Mistakes in scores

[Mick1303]

This is the thread for score discrepancies:

In 2021 tokyo Olympics you have 3 matches where tie-break scores are missing. Winner;Loser;Round;Score Pablo Carreno-Busta; Dominik Koepfer;R16;7-6(7) 6-3 Ilya Ivashka; Mikhail Kukushkin;R32;6-7(4) 6-3 6-3 Marcos Giron; Norbert Gombos,R64;7-6(4) 3-6 6-2

In Wimbledon 21 in the score for Otte-Rinderknech in R128 final set tb score is missing. Shall be 4-6,6-3,6-2,6-7(5),13-12(2).

In Wimbledon 19 in the score for Djokovic-Federer the final tb score is missing. Shall be 7-6(5),1-6,7-6(4),4-6,13-12(3)

In RG 2020 R32 Grigor Dimitrov - Carballes Baena shall say 6-1,6-3;ret. rather than 6-1,6-3,0-0.

Davis Cup WG PO 2012: BRA vs RUS: Rogerio Dutra Silva-Igor Andreev shall say 6-2,6-1;ret. rather than 6-2,6-1,0-0.

Davis Cup WG R1: GER vs ESP 2014 Feliciano Lopez- Philipp Kohlschreiber DC site says w/o rather than 0-0 (latter implies that the play started).

In RG 2020 R32 Stefanos Tsitsipas - Bedene "Ret." is missing in the score.

It will be a low priority thread, because generally I'm switching to WTA syncing. But from time to time I will revisit this one.

[Mick1303]

In RG 2019 you have 25(!) cases of wrong scores. I was checking against ATP, but I usually import tournaments from SteveGTennis and my scores were in alighnment with ATP (meaning I have 2 sources in agreement). All these incorrect scores are related to TBs. I.e you have R128 Zverev- Millman as 7-6(4),6-3,2-6,6-7(7),6-3, while ATP has it 7-6(4),6-3,2-6,6-7(5),6-3. Also R128 for Kecmanovic- Kudla, Bublik- Molleker and others. Highest round is R16 Nishikori-Paire. You have 6-2,6-7(10),6-2,6-7(10),7-5, while ATP has 6-2,6-7(8),6-2,6-7(8),7-5. Rather than list all incorrect scores I recommend just re-import this toirnament from ATP site. Mostly the scores are off by 2 points. I suspect they erroneously put tb scores of winners there and later fixed it.

[Mick1303]

Oz Open 2016 is missing all TB scores in your DB - total of 64 matches. ATP site (https://www.atptour.com/en/scores/archive/australian-open/580/2016/results) has complete scores.

[Mick1303]

There are discrepancy in some scores in the ITF (wiki) version and ATP version of Canadian Open 2000. For instance Kafelnikov-Vicente ITF has 7-5,3-6,7-6(0), while ATP - 6-4,3-6,7-6(0). Novak-Dosedel ITF has 7-6(4),6-3, while ATP - 7-6(4),6-2. In this instance I'm more inclined to believe ITF/wiki, because ATP has even invalid score Grosjean-Hewitt 7-6(0),6-3(5). ITF has it 6-3,7-6(5). Also Safin-Sampras ITF has 6-4,3-6,7-6(8), while ATP - 6-4,3-6,7-6(10). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_du_Maurier_Open_%E2%80%93_Men%27s_singles

[Mick1303]

In 2001 US Open R128 Gimelstob - Tabara the score is not right. If you count sets it looks like Gimelstob lost. 4th set is reversed. Shall be 6-4

[Mick1303]

in 2000 Stockholm draw QF Grosjean - Schuettler 6-7,5-7,7-6(5) the score is incorrect. The winner won less sets. Correct score is 6-1,5-7,7-6(5) (see ITF site)

[Mick1303]

2007 Acapulco. Moya- Hartfield 4-6 6-1 4-6. This is incorrect, winner lost more sets. Shall be 4-6,6-1,6-4

[Mick1303]

2007 Memphis. 3 matches with incomplete scores miss "retired" mark. The same for 2 matches in 2007 Marseille. Overall there is too many to list all of those on ATP site. Probably some automation shall be applied to fix this. If the match ends with irregular score in sets (like 4-1 etc.) or if the number of sets does not add up - put "retired' in the end. Maybe some of them shall have 'default" rather than "retired", but in any case you will be left with much smaller pool of discrepancies.

