? If so, I'll get tests written for this change this weekend and submit PR

[kblankenship11]

Yes, that is exactly what I was looking for!

[jasonrahm]

This has been merged to development and will be in the next dot release. Closing issue.