[Mick1303]

Error copied from ATP site: Copenhagen 2000. Pozzi - Liukko R16 score 6-3,3-6(4),6-4 is invalid. ITF has 6-3,3-6,6-4

[Mick1303]

Error copied from ATP site: Memphis 2000. Salzenstein - Fredrik Jonsson score 7-6,6-1(4) is invalid. Shall be 7-6(5),6-1

[Mick1303]

Error copied from ATP site: Hertogenbosch 1999. Rafter-Carlsen.- 6-3,6-4(8) is invalid. ITF has just 6-3,6-4.

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Sofia 1981 R32. Dupasquier- Parrini ATP has w/o. ITF has 6-4,6-3.

[Mick1303]

In 1982 Queen's Club you have 4 matches with funny sets 1-08, 1-19. Shall be 10-8 and 11-9.

[Mick1303]

In Vienna 1981 you have R32 Potier-Glickstein with unknown score. ATP has it 1-6,6-1,7-5

In Geneva 1981 you have R32 Gunthardt-Pirow with invalid score 6-6,2-7,5-0. ATP has it 1-6,6-2,7-5

[Mick1303]

In Sofia 1980 you have SF Hjertquist-Pugayev with invalid score 7-6,6-5. ATP has it 7-6,6-4

In Guaruja 1981 you have R32 Pfister-Lopez-Maeso with invalid score 6-3,3-6,6-0,NA. ATP has it just 6-3,3-6,6-0

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of US Open 1979 R128. Smid-Scanlon ATP has 6-3,6-3,2-6,6-3. ITF has 6-3,6-3,2-6,3-6,6-3

[js] moved this to the Unresolved Discrepancies thread

[Mick1303]

Bogota 1978 (tid 1978-359). ATP has results for 4 matches that you have as unknown score.

[Mick1303]

You have 1977 Madrid R64 Lloyd-Richardson with a score 6-3,7-5 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:6-3,7-6 Also R64 Smid-Castanon with a score 6-0,6-0. ATP has:6-0,6-2

[Mick1303]

In 1977 Tournament of Champions WCT in the final you (and ATP) have Solomon-Rosewall with a score 4-1 in sets (6-5,6-2,2-6,6-0,6-3). I have it 5-6,6-2,2-6,6-0,6-3. Don't remember where I imported it from (maybe ITF but now they don't have it). Interestingly TennisArchives has a 3rd variation of the score 6-5,6-2,2-6,0-6,6-3.

[js] can't find the score reported in the newspapers, which is shocking, because apparently it was televised across the US. I guess I'll go with what TennisArchives has until we can find something more definitive.

[Mick1303]

You have 1977 Louisville R64 Spear-Betancur with a score 6-3,5-7,6-3 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:6-3,5-7,6-1

[Mick1303]

You have 1977 Las Vegas SF Connors-Hewitt with a score 6-2,7-6 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:6-3,7-5 also here you have R32 Connors-Bengtson with a score 6-2,5-7,6-3 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:6-2,5-7,6-2 also here you have R16 Dibley-Laver with a score 6-4,3-6,6-3 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:6-4,3-6,6-2 also here you have R32 Edmondson-Tanner with a score 4-6,6-4,6-2 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:4-6,6-4,6-3 also here you have R16 Fillol-sr-Lutz with a score 6-4,6-1 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:7-6,6-1 also here you have R32 Hewitt-Dent with a score 3-6,6-4,7-6 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:2-6,6-4,7-5 also here you have QF Ramirez-Fillol-sr with a score 6-4,6-3 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:6-4,6-2 also here you have R32 Rosewall-Pasarell with a score 6-4,7-5 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:6-4,7-6 ITF has the same scores as ATP.

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Palm Springs 1977 R16. Scanlon-Case. ATP has 6-4,6-2. ITF has 6-3,7-5. Your result 6-3,7-6 is different from both.

[js] ATP score confirmed in the Palm Springs newspaper the following day

[Mick1303]

You have San Francisco 1976 R32 Tanner-Pasarell with a score 6-2,7-5. ATP has 6-3,7-6. ITF has 6-2,7-6

[js] LA Times (among many others) has 6-3 7-6

[Mick1303]

You have US Open 1976 R16 Kodes-McMillan with a score 7-6,6-3,2-6,7-6. ATP has 6-4,7-6,2-6,7-6. ITF has 7-6,6-4,2-6,7-6 R32 Orantes-Stone you have 6-2,6-2. Both ATP & ITF have it 6-2,6-4 R64 Richey-Gottfried you have 6-1,6-2. Both ATP & ITF have it 6-0,6-2

[js] NY Times confirms ATP's score for Kodes-McMillan of 6-4,7-6,2-6,7-6

[Mick1303]

You have 1976 Wimbledon QF Nastase-Pasarell with a score 6-4,6-3,6-3 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:6-4,6-2,6-3 also here you have R128 Reid-Molina with a score 6-4,5-7,6-3 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:6-4,5-7,6-3,6-4 also here you have R128 Meiler-Cahill with a score 6-8,7-9,3-6,6-4 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:6-8,9-7,3-6,6-3,6-4 also here you have R128 Stone-Yuill with a score 6-4,4-6,6-1 that differs from ATP site. ATP has:6-4,4-6,6-1,6-3. ITF has the same scores as ATP.

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Las Vegas 1976 R16 Moore-Pasarell. ATP has 2-6,7-5,6-3. ITF has 1-6,7-6,6-3 R32 Panatta-Rahim. ATP has 6-4,4-6,6-4. ITF has 6-0,4-6,6-4 R16 Moore-Pasarell. ATP has 4-6,6-2,7-6. ITF has 6-4,2-6,7-6. You have a score that differs from both (4-6,6-3,7-6) also here both ATP and ITF have R32 Newcombe-Van Dillen 6-2,6-3, while you have it 6-2,6-4

[js] I think you mean Tanner-Gorman as the third match (where I have 4-6 6-3 7-6) ... Tanner-Gorman is 4-6 6-2 7-6, Moore-Pasarell is 2-6 7-5 6-3, Panatta-Rahim is 6-4 6-4, per the LA Times

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Barcelona 1976 (tid 1976-278): R16 Gisbert Sr-Fibak. ATP has 5-7,6-4,6-1. ITF has 5-7,6-1,6-1 ITF link: https://event.itftennis.com/itf/web/usercontrols/tournaments/tournamentprintabledrawsheets.aspx?tournamentid=1010001999&tenniscatecode=MT&eventid=1010003442 In other 3 matches ATP and ITF are in agreement, but your scores differ: You have: R32 Panatta-Benavides 6-4,6-4. ATP/ITF have 6-4,6-2 R64 Higueras-Caujolle walkover. ATP/ITF have 5-0;ret. R64 Taroczy-Kirmayr 6-3,6-3. ATP/ITF 6-2,6-3

[js] US newspapers agree with ATP on Gisbert-Fibak

[Mick1303]

You may want to re-import Palma 1976 (tid 1976-655) from ATP site. https://www.atptour.com/en/scores/archive/mallorca/655/1976/results. All unknown results are fixed there.

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Hampton 1976 SF Nastase-Martin ATP has 6-3,6-1. ITF has 7-6,6-2 SF Connors-Dibley ATP has 6-4,7-6. ITF has 6-1,6-4 R16 Pecci Sr.-Gerulaitis ATP has 6-7,2-1;def.. ITF has 6-7;ret. R16 Dibley-Parun ATP has 2-6,7-6,6-4. ITF has 3-6,7-6,6-4 ITF link:https://www.itftennis.com/en/tournament/hampton/usa/1976/m-gp-usa-15a-1976/draws-and-results/ also here you have R16 Nastase-Lewis as 6-2,6-3, while both ITF and ATP have 6-3,6-3

[js] Dibley-Parun is 2-6 7-6(0) 6-4 ... Pecci-Gerulaitis is 6-7(4) 2-1 RET ... Connors-Dibley is 6-4 7-6(4) ... Nastase-Martin, the local paper has 6-4 6-1

[Mick1303]

You (and ATP) have WCT Challenge Cup 1976 RR Newcombe-Ramirez with a strange score 6-4,6-1,3-6,5-7,6-2;ret..

[js] it's 3-2 RET in the 5th

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Salisbury 1976 R32 S.Mayer-Lewis ATP has 6-3,4-6,6-3. ITF has 6-3,4-6,6-4 also here you have SF Connors-Mayer, S as 6-7,6-3,6-4,6-2, while ITF has it 6-7,6-3,4-6,6-4,6-2 and ATP has 6-7,6-3,3-6,6-4,6-2 also here you have R64 Estep-McNair as 6-7,6-1,6-1, while both ITF and ATP have 6-7,6-1,6-4

[js] newspapers confirm ATP on the two discrepancies -- Connors-Mayer is 6-7(2) 6-3 3-6 6-4 6-2

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Indianapolis WCT 1976 QF Gerulaitis-Drysdale ATP has 7-6(4),6-4. ITF has 7-6(4),6-1. You have a 3rd version of the score 7-6(4),6-3.

[js] local paper confirms my 7-6 6-3

[Mick1303]

You have Australian Open 1976 R16 Case-Pasarell with a score 6-3,6-3,6-4. ATP/ITF have 6-3,6-3,4-6,6-7,7-5 also here you have R16 Rosewall-Ball with a score 6-3,7-6,6-0. ATP/ITF have 3-6,7-6,6-0,6-4 also here you have R32 Warwick-Marten with a score 6-4,6-7,6-4,6-3. ATP has it 6-4,6-2,6-1, while ITF has 6-4,6-3,4-6,6-3 also here you have R32 Hagelauer-Masters with a score 6-4,6-1,4-6,5-7,7-6. ATP/ITF have 6-1,6-4,5-7,6-7,6-4 also here you have R32 Ruffels-Giltinan with a score 6-4,7-6,6-4. ATP/ITF have 6-4,6-7,4-6,6-2,6-2 also here you have R32 Drewett-Stone with a score 6-3,6-4,4-6,7-5. ATP/ITF have 6-3,3-6,4-6,6-2,6-3 also here you have R32 Ball-Coghlan with a score 6-2,6-4,6-7,6-3. ATP/ITF have 6-4,6-7,6-3,6-2 also here you have R64 Carter-Busby with a score 6-2,6-3,3-6,6-2. ATP/ITF have 6-3,6-3,3-6,6-2 also here you have R64 Little-McNamara with a score 6-1,6-1,6-4. ATP/ITF have 6-1,1-6,4-6,6-4,7-5 also here you have R64 Marten-Soares with a score 7-6,6-1,6-2. ATP has it 7-6,6-1,6-3, while ITF has 6-4,6-3,6-4 also here you have R64 Edmondson-Feigl with a score 1-6,6-4,6-7,6-4,6-1. ATP/ITF have 6-1,4-6,7-6,4-6,6-1 also here you have R64 Crealy-Smith, J with a score 6-4,7-5,7-6. ATP/ITF have 4-6,7-5,7-6,7-5 also here you (and ATP) have R64 Coghlan-Bartlett with a score 3-6,2-6,6-3,6-2,6-4. ITF has it 4-6,2-6,6-4,6-2,6-4

[js] US papers have Marten d Soares 7-6 6-1 6-3 ... LA Times agrees with ITF on Warwick-Marten ... can't find anything on Coghlan-Bartlett so I'll stick with ATP for now

[Mick1303]

You have Boston 1975 SF Vilas-Ashe with a score 4-6,6-0,6-3,6-4. ATP and ITF both have it 4-6,6-3,6-0,6-4 There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of QF Vilas-Laver. ATP has 6-3,6-4. ITF has 6-3,6-1. You have it the same as ATP. You have R32 Vilas-Bertolucci with a score 6-2,7-5. ATP and ITF both have it 6-3,6-4. You have R64 Stockton-Van Dillen with a score 6-3,7-6. ATP has it 6-2, 7-6, while ITF has it 6-3,7-5.

[js] ATP is correct on Vilas-Laver. ATP is also right on Stockton-Van Dillen.

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Cincinnati 1975 QF Bertram-Teacher ATP has 6-1,3-6,7-6. ITF has 6-1,3-6,7-5 also here you have R16 Teacher-Stockton with a score 1-6,7-6,6-4. ATP and ITF both have it 1-6,7-6,6-3. also here you have R64 Gullikson-Estep with invalid score 2-6,6-2,6-8. ATP and ITF both have it 2-6,6-2,6-3

[js] ATP is right on Bertram-Teacher

[Mick1303]

You have Wimbledon 1975 R128 Metreveli-Amritraj with a score 6-4,6-0,6-2. ATP and ITF both have it 6-4,6-1,6-2 also here you have R128 Parun-Fraser with a score 6-3,6-3,9-7. ATP and ITF both have it 6-3,6-2,9-7 also here you have R128 Taroczy-Robinson with a score 8-9,8-6,6-3. ATP and ITF both have it 8-9,8-6,6-3,6-4

[JeffSackmann]

up to date on this, except for the most recent few comments re: 1975.

note that I added comments (in bold) in some places above, where I resolved a discrepancy (or was unable to do so).

[Mick1303]

In Houston 1975 you have scores mixed between semi Rosewall-Solomon and the final Rosewall-Drysdale. Both ATP and ITF have semis 6-4,6-7,6-4 and the final 6-3,3-6,6-1.

[Mick1303]

Re-import Florence 1975 from ATP. They have all scores from quarters and forth.

[Mick1303]

You have Monte Carlo WCT 1975 R32 Orantes-Franulovic with a score 6-2,6-1. ATP and ITF both have it 6-4,6-1 also here you have R32 Dominguez-Pilic with a score 6-4,6-7(5);ret.. ATP and ITF both have it 6-4,6-7,2-0;ret. ATP has the same TB score as you. I put 6-4,6-7(5),2-0;ret. as a final result in my DB.

I think I shall separate the mistakes in scores from the discrepancies, when both versions look valid. I will continue to put mistakes here and create a separate thread for ITF/ATP discrepancies.

[Mick1303]

Re-import Cairo 1975 from ATP. They have all scores from quarters and forth.

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Hong Kong 1975 R16 Gisbert Sr-Orantes ATP has 6-3,6-3. ITF has 6-3,6-2 also here both ATP&ITF have: QF Gottfried-Newcombe 6-3,4-6,6-3, while you have it 6-4,4-6,6-3

[js] ATP is right on Gisbert-Orantes

[Mick1303]

You have Basel 1975 F Hrebec-Nastase with a score 6-1,7-6,2-6,6-4. ATP and ITF both have it 6-1,7-6,2-6,6-3.

[Mick1303]

You have Roanoke 1975 R32 Tiriac-Austin with unknown score. ATP has 6-7,6-3,7-6.

[Mick1303]

Australian Open 1975 (December 1974) strangely has an empty page on ATP site ATM. There are discrepancies in our data: You have R64 Thomson-Prineas 4-6,3-6,?-?. ITF and Wiki have it 6-4,6-3,6-3. You have R16 Roche-McNamara 4-6,7-5,6-2,6-3 (same as Wiki). ITF has it 6-7,7-5,6-2,6-3 You have R32 Stone-James Sr. 6-4,7-6,6-7,8-6 (same as Wiki). ITF has it 6-3,7-5,6-7,8-6

[js] ATP player pages have scores from this tournament (e.g. https://www.atptour.com/en/players/allan-stone/s148/player-activity?year=1975 ), and they agree with ITF for each of these.

[Mick1303]

You have Stockholm 1974 R32 Riessen-Andersson with invalid score 6-1,6-3,6-4 (shall be bof3). ATP has 6-1,3-6,6-4 also you have R54 Okker-Johansson with invalid score 5-7,7-6,7-4. ATP has 5-7,7-6,6-4

[Mick1303]

You have Hilversum 1974 R32 Kamiwazumi-Andrew with incomplete score 6-1,4-6. ATP has it 6-1,4-6,7-5

[Mick1303]

You have Wimbledon 1974 R128 Johansson-Gerken with invalid score 7-9,6-3,6-2,6-1,14-12. ATP has it 7-9,3-6,6-2,6-1,14-12

[Mick1303]

You have Roland Garros 1974 R16 Pohmann-Dibbs with a score 6-3,6-3,4-6,6-3. ATP and ITF both have it 6-3,6-3,4-6,6-4 also here you have R32 Nastase-Goven 6-4,6-2,7-6, while both ATP and ITF have it 6-3,7-5,6-4 also here you have R32 Koch-Sakai 6-1,6-7,4-6,6-4,6-4, while both ATP and ITF have it 6-1,6-7,4-6,6-1,6-4 also here you and ATP have R32 Ramirez-Proisy as unknown score, while ITF has it 6-4,6-4,4-6,6-3 also here you have R64 Barthes-Hrebec 6-2,6-1, while both ATP and ITF have it 6-2,6-2 for R64 Fassbender-Kamiwazumi ATP has 6-2,7-6, while ITF has 6-1,7-6 also here you have R64 Amritraj, Vijay-McNair 7-5,3-6,6-3, while both ATP and ITF have it 7-6,3-6,6-3 for R128 Franulovic-Laimina ATP has 4-6,7-5,7-5, while ITF has 3-6,7-5,7-5 for R128 Riessen-Kary ATP has 1-6,6-4,6-3, while ITF has 4-6,6-4,6-3

[js] newspapers support ATP for Fassbender and Riessen, and agree with ITF for Franulovic

[Mick1303]

You have Bournemouth 1974 F Nastase-Bertolucci with a score 6-1,6-3,6-0. ATP and ITF both have it 6-1,6-3,6-2 also here you have R32 Kronk-Panatta 4-6,6-4,6-2, while both ATP and ITF have it 4-6,6-4,6-3

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Dusseldorf 1976 R32 Fillol-sr-Hrebec ATP has 6-2,6-1. ITF has 6-3,6-1 R64 Fairlie-Yuill ATP has 7-6,6-3. ITF has 3-6,6-2,6-2 In the same tournament both ITF and ATP have R64 Pala-Bengtson as 6-3,6-1. You have it 6-3,3-6,6-1

[js] a newspaper report says Fairlie-Yuill was 7-6 6-3. I can't find anything for Fillol-Hrebec.